Work left for second public draft - w3c/wcag2ict GitHub Wiki
The following work items will need to be completed and agreed upon before we can progress to publishing the next draft. The Status column, shows where we are and what needs to be done.
Open issues
AG WG review comments
| Issue | Topic | Last TF activity Date | Status | Google doc | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Issue 266 | Thumbs down on 4.1.1 Parsing | 23 Apr. | Content changes agreed by TF, commenters reviewed and still have concerns | 4.1.1 doc | Changes incorporated into PR 338, commenter's reply on the PR. Met with commenters on 24 Apr. to discuss their concerns, resulting in an in-progress new proposal for 4.1.1. |
Issues from the TF
(2 done, 2 surveying (1 of those is reviewing the issue answer (content already done), 1 PR in progress)
| Issue | Topic | Last TF activity Date | Status | Google doc | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 329 | Use of requires or required or requiring | 3 Apr. | In progress | none | See PR |
| 145 | Add info/content on the WCAG exemptions in regulatory work | 23 Apr. | Surveying updated proposals | Issue 145 doc | See the Survey results for issue 145 first 3 questions. Previous survey results for issue 145 on PR 330 for proposed changes. Will discuss on 25 April. |
| 257 | Clarity on testing 1.4.10 Reflow on mobile devices | 23 Apr. | Changes agreed and merged, Surveying issue answer | Issue 226 doc | General guidance changes agreed and merged, survey results on draft answer to be discussed on 25 April. |
| 196 | Can a non-web software act as, or have, a conforming alternate version? | 18 Apr. | Done | none | TF decided to leave current text as-is with no changes. |
| 243 | Revisit TF decision on inclusion of WCAG intent sections | 4 Mar. | Done | none | Consensus to remove on 29 Feb., changes merged. |
Public comments (FPWD and otherwise)
Summary: 8 done, 2 changes merged and surveying issue responses, and 1 issue to go
| Issue | Topic | Last TF activity Date | Status | Google doc | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | Looking for guidance for SC 1.4.4 Resize Text on mobile native apps | 5 Dec. | Needs draft answer, possible doc change | none | Sub-group working through discussions on several topics brought up in this issue. Comment from Mary Jo indicates maybe some notes regarding platform support for resizing should be added. See also the GitHub discussion on Issue 4 |
| 221 | 1.4.10 Reflow applied to self-service terminals/kiosks | 23 Apr. | Changes to 1.4.10 approved by TF, surveying issue answer | 1.4.10 Reflow doc | Content changes for general guidance agreed and merged. May need SC problematic for closed content change (proposed in Google doc) Related to issues 226, 227, 257. See survey results for issue 221 answer and survey results for proposed SC problematic for closed for 1.4.10 Reflow. |
| 226 | Where a technology does not support an SC | 23 Apr. | Changes to 1.4.10 approved by TF, issue answer draft started | 1.4.10 Reflow doc | Content changes for general guidance agreed and merged. May need SC problematic for closed content change (proposed in Google doc) Related to issues 226, 227, 257. Drafting updated TF issue response. |
| 77 | Including WCAG supplements and Making Content Usable for People with Cognitive and Learning Disabilities | 27 Feb. | Done | none | TF agreed upon updated response on 22 Feb, merged document changes and responded in issue. |
| 200 | CSS Pixels – Verify how density-independent pixels behave in Windows and Mac | 22 Mar. | Done | none | This was answered by the same answer as Issue 227. |
| 216 | Inconsistency between 1.4.12 Text Spacing and 4.1.3 Status Messages | 14 Mar. | Done | 1.4.12 doc and 4.1.3 doc | Answer to 216 finalized. |
| 217 | Stale closed functionality examples | 8 Feb. | Done | none | Updates to examples merged, issue closed. |
| 225 | More affirmative examples | 8 Feb. | Done | none | Response updated with TF agreed edits, and issue marked with "TF answer complete". |
| 227 | CSS pixels – How to measure CSS pixel equivalents for systems with closed functionality | 8 Feb. | Done | none | Response updated with TF agreed edits, and issue marked with "TF answer complete". |
| 230 | 2.6 Software | 8 Feb. | Done | none | Response updated with TF agreed edits, and issue marked with "TF answer complete". |
| 308 | Native application equivalent in set of documents vs set of software programs | 27 Feb. | Done | none | TF discussed survey results for Issue 308, reached consensus on an edited response. |
Editor tasks – mostly pre-publication cleanup
| Issue | Topic | Last TF activity Date | Status | Google doc | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 255 | Editorial changes/checks | 23 Apr. | In progress | none | There’s a list of work items in the issue that needs to be done. Some PRs have been merged, 3 work items left. |
| 331 | Update acknowledgements and company affiliations | 23 Apr. | In progress | none | Work being initially done in an email thread. AG WG TF will be asked if we are missing anyone. |
| 332 | Remove, update, or add editor's notes | 19 Apr. | Starting work | Editor's notes doc | All existing notes are listed in Google doc. Will need to determine what to do with them and determine what sections had enough major change to call attention with an editor's note. |
| 341 | Update Status of this Document and Abstract | 23 Apr. | Surveying | None | See survey results on SOTD to be discussed on 25 April. |
| 333 | Task Force review of the draft and agreement to publish | 19 Apr. | Not started | None | This task is targeted to begin within a couple of weeks. |
Publication preparation
| Issue | Topic | Last TF activity Date | Status | Google doc | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 334 | Set up for AG WG review of latest editor's draft | 19 Apr. | Not started | None | Have been communicating with AG WG leadership regarding publication target date so it will be on agenda. Gathering list of special attention areas to review in the issue. |
| 335 | Set up and track horizontal review of the draft | 19 Apr. | started | None | Created a checklist of items, have been gathering info about what this review entails and criteria the draft is checked against. |
| None yet | Handle any issues that arise out of horizontal and AG WG reviews. | 10 Apr. | Not started | None | Any issues that arise during the pre-publication review will need to be addressed and tracked separately. |
| 336 | Create communication announcing publication and when comments are due | 19 Apr. | In progress | Communications doc | Daniel, Mary Jo, and Shawn have been working on drafting the comms. |
New SC and updates to intro sections and definitions
| Section name | Issue | Last TF activity Date | Status | Google doc | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comments on Closed Functionality | Issues 139, 240 | 8 Feb. | Done | none | PR 254 has been merged. AG WG will need to review. |
| "Closed functionality" key term | Issue 203 | 8 Feb. | Done | none | PR 254 has been merged. AG WG will need to review. |
| SC 3.3.8 Accessible Authentication (Minimum) | Issues 42 and 253 | 20 Feb. | Done | 3.3.8 doc | TF consensus on 15 Feb.PR 259 has been merged. AG WG will need to review. |
SC Problematic for closed functionality (10 Done)
| Success Criterion | Issue | Assigned to | Status Date | Status | Google doc link | Notes and/or Next Goal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3.1 Info and Relationships | Issue 275 | Mary Jo | 14 Mar. | Done | 1.3.1 doc | Agreed 14 March, merged into editor's draft. |
| 1.4.5 Images of Text | Issue 276 | Mitchell | 15 Apr. | Done | 1.4.5 doc | Agreed 11 April, merged into editor's draft. |
| 2.1.1 Keyboard | Issue 319 | Friday group | 15 Apr. | Done | 2.1.1 doc | Agreed 4 April, merged into editor's draft. |
| 2.1.2 No Keyboard Trap | Issue 272 | ? | 8 Mar. | Done | none | Agreed on 7 March, merged into editor's draft. |
| 2.1.4 Character Key Shortcuts | Issue 273 | Sam | 8 Mar. | Done | none | Agreed on 7 March, merged into editor's draft. |
| 2.4.4 Link Purpose (In Context) | Issue 274 | Phil | 15 Apr. | Done | none | Agreed 11 April, merged into editor's draft. |
| 2.4.7 Focus Visible | Issue 271 | Mitchell | 8 Mar. | Done | 2.4.7 doc | Agreed on 7 March, merged into editor's draft. |
| 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum) | Issue 293 | Done | 5 Feb. | Done | none | Edited notes from the last survey for 2.5.8 agreed and incorporated into the editor's draft. |
| 4.1.2 Name, Role Value | Issue 315 | Friday group | 14 Mar. | Done | 4.1.2 doc | Agreed 14 March, merged into editor's draft. |
| 4.1.3 Status Messages | Issue 277 | Bruce | 15 Apr. | Done | 4.1.3 doc | Agreed 4 April, merged into editor's draft. |