Sprint 1 Infrastructure User Testing Session Results - UQdeco2800/2022-studio-1 GitHub Wiki

User Feedback Notes:

Wall

  • Seems a bit flat and amateur
  • Looks like a castle top but not exactly a wall
  • Use of colour if a bit bright
    • Caution tape-like
  • Initially hard to distinguish that it is a wall
  • Add isometric design

Tower

  • Cool and clean
  • Looks a bit on the bigger side
    • Make thinner, but taller?
  • Isometric design pretty good —> best of the three designs
  • Clean up graphic base (left)
  • Needs dimension
  • Looks like plain stone, would be cool to make marble (match the Ancient Greek theme)
  • Could make it chess piece inspired?

Turret

  • Would be cool if they were Gyroid-like (like in Animal Crossing game)
    • Different types of turrets with different functions/movements
    • Kind of like a small army for defence
  • Turret base is very isometric, need to work on the turret itself
    • Add extra shading
  • Dimensions could be improved
    • Looks like it’s intending to be 3D but falls a bit flat
  • Materials very similar to the tower and might be hard to distinguish
  • Eyes/expression is a bit flat, doesn’t look very isometric

Changes for Next Design Iterations

Wall

  • Make isometric
  • Change colour palette (more natural)
  • Re-design shape to be more recognisable as a wall

Tower

  • Increase height, decrease width
  • Clean up dark outlines
  • Add marble texture
  • Revaluate shape (optional)

Turret

  • Change material (make more sand-like)
  • Rework visual dimensionality
    • Darken + lighten different areas
    • Extra shading
  • Rework facial expression