Project Part 2 Feedback - lagecamp/CMPUT301W13T02 GitHub Wiki

Feedback

Requirement Specification -- Good (3)

  • Use cases are numbered, test cases are included.
  • UC1: basic flow 3, 7, add 'user' before each line. The actor is chef, but the basic flow only mentions user. This description is inconsistent. The same problem exists in other use cases. Please check and update them. :)
  • The description and definition are clear.
  • Good.

User Interface Mockups and Storyboard -- Excellent (3)

  • The UI mockups cover important use cases. The UI looks good.
  • The storyboard is clear.

OOA -- Good (1)

  • RecipeManager and IngredientManager are more like controller. Model usually means data. So, manager seems not data.
  • In general, the diagram looks good. Clearly demonstrate the functionality and design of the software.

Release Planning -- Excellent (1)

Glossary -- Excellent (1)

Summary -- (9)