Mailing List Review Checklists - cplusplus/LEWG GitHub Wiki
Pre-Mailing-List Checklist
- Schedule a paper for mailing list review, according to priority.
- Update the paper's status (move to Scheduled section) on Mailing List Reviews.
- Send an email to authors of the paper, make sure the paper is in review state.
- Overview the paper and identify open questions.
- Collect requests for specific feedback from the authors of the papers.
Start-of-Mailing-List Checklist
- Phrase and send an email which contains:
- The date of the end of the review.
- Status of the paper and of previous discussions if applicable
- Summary of the essence of the proposal.
- Requests for specific feedback, either collected from the paper or explicitly defined by the authors.
- Update the paper's status (move to Ongoing section) on Mailing List Reviews.
Post-Mailing-List Checklist
- Summarize the feedback, send a summary-of-review email.
- Update the Github thread of the paper.
- Update the paper's status (move to Past section) on Mailing List Reviews.
- Identify additional actions (if needed), forward to the proper authority.