5. Concept Evaluation and Product Architecture - W-Div-Engg-Exploration-Odd-2026-27/Repo-14 GitHub Wiki

Concept Evaluation and Product Architecture

PUGH CHART

Design Objectives Weights Rotating Photo Display Clock Still Photo Frame Message Box
Safety 8 ++ Datum ++ --
Ease of use 9 0 Datum + --
Portability 5 + Datum + -
Use of standard parts 5 0 Datum 0 +
Cost 9 + Datum 0 -
Score(+) 31 0 25 5
Score(-) 0 0 0 -48
Total 31 0 30 -43

5.1 JUSTIFICATIONS FOR SCORE GIVEN

Design No. Objective Score Allocated Justification for the Score
1 Safety 16 The rotating photo display uses a low-voltage motor and does not involve sharp cutting tools, making it safer than the datum.
Ease of Use 0 The operation is simple and comparable to the datum, so there is no significant advantage or disadvantage.
Portability 5 The display can be made compact and lightweight, allowing it to be moved easily.
Use of Standard Parts 0 The rotating display can use commonly available motors, shafts, platforms and electrical components similar to standard components used in the datum.
Cost 9 The system can be constructed using inexpensive and readily available materials such as a small geared motor, lightweight platform and photo holders.
2 Safety 0 The clock is taken as the datum reference for comparison.
Ease of Use 0 The clock is the datum, therefore its ease of use is taken as the reference value.
Portability 0 The clock is the datum, therefore its portability is taken as the reference value.
Use of Standard Parts 0 The clock is the datum, therefore the use of standard parts is taken as the reference value.
Cost 0 The clock is the datum, therefore its cost is taken as the reference value.
3 Safety 16 A still photo frame has no sharp moving parts or high-speed mechanisms, making it safer than the rotating display datum.
Ease of Use 9 A still photo frame is very simple to operate because photographs can be viewed directly without operating a motor.
Portability 5 A still photo frame is lightweight and can be easily moved from one location to another.
Use of Standard Parts 0 The frame can be made using commonly available materials and standard components, making it comparable to the datum.
Cost 0 The cost of a still photo frame is considered comparable to the datum for this evaluation.
4 Safety -16 A message box may involve electrical and electronic components, wiring and enclosed mechanisms, making it less safe compared with the simple clock datum.
Ease of Use -18 A message box requires additional interaction and electronic components, making it more complicated to operate than the datum.
Portability -5 Additional electronic components, display elements and housing can increase the size and weight, reducing portability.
Use of Standard Parts 5 A message box may require additional electronic components and specialized modules compared with the simple datum.
Cost -9 The additional electronic components, display and control circuitry can increase the overall cost compared with the datum.

5.2 SELECTED DESIGN

##5.3 PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE

##5.4 FUNCTION CLUSTERING

5.6 INTERACTION BETWEEN SUBSYSTEMS

5.6.1

Photo Input and Holding System With Rotation and Motion System With Power Supply System With Display and Structural System
Spatial ✅ ✅
Data
Material ✅ ✅

5.6.2

Rotation and Motion System Power Supply System Display and Structural System
Spatial ✅
Data
Material ✅ ✅

5.6.3

Power Supply System Rotation and Motion System Display and Structural System
Spatial
Data
Material ✅