Meeting 2024 01 15 - wmo-im/tt-wismd GitHub Wiki

Date/Time

Monday 15 January 2024 13h - 14h UTC

Location

MS Teams

Attendees

Team

Name Agency GitHub handle Attendance
Mr Tom KRALIDIS (Lead) MSC @tomkralidis X
Mr Guillaume AUBERT EUMETSAT @gaubert X
Mr Xinqiang HAN CMA @Amienshxq X
Ms Hanane KAMIL Météo Maroc @hananeKamil
Mr Ioannis MALLAS ECMWF tbd
Mr Ian MCDONALD EUMETSAT @McDonald-Ian
Mr Steve OLSON NOAA @solson-nws
Mr Ján OSUSKY HMEI @josusky X
Mr David PODEUR Météo-France @davidpodeur
Ms Antje SCHREMMER DWD @antje-s X
Ms Julia SIELAND DWD @jsieland X

Collaborators/Guest

Name Agency GitHub handle Attendance
Mr Masato FUJIMOTO JMA @masato-f29 X
Mr Kenji TSUNODA JMA @KenRJTD
Mr Yutaro TONOOKA JMA
Mr Kentaro JMA

WMO Secretariat

Name Agency GitHub handle Attendance
Ms Anna MILAN WMO @amilan17 X
Mr Dave Berry WMO @david-i-berry
Washington Otieno WMO X

Agenda

  • Previous meeting minutes and actions (all)
  • Secretariat updates (Anna)
  • INFCOM-3 delivery
    • WCMP2
      • Examples
      • KPI review
      • WCMP vocabularies
    • WTH
      • domain proposals
    • WNM
      • Examples
    • Final publications next steps

Notes

  • Tom opened the meeting and introduced the agenda.
  • The team review the actions from the last meeting
  • ACTION 1: (Antje) there was a point for modification of link to metadata to NOT download from the origin (Tom) I think the WIS2 Guide indicates that the GDC can update the metadata links (Antje) {{added clarification}}; (Tom wrote down the summary)
    • the problem: GC shows original WCMP2 doc with original links, GDC changes WCMP2 doc and publishes to catalog; GC still has original links;
    • solutions: Publish WCMP2 records where WNM cache=false; GDC detected cache=false; do not update links
    • (Jan) so GSs will change the WNM? (Antje) yes. Not inside the metadata record for cache=false; (Tom) noting that original intention for cache false was for data file, not metadata;
  • Secretariat updates: (Anna) focusing on prepping the specs for publication; there needs to be something ready to share with SC-IMT next week, but then there's another week to finalize the docs for INFCOM; (Tom) I'll provide an update what's come out of the SC-IMT at the next meeting;
  • WCMP2 for INFCOM-3 issues
    • examples (issue#131): (Tom) when a metadata record fails, it gets put into the 'failed' directory; (Guillaume) the centre-id failed for EUMETSAT record (Tom) added it to the centre-id; (Guillaume) other questions in PR to address if we have time; and would like to add some records for recommended data within a week; (Tom) Xingiang will you be able to update records? (Xingiang) Yes, by the end of Friday (Guillaume) there are some inconsistencies that we should probably address; (Tom) will check with Steve; (Anna) do we have parallel records for WNM records where applicable? (Tom) not yet; so we should look at the consistency across the WCMP2 and WNM records;
    • (Guillaume) What vocabulary term do I use for documentation? "describes", "describedBy"...? The team decided that 'about' might be best IANA rel type; (Guillaume) it would be good to have some basic guidance that covers most of the cases;
    • KPIs: probably ready; Anna will review for publication readiness
    • issue #19, referencing stations: (Antje) it's difficult to find the right parameters in OSCAR/surface for a FacilitySet; There are different possibilities; (Tom) predefined facility sets are not available through the API;
    • PR #144: (Julia) durations and null are in dates are not accepted and made a workaround with additionalExtents;
  • WNM for INFCOM-3
    • Issue #41 coarser resource publication example? (Guillaume) yes, I can provide an example and I think Simon is already doing that too; (Tom) this is for recommended data (NOT core data);
  • WTH for INFCOM-3
    • no outstanding issues need to be addressed for INFCOM-3
  • Next steps for final publication - (Anna) need to have something to present to SC-IMT by the end of this week, then there is another week to make final drafts; (Anna) All specs will be published in the Manual on WIS, Vol II and preparing Clause 7 for this purpose;

Actions

NOTE: ordered in priority

  • Xinqiang/Guillaume/Steve: update CMA/EUMETSAT/NOAA examples
  • Anna/Antje/Guillaume/Tom: review all WCMP2 examples for consistency between them
  • all review/create WNM examples for consistency with WCMP2 examples
  • Jan: review example snippets in WNM by 19 Jan
  • Julia: review example snippets in WCMP2 by 19 Jan
  • Tom: add "about" to [table 4 link relations selection] in the WCMP2 DONE https://github.com/wmo-im/wcmp2/pull/147
  • Tom: add issue for GDC to be able to send updated WCMP2 documents (after link injection) for publication to GB DONE: https://github.com/wmo-im/wis2-guide/issues/71
  • Guillaume: open issue for table 4 link relations selection table
  • Anna: confirm that WCMP2 KPIs are fine for publication
  • Tom: review pywcmp validation based on PR #144 results

Next meeting

2024-01-30