Meeting Minutes for June 19, 2014 - oasis-tcs/kmip GitHub Wiki

Meeting commenced 8:00PM GMT

  • Roll call Subhash Sankuratripati (Subhash)
  • Quorum achieved

Proposed agenda

  • Update on status of 1.2 documents, updates and public review - Subhash
  • Update of document format for KMIP version 1.3 specifications and committee specifications - Subhash
  • Enhancement of Standing Rules after re-charter - Judith Furlong (Judy F.)
  • Review Server to Client Query proposal - Mark Joseph(Mark J.)

Motion to approve Agenda

  • David Featherstone Moves
  • Sue Gleeson Seconds
  • No objections
  • No abstentions
  • Agenda approved

Update on status of 1.2 documents, updates and public review (Subhash)

  • Email with proposal verbiage
  • Updated status of documents
  • Looking First and Second to motion for second public review of updated documents

Motion to move all documents to second public review

  • Chuck White moves that the KMIP TC:
  1. Approve the following working drafts as Committee Specification Drafts, Committee Specification Public Review Draft
Document Modified by Status Updated Document Change Bar
Specification� Kiran� review�draft�loaded� review-update change bar
Profiles� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Additional�Message�Encodings� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Storage�Array�with�Self�Encrypting�Drives� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Symmetric�Key�Profile� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Tape�Library� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Cryptographic� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Asymmetric�Key�Profile� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Symmetric�Key�Foundry� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�Opaque� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
Profiles�-�SuiteB� Tim� review�draft�loaded� review update change bar
  1. Approve the following as Committee Note Drafts, Committee Note Public Review Draft
Document Owner Status Notes
Test�Cases� Tim� non-material�changes�only�draft�loaded review update (Only�references�corrected)�
Usage�Guide� Judy� review�draft�loaded� review update
  1. Provide the editors the approval to: a.�Change�doc�names�to�C(D|N)S�and�modify�any�cross�references b.�Change�front�page�to�modify�editor�and�co-chair�names�as�deemed�necessary

  2. Authorize the co-chairs to request that all the documents be submitted for a 15 day public review

  3. Designate the WORD version of each document as the authoritative version

  • Mark J. seconds motion

  • No Objections

  • One Abstention (John Leiseboer)

  • Motion Approved

  • AI1: Subhash to submit TC admin requests after meeting minutes are uploaded

Update of document format for KMIP version 1.3 specifications and committee specifications - Subhash

  • Specification and Profile documents need to be dropped into new format
  • AI2: Subhash to validate if committee specifications require same format

Enhancement of Standing Rules after re-charter - Judith Furlong (Judy F.)

  • Do rules need to be re-balloted?
  • Not required (Hal Lockhart)
  • Do we need to modify to fit new charter based on name change of use cases to test cases?
  • AI3: To be researched (Judy?)

Review Server to Client Query proposal - Mark J.

  • Server to Client Operations
  • Server to Client Test Cases
  • John L. Asked about proxy clients that sat in front of more than one end point
  • Bob Lockhart agreed thought needs to be given to it but that it may be something for later to update as required via Profiles or in the specifications
  • Mark J. suggested that in cases where more than one end point was serviced by a proxy an error be returned
  • Further discussion to be detailed in email follow up

Upcoming Meeting Cancellations

  • June 26, 2014 meeting cancelled as no agenda items
  • July 3, 2014 meeting cancelled due to U.S. holiday July 4th

Motion to Adjourn Meeting

  • Chuck White moves to adjourn
  • Mark Joseph seconds

Meeting Adjourned 8:43PM GMT