Arc Solution ae3edfdc in metta - trueagi-io/metta-wam GitHub Wiki
🧠 Translating Logic: From Python to Declarative MeTTa
This guide walks through a three-step translation pipeline to convert typical Python logic into fully declarative, symbolic MeTTa — a language designed for higher-order reasoning and unification-based pattern matching.
Our example comes from the ARC (Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus), where solving visual puzzles involves manipulating objects, colors, and spatial transformations.
Along the way, we demonstrate higher-order programming, where functions are passed and composed dynamically — a core strength preserved in the final MeTTa form.
✅ Step 1: Start with Python
Here's a Python function using functional composition and direct logic:
def solve_ae3edfdc(I):
objs = objects(I, T, F, T)
x = replace(replace(I, THREE, ZERO), SEVEN, ZERO)
filt = lbind(colorfilter, objs)
apply_grav = chain(lbind(rbind, gravitate), first, filt)
x7, x8 = apply_grav(TWO), apply_grav(ONE)
paint1 = mapply(fork(shift, identity, x7), filt(THREE))
paint2 = mapply(fork(shift, identity, x8), filt(SEVEN))
return paint(paint(x, paint1), paint2)
📝 This version is tight, but the logic is implicit — intermediate values are opaque (x
, x7
, etc), and behavior is hard to follow.
🧩 Step 2: Expand with Meaningful Names
We rewrite the logic using descriptive names. This reveals the modular structure and makes logic pipelines explicit.
def solve_ae3edfdc(I):
objs = objects(I, T, F, T)
replaced_3 = replace(I, THREE, ZERO)
replaced_3_7 = replace(replaced_3, SEVEN, ZERO)
color_filtered = lbind(colorfilter, objs)
gravity_applier = chain(lbind(rbind, gravitate), first, color_filtered)
gravity_vec_2 = gravity_applier(TWO)
gravity_vec_1 = gravity_applier(ONE)
color3_objs = color_filtered(THREE)
color7_objs = color_filtered(SEVEN)
shift_3 = fork(shift, identity, gravity_vec_2)
shift_7 = fork(shift, identity, gravity_vec_1)
moved_3_objs = mapply(shift_3, color3_objs)
moved_7_objs = mapply(shift_7, color7_objs)
painted_3 = paint(replaced_3_7, moved_3_objs)
output = paint(painted_3, moved_7_objs)
return output
🔍 This version clarifies:
- Object extraction
- Color filtering
- Gravity vector computation
- Object shifting
- Compositional painting
🧬 Step 3: Convert to Declarative MeTTa
Now we translate the program into MeTTa, a Datalog-inspired symbolic language using S-expressions and logic variables.
(= (solve_ae3edfdc $I $output)
(match-and &self
(objects $I T F T $objs)
(replace $I THREE ZERO $replaced_3)
(replace $replaced_3 SEVEN ZERO $replaced_3_7)
(lbind colorfilter $objs $color_filtered)
(lbind rbind gravitate $grav_func)
(chain $grav_func first $color_filtered $gravity_applier)
($gravity_applier TWO $gravity_vec_2)
($gravity_applier ONE $gravity_vec_1)
($color_filtered THREE $color3_objs)
($color_filtered SEVEN $color7_objs)
(fork shift identity $gravity_vec_2 $shift_3)
(fork shift identity $gravity_vec_1 $shift_7)
(mapply $shift_3 $color3_objs $moved_3_objs)
(mapply $shift_7 $color7_objs $moved_7_objs)
(paint $replaced_3_7 $moved_3_objs $painted_3)
(paint $painted_3 $moved_7_objs $output)))
🎯 Each step is declarative and referentially transparent. Logic is explicit and composable, enabling:
- Backward and forward reasoning
- Symbolic queries
- Program introspection
🔄 Why This Workflow?
Step | Purpose |
---|---|
🧩 Expand Python | Improve readability and structure |
🧬 Convert to MeTTa | Unlock symbolic reasoning and queryability |
♻️ Retain Higher-Order | Preserve abstraction and logic pipelines |
This supports logic-heavy systems and AI-focused symbolic inference.
🧠 What MeTTa Unlocks
By translating to MeTTa, we gain:
✅ Bidirectional reasoning — any variable can be an input or a goal
✅ Composable relations — logic can be reused and inverted
✅ Higher-order logic programming — function pipelines as first-class objects
✅ Explainability — every clause is traceable and transparent
✅ Symbolic search — pose abstract questions like "what shift aligns color-3 with color-7?"
🧰 Integration with ARC DSL
This MeTTa program works with the arc-dsl.metta
library, which provides:
objects
,paint
,replace
- Combinators like
lbind
,chain
,fork
- Spatial and logical operators
It composes with other ARC solvers to handle complex visual logic declaratively.