4. Concept selection - S-Division-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-16 GitHub Wiki

4.1 ASSIGN WEIGHTS OF THE OBJECTIVES

SL no Objectives Weights
01 Semi automatic 8
02 Portability 7
03 User friendly 6
04 Aesthetically pleasing 5
05 Ease of use 9

4.2 PUGH CHART

SL no Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4 Design 5
01 Semi automatic 8 Datum + + ++ +
02 Portability 7 Datum + + ++ +
03 User friendly 6 Datum + + ++ +
04 Aesthetically pleasing 5 Datum - + + +
05 Ease of use 9 Datum + + + +
Score(+) 0 35 35 56 35
Score(-) 0 5 0 0 0
total 0 30 35 56 35

4.3 Justification of the allocated score

Design No. Objective Score Allocated Justification for the Score
1 semi automatic Datum As reference
Portability Datum As reference
User friendly Datum As reference
Aesthetically pleasing Datum As reference
Ease of use Datum As reference
2 semi automatic + The bot is better than the datum
Portability + It is easily portable
User friendly + The bot is user friendly
Aesthetically pleasing + It 's appearance is better than the datum
Ease of use + It is easy to use than the datum
3 semi automatic + The bot is better than the datum
Portability + It is easily portable
User friendly + The bot is user friendly
Aesthetically pleasing + It's appearance is better than the datum
Ease of use + It is easy to use than the datum
4 semi automatic ++ The bot is very much better than the datum
Portability + + It is more easily portable
User friendly ++ The bot is very user friendly
Aesthetically pleasing + It's appearance is better than the datum
Ease of use + It is easy to use than the datum
5 semi automatic + The bot is better than the datum
Portability + It is easily portable
User friendly + The bot is user friendly
Aesthetically pleasing + It's appearance is better than the datum
Ease of use + It is easy to use than the datum

4.4 Selected design

image

Activity 2.2 : Subsystem List

--

Sl no user indication performing aarti play drum casing
01 Spatial Yes No Yes
Data Yes Yes No
Material Yes No No
   
   
SL no performing aarti play drum user indication casing
02 Spatial No No Yes
Data No Yes No
Material No Yes No
   
SL no play drum performing aarti user indication casing
03 Spatial Yes No Yes
Data Yes Yes No
Material Yes Yes No
 
SL no Casing user indication performing aarti play drum
04 Spatial Yes Yes Yes
Data Yes Yes No
Material Yes Yes No