Meeting Minutes for August 7, 2014 - oasis-tcs/kmip GitHub Wiki

Meeting Minutes August 07, 2014

  • Meeting commenced 1:00PM US-PDT

Roll call

  • Saikat performed roll call, we have quorum. This will be an official meeting.

Agenda

  • Client Registration Proposal (Tim)
  • Interop Subcommittee status (Tony)
  • KMIP 1.2 Status (Subhash)

Approve meeting agenda

  • Chuck moved, Tim seconded. No objections or abstentions or discussions. Agenda approved

Approve previous meeting minutes

  • Chuck moved, Tim seconded. No objections or discussions. Minutes approved

Client Registration Proposal

  • Tim went thru the proposal as submitted to the tc https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/kmip/download.php/53769/KMIP-Client-Registration-V2A-with-test-case.pdf
  • Questions: Are all four options in slide #4 desired. Saikat: All four are desired to suit a broad spectrum of vendor implementation, Mark: Option #4 does not make much sense Saikat: Makes sense if client and server both have a common trust point such as a root trust point. Chuck: Agreed. Hal: Option #4 is not uncommon in PKI world. No objections to including returning which options are supported as part of Query Capabilities. Tim will update based on that.
  • Saikat: Automatic client registration - what is the bootstrap authentication mechanism, Tim: Username/password, device credential or any other KMIP supported authentication mechanism
  • Tim: Slide 6 - no additional suggestions from tc but requested to send anything to add to the usage guide to Judy, Tim, and/or TC or will just use the list from this slide. No objections.
  • Client registration proposal could incorporate Bob Lockhart's PKCS#12 proposal if it was included but works entirely without it as it as Bob hasn't yet provided his proposal.

Interop status

  • Tony mentioned that today was the first interop plug fest call. There are three confirmed, 2 may be vendors for the plug fest
  • Subhash: Do we have well-defined rules since we had some contentions during last round of interop.
  • Tony: Well defined rules, will work-out finer details and scope between the participants
  • Subhash: It will be great to have at least 5 vendors participate in the plug-fest following our standard committee acceptance criteria
  • John: Can you clarify if plug-fest is limited to only 1.3 functionality, Tony: Confirmed as current scope.

Motion

  • Motion to approve the KMIP 1.2 errata document and if required for the co-chairs to submit request for formal ballot to tc admin.
  • Tim moves the motion
  • Chuck seconds, no abstentions, no objections
  • Motion carries

KMIP 1.2 status

  • Subhash submitted the request for all the 13 documents to OASIS admins. Subhash will check status of the requests.

Motion to Adjourn

  • Chuck moves, Tim seconds. No objections or abstentions or discussions. Adjourned 1:34PM US-PDT.