scientific standards - zfifteen/unified-framework GitHub Wiki
Scientific methodology and standards for Z Framework research.
This document outlines the scientific standards and methodological requirements for research conducted within the Z Framework project.
- Statistical Significance: p < 0.05 with multiple testing corrections
- Effect Size Reporting: Cohen's d and confidence intervals required
- Reproducibility: All analyses must be independently reproducible
- Sample Size: Power analysis for adequate sample sizes
- Proof Requirements: Formal mathematical proofs for theoretical claims
- Computational Validation: Cross-validation across multiple implementations
- Precision Standards: High-precision arithmetic (mpmath dps=50) for critical calculations
- Error Analysis: Comprehensive error propagation analysis
- Data Integrity: Verified data sources and preprocessing protocols
- Version Control: Complete version tracking for datasets and analysis
- Documentation: Comprehensive metadata and provenance tracking
- Validation: Independent verification of data quality
- Internal Review: Technical review by framework maintainers
- External Review: Independent review by domain experts
- Community Review: Open review process for major claims
- Revision Process: Iterative improvement based on feedback
- Complete Methodology: Detailed description of all procedures
- Statistical Analysis: Full statistical analysis protocols
- Limitations: Clear acknowledgment of limitations and assumptions
- Reproducibility: Complete instructions for reproduction
- Transparency: Open disclosure of methods and potential conflicts
- Attribution: Proper attribution of contributions and prior work
- Collaboration: Respectful and inclusive collaboration practices
- Integrity: Honest reporting of results including negative findings
- Multiple Validation: Independent validation by multiple researchers
- Cross-Platform Testing: Validation across different computational environments
- Long-term Monitoring: Ongoing validation of published results
- Community Verification: Open community verification processes
- Regular Updates: Regular review and updating of standards
- Community Input: Integration of community feedback and suggestions
- Best Practice Evolution: Adoption of emerging best practices
- Training Programs: Ongoing training in scientific methodology