effect of parallel resistor - diglet48/restim GitHub Wiki

We compare these two schematics. The TPA3116 is used as signal generator.

simple schematic circuit with parallel resistor

Carrier frequency dependent effects?

We set the volume to a fixed level. Then we measure the current over the high-side resistor by measuring the voltage drop over a smaller (22Ω) resistor.

test name description
A No parallel resistor, 440Ω load
B 22Ω resistor, 440Ω load
C No parallel resistor, 2kΩ load
D 22Ω resistor, 2kΩ load
freq mA (A) mA (B) mA (C) mA (D)
200 46.4 41.8 26.6 21.5
300 46.4 42.7 27.3 21.5
400 46.4 41.8 27.3 22.2
500 44.5 42.7 26.5 22.9
600 45.5 43.6 28.4 23.0
700 45.5 41.8 28.4 22.9
800 46.4 41.8 28.7 24.8
900 48.2 43.6 28.7 22.9
1000 48.2 43.6 28.7 24.7
1500 48.2 41.8 28.0 24.7
2000 48.2 44.5 29.5 25.1
2500 48.2 44.5 29.8 25.8
3000 46.4 41.8 28.4 25.8
3500 46.4 43.6 28.4 24.0
4000 46.4 41.8 28.4 24.0
4500 46.4 41.8 29.1 23.3
5000 47.3 43.6 28.7 24.4

chart

We are looking for a flat response, all tested setups deliver. What we can conclude here is that the parallel resistor doesn't do anything for this specific test.

Load dependent effects?

We set the volume to some nice level, then we replace the 440Ω resistor with a different load, we measure the change in current.

Then we attach the parallel resistor, turn the volume knob once more to a nice level, and repeat the process.

Resistance Current (No parallel resistor) Current (Parallel resistor)
220 26.4 mA (+15%) 26.7 mA (+18%)
440 (baseline) 22.9 mA 22.5 mA
660 20.3 mA (-11%) 20.0 mA (-11%)

That wasn't very conclusive, perhaps we have to up the resistance?

Resistance Current (No parallel resistor) Current (parallel resistor)
0 47.2 mA (+159%) 50.5 mA (+177%)
1000 27.1 mA (+49%) 27.3 mA (+50%)
2000 (baseline) 18.2 mA 18.2 mA
3000 13.8 mA (-24%) 13.8 mA (-24%)

Conclusion: the parallel resistor doesn't do anything until we get to really low resistances, then the parallel resistor makes it worse.

Conclusion

For the tested amplifier/transformer combo, the parallel resistor does nothing useful.

⚠️ **GitHub.com Fallback** ⚠️