music composition id_criteria - freebase-schema/freebase GitHub Wiki

Identity Criterion for Music Composition type

Features for establishing identity relationships

  • name_match: There is a name_match if the names of the music compositions or aliases on both the sources match. Some composition names may be displayed in their original language while some may use the English translation.

  • composer_match : There is a composer_match if at least one of the composers listed in Freebase property /music/composition/composer (Composer) matches with the composers on the other source.

  • lyricist_match : There is a lyricist_match if at least one of the composition lyricists listed in Freebase property /music/composition/lyricist (Lyricist) matches with the lyricists on the other source.

  • includes_match : There is an includes_match if at least one of the smaller included compositions listed in Freebase property /music/composition/includes (Includes) matches with the compositions on the other source.

  • part_of_match: There is a part_of_match if at least one of the larger compositions that include this composition listed in Freebase property /music/composition/part_of (Part of) matches with the compositions on the other source.

  • arrangements_match: There is an arrangements_match if at least one of the composition arrangements listed in Freebase property /music/composition/arrangements (Arrangements) matches with the composition arrangements on the other source.

  • recorded_versions_match: There is a recorded_versions_match if at least one of the composition’s recorded versions listed in Freebase property /music/composition/recordings (Recorded versions) matches with the recorded versions on the other source.

  • recorded_as_album_match: There is a recorded_as_album_match if at least one of the composition’s recorded album listed in Freebase property /music/composition/recorded_as_album (Recorded as album) matches with the recorded albums on the other source.

  • date_completed_match: There is a date_completed_match if the composition’s completion date (year) listed in Freebase property /music/composition/date_completed (Date completed) matches with the composition completion date on the other source.

  • place_composed_match: There is a place_composed_match if the composition’s composed place (city, country) listed in Freebase property /music/composition/place_composed (Place(s) composed) matches with the composition composed place on the other source.

  • date_of_first_performance_match: There is a date_of_first_performance_match if the composition’s first performance date (year) listed in Freebase property /music/composition/date_of_first_performance (Date of first performance) matches with the first performance date on the other source.

  • place_of_first_performance_match: There is a place_of_first_performance_match if the composition’s first performance place (city, country) listed in Freebase property /music/composition/place_of_first_performance (Place of first performance) matches with the performance place on the other source.

General guidelines for establishing identity between two Music Compositions

Here are some typical patterns for determining identity of music compositions:

  1. name_match and composer_match. (Example 1)
  2. name_match and lyricist_match. (Example 2)
  3. name_match and date_completed_match and place_composed_match. (Example 3)
  4. name_match and includes_match. (Example 4)
  5. name_match and part_of_match. (Example 5)
  6. name_match and arrangements_match. (Example 6)
  7. name_match and recorded_versions_match. (Example 7)
  8. name_match and recorded_as_album_match. (Example 8)
  9. name_match and date_of_first_performance_match and place_of_first_performance_match . (Example 9)

Examples





Pattern 1 Example 1: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and their composers match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.





Pattern 2 Example 2: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and their lyricists match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.





Pattern 3 Example 3: Permalink Here the names of the compositions, their years of completion and the places where the compositions were composed, match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.





Pattern 4 Example 4: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and their included compositions match on both the sources. Hence the music compositions are identical.





Pattern 5 Example 5: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and the bigger compositions they are part of, match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.





Pattern 6 Example 6: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and their arrangements match on both the sources. Hence the music compositions are identical.





Pattern 7 Example 7: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and a few of their recorded versions match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.





Pattern 8 Example 8: Permalink Here the names of the compositions and their recorded albums match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.





Pattern 9 Example 9: [[Permalink|http://imslp.org/wiki/Sea_Pictures,Op.37%28Elgar,_Edward%29]] Here the names of the compositions, their first performance dates and their places of first performance match on both the sources. Hence the compositions are identical.

⚠️ **GitHub.com Fallback** ⚠️