Meeting Minutes for July 23, 2015 - oasis-tcs/kmip GitHub Wiki

Meeting commenced 8:00PM GMT

  • Roll call Tony Cox (Tony C.)
  • Quorum achieved

Proposed agenda

  • Approve Agenda
  • Roll call
  • Approve minutes
  • KMIP 1.3 Status
  • Review face to face action items
    • Key Wrapping (Mark) - discuss
    • Error Handling (Richard/Bruce) - discuss
  • Plugfest ballot
  • New business
  • Adjourn

Motion to approve Agenda

  • Tim H Moves
  • Gerry Seconds
  • No objections
  • No abstentions
  • Agenda approved

Motion to approve June 9th meeting minutes

  • Tim Chevalier Moves
  • Gerry Seconds
  • No objections
  • No abstentions
  • Minutes approved

KMIP 1.3 status

  • No KMIP 1.3 updates from authors - Tony assuming that this means no progress on those items.
  • TimH confirms he has not progressed his items

Key Wrapping Proposal

  • Mark briefly presented on Wrap/Unwrap proposal at https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/kmip/download.php/56111/detailed_wrap_unwrap_proposal.odt and https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/kmip/download.php/56112/detailed_wrap_unwrap_tests.odt
    • Very similar to the Get operation only it returns a managed object instead of returning a wrapped key
    • Unwrap object is similar to Register - difference is two fold, creates managed object when unwraps key that it has been give - and it also does attribute merging
    • Some comments that the merging is a little too open from Anthony - controlled by policy - perhaps attributes on unwrap key takes precedence over those provided - or limits.
    • Perhaps this should be explored and compared with Derive Key or attributes included in the wrapping
    • TimH - has anyone explored wrapping of attributes along with the keys? No responses.
    • BruceR - discussion on client policy enforcement - will
    • TimH - perhaps this is a topic for the next face to face.
    • Minute this and review in next meeting to see if it makes sense to include or leave out for KMIP 1.4 - that would control
  • Mark - proposal is done
  • Tony - do we need to wait for next week? Tim - yes.
  • Tony - would like to ballot this into 1.4 - next meeting? Yes.

Error Handling

  • Bruce walked through the posted item at https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/kmip/download.php/55985/KMIP%20error%20clarification.pdf
    • Request for clarity. Clarity is like beauty - a little bit abstract.
    • Two parts - header processing items and then errors with particular operations.
    • Should this be test cases or descriptions.
    • TimH Example of row 4 in 11.1 General table - what does it mean - Bruce and Tim would both not mind that row disappearing.
    • e.g. what happens if we have an attribute that is unknown? what is a field?
    • (discussion)
    • TimH perhaps we should limit to 11.1 General as a starting point
  • Tony: action item for status update for next meeting with further discussion to follow.

Plugfest Ballot

  • Cryptsoft, EMC, IBM, P6R, and HP - plug fest in around week 21-25th September with potential live f2f or plugfest at SDC or SNIA event
  • Next step is to fire up the interop sub-committee next week to figure out the details
  • Will be off the OASIS dial-in list if we have any non-OASIS members
  • Bruce - how do non-OASIS members find out about this
  • Tim - suggest we have a consistent description

Review Face to Face Action Items

  • No KMIP 1.3 updates from authors

Call for late arrivals - Tony C.

  • Joe & Jim

Motion to Adjourned

  • Joe Moves
  • Jim seconds
  • No abstentions
  • No objections
  • Motion Approved

Meeting Adjourned at 8:51PM GMT