5. CONCEPT EVALUATION AND PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE - S-Division-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-13 GitHub Wiki

1.ASSIGN WEIGHTS TO THE OBJECTIVES

SL.NO OBJECTIVES WEIGHTS
1 Semi- automatic 7
2 Light weight 8
3 Good looking 3
4 Portable 6
5 High heat resistant material 8
6 User friendly 6

2.PUGH CHART

SL.NO OBJECTIVES WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 DESIGN 4
1 Semi- automatic 7 Datum ++ + ++
2 Light weight 8 Datum + + +
3 Good looking 3 Datum ++ - 0
4 Portable 6 Datum 0 ++ 0
5 High heat resistant material 8 Datum ++ 0 +
6 User friendly 6 Datum ++ + +
Score(+) 0 56 36 36
Score(-) 0 0 -3 0
Total Score 0 56 33 36

5.1 JUSTIFICATION

123


5.2.SELECTED DESIGN

Design 2

5.3 PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE

SUB-SYSTEM LIST

Sl.no Sub-Systems
1 USER INDICATION
2 WOOD HANDLING
3 GHEE HANDLING
4 CASING

5.4 FUNCTION CLUSTERING

function cluster


5.5 SUB-SYSTEM INTERACTION

User Indication Wood Handling Ghee Handling Casing
Spatial NO NO NO
Data YES YES NO
Material NO NO NO

Wood Handling User Indication Ghee Handling Casing
Spatial YES NO YES
Data YES NO NO
Material NO NO NO

Ghee Handling User Indication Wood Handling Casing
Spatial YES NO YES
Data YES NO NO
Material NO NO NO

Casing User Indication Wood Handling Ghee Handling
Spatial NO YES YES
Data NO NO NO
Material NO NO NO