5. CONCEPT EVALUATION AND PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE - S-Division-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-08 GitHub Wiki

Assigned Weights to Objectives

Objectives Weights
SemiAutomatic 6
Modular Colours 1
Portable 3
High-graded Material 6
Light Weight 4
Cost Efficient 7
User Friendly 8
Safety 9
Region Selectivity 6

PUGH CHART

Objectives Weight Rack-Pinion Model Scissor-Lift Model Wiper Model Robotic-Arm Model
SemiAutomatic 6 DATUM 0 0 0
Modular Colours 1 DATUM 0 0 0
Portable 3 DATUM ++ + 0
High-graded Material 6 DATUM 0 0 0
Lightweight 4 DATUM + + -
Less Power Consuming 5 DATUM + 0 -
Cost efficient 7 DATUM 0 + 0
User-friendly 8 DATUM ++ 0 +
Safety 9 DATUM 0 + -
Region Selectivity 6 DATUM ++ 0 ++
Score(+) 55 DATUM 43 31 20
Score(-) 0 DATUM 0 0 18
Total 55 DATUM 43 31 2

5.1 JUSTIFICATION FOR SCORE

Design Objective Score Allocated Justification
Rack-Pinion Model Semi Automatic DATUM -
Modular Colours DATUM -
Portable DATUM -
High-graded Material DATUM -
Light Weight DATUM -
Less Power Consuming DATUM -
Cost Efficient DATUM -
User-friendly DATUM -
Safety DATUM -
Region Selectivity DATUM -
Scissor-Lift Model Semi Automatic 0 similar to DATUM
Modular Colours 0 similar to DATUM
Portable 6 Due to the string
High-graded Material 0 similar to DATUM
Light Weight -4 Has two sections
Less Power Consuming 0 similar to DATUM
Cost Efficient 0 similar to DATUM
User-friendly 8 Using the Interface
Safety 0 similar to DATUM
Region Selectivity 6 Using the Interface
Wiper Model Semi Automatic 0 similar to DATUM
Modular Colours 0 similar to DATUM
Portable 6 Due to it's clip ON fixation
High-graded Material 0 similar to DATUM
Light Weight 4 Less motors
Less Power Consuming 5 Less motors
Cost Efficient 7 Less components needed
User-friendly 0 similar to DATUM
Safety 9 The parts remain attached to board
Region Selectivity 0 similar to DATUM
Robotic-Arm Model Semi Automatic 0 similar to DATUM
Modular Colours 0 similar to DATUM
Portable 0 similar to DATUM
High-graded Material 0 similar to DATUM
Light Weight -4 Single Motor
Less Power Consuming -5 Single Motor
Cost Efficient 0 similar to DATUM
User-friendly 8 Interface
Safety -9 Heavy weight (might not stand)
Region Selectivity 12 Interface

5.2 SELECTED DESIGN

The Scissor-Lift Model


5.4 FUNCTION CLUSTERING

INDICATION UNIT

  • INDICATING START
  • INDICATING PAIRING MODE
  • INDICATING SUCCESSFULL CONNECTION
  • INDICATING THE CONCLUSION OF CLEANING

INTERPHASE UNIT

  • PROVISION TO SELECT THE AREA
  • DISPLAY CONNECTIVITY
  • TO INITIATE CLEANING
  • INDICATE THE CONCLUSION OF CLEANING

WIRELESS CONNECTIVITY SYSTEM

  • ESTABLISH CONNECTION BETWEEN MOBILE DEVICE AND CONNECTING BOT

CLEANING SYSTEM

  • TO MOVE THE BOT
  • TO CLEAN

SPRAYING SYSTEM

  • A CONTAINER TO STORE THE LIQUID
  • TO SPRAY THE LIQUID

Copy of Minimalist Gold Company Organization Chart


5.5 INTERACTION BETWEEN SUBSYSTEMS

Sl.No. Subsystem
1 Indication unit
2 interface unit
3 Wireless connection unit
4 Cleaning unit
                                                      **Interaction Details**
Indication Unit interface unit Wireless connection unit Cleaning unit
Spatial Yes No No
Data Yes Yes Yes
Material No No No
Interface Unit Indication unit Wireless connection unit Cleaning unit
spatial Yes Yes No
Data Yes Yes Yes
Material No No No
Wireless Connection Unit Indication unit Interface unit Cleaning unit
Spatial No No No
Data Yes Yes Yes
Material No No No