ED3‐CS - U-Div-Engg-Exploration-Odd-26-27/Repo-14 GitHub Wiki

ED3-CS: Concept Selection (Team 14)


Task 1: Assign Weights to the Objectives

Objectives Weights
Safety 9
Ease of use 7
Portability 5
Use of standard parts 6
Cost 6

Task 2: Pugh Chart for Alternative Designs

Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4 Design 5
Safety 9 + ++ Datum + +
Ease of user 7 ++ + Datum + -
Portability 5 -- -- Datum - -
Use of standard 6 - + Datum + +
Cost 6 + - Datum - +
Score (+) +29 +31 +22 +21
Score (-) -16 -16 -11 -12
Total 13 15 0 11 9

Task 3: Justification for the Scores Given

Design No. Objective Score Allocated Justification for the Score
1 Safety + The machine has a covered drum that helps reduce direct contact with waste and moving parts.
Ease of user ++ The top lid makes waste loading easy, and the rotating mechanism helps mix the waste efficiently.
Portability -- The machine has a large structure and a fixed supporting frame, making it difficult to move.
Use of Standard - Some parts, such as the rotating drum and internal paddles, may require customized fabrication.
Cost + The machine can be constructed using locally available materials, helping reduce manufacturing costs.
2 Safety ++ Enclosed structure and controlled operation provide better protection to the user.
Ease of user + Simple loading and operating mechanism makes it relatively easy to use.
Portability -- The machine is comparatively bulky and heavy, making it difficult to move.
Use of Standard + Most of the components can be made using commonly available standard parts.
Cost - More components and complex construction increase the overall cost.
3 Safety Datum Reference design
Ease of user Datum Reference design
Portability Datum Reference design
Use of Standard Datum Reference design
Cost Datum Reference design
4 Safety + The insulated outer shell helps reduce heat transfer to the outside surface and protects users from direct contact with internal components.
Ease of user - The machine has a control panel and input lid, but operating the agitator and cleaning internal components may require additional effort.
Portability - The machine contains a motor, heating element, gears, and a strong outer body, which may make it heavy and difficult to move.
Use of Standard + The design can incorporate appropriate electrical safety standards, insulation requirements, ventilation provisions, and safe mechanical components.
Cost + The machine can reduce household organic waste disposal and produce useful compost. However, the motor, heating element, and control system may increase the initial manufacturing cost.
5 Safety + The enclosed hopper and mixing mechanisms reduce direct contact with moving parts.
Ease of user - Operation involves manual actions like handling/loading of material, so it requires more operator effort.
Portability - Although wheels are provided, the machine is relatively large and bulky, making movement and transportation difficult.
Use of Standard + It can follow applicable safety, electrical and material standards during fabrication.
Cost + Simple construction and commonly available materials may help reduce manufacturing costs.