Circuit protection - VTAstrobotics/Documentation GitHub Wiki


Contents

Prerequisites

None

Circuit-Protection

Introduction

Circuit Protection is an essential part of electrical engineering, focusing on keeping your designs safe from a variety of things. Lacking good circuit protection, your design could be unreliable, accidentally fry your most expensive components, or need to be replaced anytime something unfortunate happens. Good circuit protection is not necessarily hard, and it generally takes place near the power source, so it doesn't need to be present in every tiny segment of the wider circuit. Circuit protection generally comes with two choices, fuses vs circuit breakers (which protect against overcurrent), and TVS diodes, varistors and gas discharge tubes (which protect against temporary surges in voltage).

Fuses vs Circuit Breakers

Fuses and Circuit Breakers both fulfill the same essential function, they prevent overcurrent from frying all of your electronics. A short circuit happens somewhere else, and then current surges, which will lead to the fuses and/or circuit breakers from breaking the circuit minimizing damage and power losses. Their comparison can be found below:

Criteria Fuses Circuit Breakers Notes
What is it Wire that burns when too much current goes through it System that moves away conductor if too much current goes through it by electromagnetic induction -
Cost Dirt Cheap Varies -
Reaction time Very fast Varies with cost Some of the more expensive circuit breakers rival fuses in terms of speed
Size Very small Medium-Large This also varies with cost
Reusability Need a replacement every time it's tripped Has no need for replacement unless it breaks -
Applications Sensitive electronics 3-phase applications For everything else there is no cut and dry difference

TVS diodes vs Varistors vs Gas Discharge Tubes

TVS diodes, Varistors and Gas Discharge Tubes all perform the same essential function, they act to mitigate damage caused by short term voltage surges (transients). These transients can be caused by a variety of things, from turning a switch to lightning strikes to effectively luck. In all of these cases, these devices will try to effectively short from power to ground, thus absorbing that surge in power. Note that these devices cannot generally handle long term surges in voltage. Their comparison is provided below:

Criteria TVS Diodes Varistors Gas Discharge Tubes Notes
What is it Basically a potent zener diode A variable resistor whose effective resistance changes with applied voltage A tube with gas that is generally an open circuit but can behave like a short if sufficient voltage is applied across it -
Cost Medium Inexpensive Varies -
Reaction time Very fast Fast Relatively slow -
Size Very small Small Larger -
Voltage Small Large Very Large -
Lifespan Medium Small Large -
Leakage Current Low Relatively Large Very small GDT have follow current which needs to be mitigated for proper use
Applications Sensitive electronics High Energy Systems Very High Energy Systems (power) --

Other

There are other a variety of other circuit protection devices out there, but they are far less commonly used. These include PPTC/Resettable Fuses, Thermistors, Transient Blocking Units, Current Limiting Diodes, Thyristors and Ferrite Beads with inductors. I do not suggest using these for Astrobotics purposes (as of Summer 2024), but they may be encountered in industry for specialized purposes.

Bypass Capacitor

I suggest having a 100uF (or more depending on the power source) capacitor going from power to ground near your power source, ideally beyond other circuit protection. This capacitor's job is largely to just absorb many short term fluctuations in the power supply, to smooth it out. While not circuit protection, it is often placed near the other components so it is included here.