2024 06 08 troubleshooting write data discard issue in xtermjs library - bizkite-co/handterm GitHub Wiki
original file name: Codeium Chat - jdeADPuxbmMYxVUpqUAlshRwHO2yZeyb.md summary: In this chat, the user encountered an error related to writing data to the terminal too quickly, resulting in a "write data discarded" issue in the xterm.js library. The chat covered several troubleshooting steps, including the implementation of flow control to manage data writes and handling the Home key functionality within the terminal.
The user initially faced challenges using flow control to prevent data loss, which led to discussions on using the 'drain' event and queuing data writes at a controlled rate. Subsequently, issues with TypeScript typings for event handling in xterm.js were addressed, emphasizing the use of the onData
method for handling data received by the terminal.
Further discussions centered on correctly handling the 'drain' event and clarifying its absence in xterm.js due to differences in stream processing between Node.js and browser environments. The chat concluded with suggestions on improving the Home key functionality and fixing array length errors in the code related to cursor manipulation within the terminal. date: 2024-06-08T10:20
Note: This is purely the output of the chat conversation and does not contain any raw data, codebase snippets, etc. used to generate the output.
User at 10:20 am, Jun 8, 2024
I am getting this error when trying to navigate Home
when the Home key is pressed on the keyboard.
WriteBuffer.ts:105
Uncaught Error: write data discarded, use flow control to avoid losing data
at n.write (WriteBuffer.ts:105:13)
at P.write (CoreTerminal.ts:151:23)
at d.write (Terminal.ts:225:16)
at XtermAdapter.onDataHandler (XtermAdapter.tsx:148:29)
at t2.EventEmitter.fire (EventEmitter.ts:55:16)
at EventEmitter.ts:72:23
at t2.EventEmitter.fire (EventEmitter.ts:55:16)
at t2.CoreService.triggerDataEvent (CoreService.ts:77:18)
at P._keyDown (Terminal.ts:1072:22)
at HTMLTextAreaElement.<anonymous> (Terminal.ts:379:99)
Codeium at 10:20 am, Jun 8, 2024
The error message indicates that @xterm/xterm.js
is throwing an error due to the write buffer being overloaded. This can happen if you try to write data to the terminal faster than it can process it.
Looking at the code snippet from XtermAdapter.tsx
, the onDataHandler
method, it seems that you're trying to handle the Home key by writing escape sequences to the terminal to move the cursor. However, this code is commented out:
// while(this.terminal.buffer.active.cursorX > this.promptLength) {
// this.terminal.write('\x1b[D');
// }
If you're trying to implement the Home key functionality to move the cursor to the beginning of the prompt, you'll need to ensure that you're not writing to the terminal too quickly. You can either use flow control by checking the terminal's readiness to accept more data, or limit the rate at which you write to the terminal.
One possible approach to handle flow control is to listen for the drain
event, which Terminal
will emit when it is ready to accept more data. Here's an example based on the existing context (please adjust as necessary for your actual implementation):
// Example method added to the XtermAdapter class
handleTerminalDrain() {
// Implement logic to handle when terminal is ready to receive more data
// Possibly by maintaining a queue of data to write and continuing from where it left off
}
// In the constructor, you could bind the drain event to your handler
this.terminal.on('drain', this.handleTerminalDrain.bind(this));
// Now, inside your onDataHandler or any method that writes to the terminal:
// Check if the terminal.write returns false, if so, wait for the 'drain' event
const canContinueWriting = this.terminal.write(dataToWrite);
if (!canContinueWriting) {
// Implement logic to wait for the 'drain' event before continuing to write
}
Remember that the drain
event mechanism is just one way to handle flow control, and the exact implementation will depend on your specific use case and how you've structured your code to handle input and write operations.
If you need further assistance with the implementation details, please provide additional context or code from your project, and I'll be glad to help.
User at 10:25 am, Jun 8, 2024
I did not now about buffer draining, so I think I need to handle that better, but when I implement the code above I get this error:
Property 'on' does not exist on type 'Terminal'.ts(2339)
⚠ Error (TS2339) |
Property on does not exist on type Terminal
Codeium at 10:25 am, Jun 8, 2024
The error suggests that TypeScript does not recognize the on
method on the Terminal
type. This could be due to missing type definitions or an older version of @xterm/xterm
that doesn't support the on
method in the way it's used in the code.
However, @xterm/xterm
should have an on
method for event handling, according to the context provided and the standard API of xterm.js
. Here are a few steps to troubleshoot this issue:
-
Check
@xterm/xterm
version: Ensure you're using a version of@xterm/xterm
that includes theon
method for event handling. You might need to update@xterm/xterm
to a newer version if you're on an older one. -
Review type definitions: If you have custom type definitions or are using
@types/xterm
, check that they are up to date and include theon
method. If the type definitions are outdated, they may not include theon
method, leading to the TypeScript error. -
Type casting: As a temporary workaround, you could use type casting to bypass the TypeScript error, although this is not recommended for a permanent solution as it bypasses type safety:
(this.terminal as any).on('drain', this.handleTerminalDrain.bind(this));
Given the context provided in the code snippets, the Terminal
class should support the on
method for event handling. If you continue to experience issues after checking the version and type definitions, please provide more details about your @xterm/xterm
version and TypeScript configuration, and I can help you further diagnose the issue.
User at 10:31 am, Jun 8, 2024
I am using "@xterm/xterm": "^5.5.0"
, which is the latest version, according to npmjs.com
.
I don't see an on
event in the type definitions in node_modules\@xterm\xterm\typings\xterm.d.ts
. I'm not sure where I should be looking though.
Codeium at 10:32 am, Jun 8, 2024
The @xterm/xterm
library uses an IEvent
interface for event handling rather than the typical EventEmitter pattern, which is why you're not seeing an on
method directly on the Terminal
class. Instead, you'll find properties on the Terminal
instance that are of type IEvent
.
Here's how you can attach an event handler for the drain
event using the Terminal
class from @xterm/xterm
version ^5.5.0
:
// Assuming terminal is an instance of Terminal
terminal.onData((data) => {
// Your data handling logic here
});
// If you need to handle the 'drain' event, you might need to use the underlying parser
terminal.parser.registerCsiHandler({final: 'D'}, () => {
// Your drain handling logic here
return true; // Return true if the handler should consume the sequence
});
For the 'drain' event specifically, it's not a standard event emitted by the Terminal
class, so you will not find a direct method or event property for it. The drain
event is more of a concept used in Node.js streams. In the context of xterm.js
, you would typically handle this flow control at the data source level, for example, where you're receiving input from a pseudo-terminal (pty) if you're using xterm.js
in a server-side context.
If you're handling user input in the browser and sending it to the server, you should ensure your server-side code properly handles flow control with the pty and only sends data to the client that the client terminal can handle.
If you're implementing some custom flow control on the client side, you would need to do this logic manually, possibly by queuing data writes and checking if the terminal is ready to accept more data.
Can you clarify where you're seeing the need for a 'drain' event in your application? If you're looking to handle back-pressure or flow control in a browser environment, you may need to explain your setup in more detail for a more targeted solution.
User at 11:06 am, Jun 8, 2024
I already have an .onData
handler that I bind in my componentDidMount
:
componentDidMount() {
const { terminalElementRef } = this.props;
if (terminalElementRef?.current) {
this.initializeTerminal();
} else {
console.error('terminalElementRef.current is NULL');
}
this.terminal.onData(this.onDataHandler.bind(this));
this.terminal.parser.registerCsiHandler({final: 'D'}, () => {
let result = true;
return result;
})
this.terminal.onCursorMove(() => {
// console.log('cursor move', this.terminal.buffer);
})
// this.loadCommandHistory();
this.setViewPortOpacity();
this.terminal.focus();
this.prompt();
if (this.videoElementRef.current) {
this.webCam = new WebCam(this.videoElementRef.current);
}
window.addEventListener('resize', this.handleResize);
}
But we were talking specifically about monitoring the drain to see if that was causing the original error.
How would I implement the code inside registerCsiHandler
?
Codeium at 11:06 am, Jun 8, 2024
My apologies for the confusion. The registerCsiHandler
in xterm.js
is not used for flow control or buffer draining; it's for handling specific CSI (Control Sequence Introducer) escape sequences that the terminal receives.
For the issue you're experiencing (the write data discarded
error), there's no direct 'drain' event in xterm.js
to listen for because xterm.js
does not use Node.js streams in the browser environment, and therefore does not emit a 'drain' event as you would find in Node.js.
Instead, you'll want to manage the rate at which you write to the terminal. This can be achieved by checking whether the terminal is currently processing a write. The Terminal.write
method in xterm.js
is synchronous, but if you're calling it in rapid succession, you may need to implement your own flow control.
Here's a basic approach to managing the writes:
- Create a queue for the data you want to write.
- Write data from the queue to the terminal at a controlled rate.
Here's a very simple example of how you might implement this:
class XtermAdapter extends React.Component {
// ... existing properties and methods
writeQueue = [];
isWriting = false;
writeDataToTerminal(data: string) {
this.writeQueue.push(data);
this.processWriteQueue();
}
processWriteQueue() {
if (this.isWriting || this.writeQueue.length === 0) {
return;
}
this.isWriting = true;
// Dequeue the next item to write.
const nextData = this.writeQueue.shift();
// Write the data to the terminal.
this.terminal.write(nextData, () => {
// Callback when the write is done.
this.isWriting = false;
// Process the next item in the queue.
this.processWriteQueue();
});
}
onDataHandler(data: string): void {
// ... existing logic
// Assume we want to write something back to the terminal
this.writeDataToTerminal('\x1b[H'); // Example of writing Home cursor position
}
// ... rest of the class
}
In this example, the writeDataToTerminal
function adds data to a queue, and processWriteQueue
writes it to the terminal one piece at a time, ensuring the terminal has finished processing one write operation before beginning the next.
Please adjust this example to fit into your application's logic and flow. This is just a starting point and may need to be refined based on how your application interacts with the terminal.
User at 11:20 am, Jun 8, 2024
That has changed which error I get:
XtermAdapter.tsx:51
Uncaught RangeError: Invalid array length
at Array.push (<anonymous>)
at XtermAdapter.writeDataToTerminal (XtermAdapter.tsx:51:21)
at XtermAdapter.onDataHandler (XtermAdapter.tsx:176:20)
at t2.EventEmitter.fire (EventEmitter.ts:55:16)
at EventEmitter.ts:72:23
at t2.EventEmitter.fire (EventEmitter.ts:55:16)
at t2.CoreService.triggerDataEvent (CoreService.ts:77:18)
at P._keyDown (Terminal.ts:1072:22)
at HTMLTextAreaElement.<anonymous> (Terminal.ts:379:99)
[email protected]:[email protected]:176
Codeium at 11:21 am, Jun 8, 2024
The new error message Uncaught RangeError: Invalid array length
suggests that there's an issue with the array manipulation in your code. This error typically occurs when you try to define an array or set a length with an invalid value (such as a negative number, a non-integer, or too large of a number).
It's possible that the value being pushed onto the writeQueue
array or the logic to set the writeQueue
length is the source of the problem. However, without the relevant portion of your code, it's difficult to pinpoint the exact cause.
Based on the provided code snippets, here's a part of the XtermAdapter
class where you're manipulating the writeQueue
:
// XtermAdapter.tsx
writeDataToTerminal(data: string) {
this.writeQueue.push(data);
this.processWriteQueue();
}
There doesn't seem to be anything inherently wrong with this method as it's simply pushing data onto the queue. The error could be happening elsewhere.
To troubleshoot this issue further, consider the following steps:
-
Check the
writeQueue
initialization: Ensure thatwriteQueue
is initialized as an empty array and that there's no code accidentally setting its length to an invalid value. -
Check the use of
Array.prototype.push
: Verify thatdata
is not an exceptionally large string or an object that could be causing the array to exceed a reasonable length. -
Examine the call to
writeDataToTerminal
: Ensure that thedata
argument provided towriteDataToTerminal
is always a string and not something that could cause issues when being pushed into an array (likeundefined
, an object, etc.) -
Examine the
processWriteQueue
logic: Double-check the logic insideprocessWriteQueue
to ensure that it correctly manages the queue and that it's not setting an invalid length for the array.
If you continue to encounter issues, please provide the exact code where the array manipulation occurs, particularly around the writeQueue
, as well as any other related methods that might influence the queue's state. This will help in diagnosing the issue more accurately.
User at 11:25 am, Jun 8, 2024
The error is caused by this attempt to implement Home
key functionality:
if (data.charCodeAt(2) === 72) { // HOME
console.log('Home pressed');
// TODO: Handle Home key
while (this.terminal.buffer.active.cursorX > this.promptLength) {
setTimeout(() => this.writeDataToTerminal('\x1b[D'), 100);
}
return;
}
I have tried adding a timeout, but that didn't work and is probably implemented wrong, but I also thing that might not be the write way to make the cursor to Home
in xterm
Do you have any better ideas?
Codeium at 11:25 am, Jun 8, 2024
The setTimeout
inside the loop is problematic because it schedules many writeDataToTerminal
calls without waiting for the previous one to complete, which can easily flood the terminal with commands and cause the error you're seeing.
To move the cursor to the Home position (the beginning of the line), you don't need to issue multiple left arrow commands. Instead, you can use the following ANSI escape sequence to move the cursor directly to the beginning of the line:
-
'\x1b[1G'
- Moves the cursor to the first column of the current line.
Here's how you can adjust the onDataHandler
method to handle the Home key without a loop:
if (data.charCodeAt(2) === 72) { // HOME key
console.log('Home pressed');
// Move the cursor to the first column of the current line.
this.writeDataToTerminal('\x1b[1G');
return;
}
This sends a single command to move the cursor to the beginning of the current line, which should resolve the issue you were facing with the loop and setTimeout
.
Additionally, if you want to ensure the cursor moves to the beginning of the prompt (and not necessarily to the very beginning of the line), and you have a specific promptLength
, you could adjust the escape sequence to take that into account:
this.writeDataToTerminal(`\x1b[${this.promptLength + 1}G`);
This would move the cursor to the column immediately after the prompt, assuming this.promptLength
is the number of characters in the prompt. Adjust the 1
if your prompt positioning is different.
Try this solution and see if it resolves the error.
User at 11:43 am, Jun 8, 2024
That second suggestion is much better than what i was trying to do.
Do I still really need writeDataToTerminal
or is that just a workaround that I don't need now?
Codeium at 11:43 am, Jun 8, 2024
Given the updated approach to handle the Home key, you no longer require a complex workaround with writeDataToTerminal
. Instead, you can write directly to the Terminal
instance.
Here's how you can update your onDataHandler
method to move the cursor:
if (data.charCodeAt(2) === 72) { // HOME key
console.log('Home pressed');
// Move the cursor to the column after the prompt.
this.terminal.write(`\x1b[${this.promptLength + 1}G`);
return;
}
This simplifies the logic and directly sends the escape sequence to move the cursor to the desired position.
However, if there are other places in your application where you have complex logic determining what gets written to the terminal, or if you potentially have multiple components or functions that need to write to the terminal, it might still be beneficial to keep the writeDataToTerminal
method. It can serve as a single point of control, making it easier to manage writes, debug, or extend functionality in the future.
If the Home key handling is an isolated case and you're confident that writes to the terminal will remain straightforward, you can opt to write directly to the terminal as shown and remove the writeDataToTerminal
method. But if your application might grow in complexity, retaining writeDataToTerminal
could be useful.