Meeting Minutes for October 31, 2013 - oasis-tcs/kmip GitHub Wiki

1:00PM PDT Call Started

Attendance Taken - Subhash Quoram - Achieved

Agenda

  1. Review of 1.2 items sent out to reflector by Subhash
  2. Various 1.3 information
  3. Changes to the Wiki

Tim Hudson Moves to accept Agenda Sue Gleeson Seconds

Prior minutes approval

Subhash: Previous three meetings Minutes posted by Saikat. Any additions or changes? Saikat: References between profile and specification sent from Tim. Tim H: List of Profiles in the Specification versus on the Web Page needs changed in Notes based on recollection for last weeks meeting (10/17/2013). Subhash had same recollection

Tim H: Motion to accept minutes with update Bruce Rich seconds No Objections and Abstentions - minutes are approved.

1.2 progress

Subhash: Moving 1.2 documents to next stage. Need to review draft motion to the list to approve CSD's and modify cross references and document names as needed to move to 30 day public review. Any concerns?

Tim H.: Just need to motion to update documents as needed either via online vote or motion during meeting Judy: There were changes made to the usage guide - so that needs to be corrected from what was sent to the reflector

Tim Moves to accept documents as per Subhash' draft motion (below) Kiran Seconds No Objections No Abstensions

Subhash's Draft Motion: (https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/kmip/201310/msg00031.html) Inlined as well


__________ moves that the KMIP TC

1) Approve the following working drafts as Committee Specification

��Drafts�(All�of�them�have�minor�editorial�edits�from�the�time�they
��were�approved�as�``CDSs``)
���1.��KMIP�1.2�Specification�-�Committee�Specification�Draft�01
���2.��kmip-tape-lib-profile-v1�0-wd04a.doc
���3.��kmip-sym-key-profile-v1.0-wd03a.doc
���4.��kmip-sym-foundry-profile-v1.0-wd03a.doc
���5.��kmip-suite-b-profile-v1.0-wd03a.doc
���6.��kmip-sa-sed-profile-v1.0-wd04a.doc
���7.��kmip-opaque-obj-profile-v1.0-wd03a.doc
���8.��kmip-cs-profile-v1.0-wd05a.doc
���9.��kmip-asym-key-profile-v1.0-wd03a.doc

2) Approve the following working drafts as Committee Note Drafts

���1.��kmip-testcases-v1.2-wd02a.docx
���2.��KMIP�1.2�Usage�Guide�-�Committee�Note�Draft�01�


Tim H: We will need to provide link to meeting minutes of meeting with motion for OASIS admin

Tim H: Changes to document names done by OASIS admin not TC editors

Kiran: Some of the documents are .docx and some are .doc. (AI)

Tim H: OASIS Admin will pickup and put in proper format as part of name change Judy F: Find out from OASIS admin what format is preferred if any Tim H: Some people on older versions of applications that may not support .docx format Kiran: OASIS provided .docx for this version of template

1.3

Subhash: From standpoint of 1.3 need call for editors. Tim submits most information so he would be good as editor of specification. Kiran: I can continue to help as needed Tim: If no one else steps forward then I can but I prefer a mix of vendors for input. Subhash: We don't have to do it today but it is something we need to think about and we would like to solidify the editors by next meeting. Will send out a query to Indra F. to see if she is willing to assist. Subhash' plate is fairly full so not going to be able to help much. If you can assist send email to Sub, Saik, Bob Judy: Are the existing editors willing to stay involved. Tim: Willing to continue with Profiles and Test Cases Subhash: Faisal needs to attend and accept to continue work on test cases.

wiki?

Subhash: Anyone looked at the Wiki? Tim: Yes looked at it Subhash: Streaming operations furthest into process. Kiran & Saikat need to look at and edit information on Saikat: Track input of old KMIP TC work by contributing companies on Wiki? Subhash: suggesting collaboration use on Wiki for initial contributions versus email as easier to track changes. Subhash: Whichever is easier email or wiki

Subhash: Meeting minutes review via wiki Bruce: Changes up to last minute might cause issues Kiran: Can sign up for tracking changes Tim: Changes are tracked and there is a watch page Subhash: Bob or Subhash/Saikat will finalize prior to meeting

Streaming

Subhash: If you can start with Streaming proposal in one to two weeks would be a good start Tim: Did you look at the current version of Wiki? Subhash: Yes can I put you in for proposal Tim: Streaming low priority and would wait if higher priority comes in. Subhash: Will follow up with owners for other works.

Interop update from Tony

Tony: Interop Sub-committee has been formed. Membership is required in TC to attend. Look at subcommittee page

�������under�KMIP�TC.��Looking�to�start�meetings�after�enough�folks�to�join�call.��Will�use�formal�interop�rules
�������used�in�last�round�starting�in�Mid-January�will�be�required�to�participate�in�interop�at�RSA.

Bob L.: Will people not planning on attending interop be able to participate in tests? Tony: I believe yes. That is a feature of recent OASIS changes for statements of use. Must participate to be

�������part�of�booth.

Subhash: Check with Chet where Interop Sub-committee is listed. It is not on the TC main page. Tim: It is currently in the complete list of OASIS committees Subhash: Chair has to edit to add to main page. Will check with Chet on specifics. Tony if you can send a note out to the TC it would be helpful.

Subhash: Anything else?

Motion to close meeting: Tim H. Second: Tony C. No Objections No Abstensions

1:36PM PDT Meeting Adjourned