setting - dingdongdengdong/astra_ws GitHub Wiki

MotorSelect

With Pully vs Without Pully

. Direct Drive (No Pulley/Gear System):

In a direct drive system, the motor's shaft is directly coupled to the wheel. There are no intermediate components like belts, pulleys, chains, or gears to alter the speed or torque.

How it works: The motor's RPM (revolutions per minute) directly determines the wheel's RPM. The motor's torque is directly applied to the wheel.

Key Characteristics (Advantages & Disadvantages compared to Pulley Systems):

Advantages:

Higher Efficiency: No power is lost to friction, slippage, or heat generation in belts, pulleys, or gear meshes. This means more of the motor's power is translated into useful work, leading to better battery life or less energy consumption. Simplicity and Compactness: Fewer components mean a simpler design, less weight, and a more compact form factor. This is why hub motors (direct drive motors built into the wheel) are so popular for electric bikes and scooters. Lower Maintenance: With no belts to tension or replace, no gears to lubricate or wear out, maintenance requirements are significantly reduced. Quieter Operation: The absence of mechanical transmission components eliminates noise from belts, chains, or gear whine, resulting in a much quieter system. Direct Control and Responsiveness: There's no "play" or "backlash" in the system, leading to very precise and immediate control over the wheel's speed and torque. This is crucial for applications requiring fine motor control. Better for Regenerative Braking: The direct connection allows for more efficient energy recovery during regenerative braking, as there are fewer losses when the wheel drives the motor. Disadvantages:

Motor Torque vs. Speed Mismatch: The biggest challenge. Motors are designed with a specific torque-speed characteristic. If you need high torque at low speeds (e.g., starting from a standstill, climbing steep hills), a direct-drive motor must be inherently large and powerful enough to provide that torque. A motor designed for higher RPMs might not have enough torque to move the load effectively without a gear reduction.

Larger/Heavier Motors for High Torque: To compensate for the lack of gear reduction, a direct-drive motor often needs to be physically larger and heavier to produce the necessary torque for a given application. This can impact overall vehicle weight and handling. Less Versatility in Speed/Torque: You're stuck with the motor's natural speed-torque curve. If your application requires a wide range of speeds and torque levels, a direct drive might be less flexible unless you use a highly sophisticated and often more expensive motor and controller. Higher Initial Cost (for high-torque applications): Achieving high torque directly often requires a more specialized, larger, or higher-pole-count BLDC motor, which can increase the initial cost compared to a smaller motor with a gearbox. 2. Pulley/Gear System (with a BLDC Motor):

In this setup, a BLDC motor drives a smaller pulley (or gear) which is connected via a belt (or chain, or direct gear mesh) to a larger pulley (or gear) on the wheel. This creates a gear ratio.

How it works: The gear ratio changes the relationship between the motor's RPM and the wheel's RPM, and inversely, between the motor's torque and the wheel's torque.

If the motor's pulley is smaller than the wheel's pulley (a common "reduction" setup), the wheel will turn slower than the motor, but with multiplied torque. If the motor's pulley is larger (less common for motive power), the wheel would turn faster than the motor, but with reduced torque. Key Characteristics (Advantages & Disadvantages compared to Direct Drive):

Advantages:

Torque Multiplication: This is the primary benefit. A smaller, higher-RPM motor can be used to generate significant torque at the wheel by reducing the speed. This is crucial for heavy loads, climbing hills, or applications requiring strong acceleration. Allows for Smaller Motors: Because torque is multiplied, you can often use a physically smaller and lighter motor to achieve the required output torque at the wheel. Motor Operating Point Optimization: The gear ratio allows the motor to operate in its most efficient RPM range, even when the wheel is turning slowly. This can sometimes lead to better overall system efficiency in certain scenarios, despite the losses in the transmission. More Versatile: You can change the gear ratio (by swapping pulleys/gears) to fine-tune the speed and torque characteristics for different tasks or conditions. Better for High-Speed Applications (if geared up): Although less common for wheels, a pulley system could also "gear up" the speed if needed. Disadvantages:

Efficiency Losses: Belts, pulleys, and gears introduce friction, leading to energy losses as heat and noise. This reduces the overall system efficiency compared to direct drive. Increased Complexity: More components mean a more complex design, requiring precise alignment, tensioning (for belts), and lubrication (for gears). More Maintenance: Belts wear out and need replacement; gears need lubrication and can wear down. Noise: Belts can sometimes squeak, and gears can produce whine, leading to a noisier operation. Backlash/Play: There can be some looseness or "play" in geared systems, which can reduce precision in control compared to direct drive. Bulkier and Heavier: The additional components add weight and take up more space. Which is "better"?

It entirely depends on the specific application:

Direct Drive is often preferred for applications where simplicity, quietness, high efficiency (especially at the motor's natural speed), and moderate to high speed are key, and where the motor itself can provide sufficient torque (e.g., many electric bicycles, low-speed robots, direct-drive turntables). Pulley/Gear Systems are chosen when high torque at low speeds is essential, or when a smaller, lighter motor is desired, even at the expense of some efficiency and increased complexity (e.g., heavy-duty electric vehicles, industrial machinery, power tools). For your "D-shift BLDC motor" connected to a wheel, the decision to go direct or use a pulley system hinges on whether your motor, in its natural speed range, can provide the necessary torque to move your wheel and load effectively. If it can, direct drive is generally the more elegant and efficient solution. If it struggles with starting torque or inclines, a pulley system would be necessary to multiply the motor's torque.