3.Concept evaluation and selected concept - Q-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-08 GitHub Wiki

TASK 1

Objectives Weights
Safety 9
Ease of use 7
Size of bot 6
Beat sound 9
Cost 8

TASK 2

Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
Safety 9 + 0 Datum 0
Ease of use 7 - - Datum -
Size of bot 6 - - Datum -
Beat sound 9 ++ + Datum ++
Cost 8 0 ++ Datum +
Score(+) 27 25 26
Score (-) -13 -13 -13
Total 14 12 13

TASK 3

Design No. Objective Score Allocated Justification for the Score
1 (1705) Safety 9 It has many electric connection as compare to datum
Ease of Use -7 Complicated circute connection
Beat sound 18 As it has many circuit connection beating drum and playing rhymes\poems become easy for bot
Size of bot -6 It occupy more space as compare to datum
Cost 0 Similar as datum
2 (1718) Safety 0 In case of safety the bot is same as datum
Ease of Use -7 Operating robotic arm is not so easy to operate as compare to datum
Beat sound 9 As it can beat only 1 drum beat at a time as compared to datum
Size of bot -6 It acquire large space as compared to datum
Cost 18 It is more expensive as compare datum
3 (1741) Safety 0 Datum
Ease of Use 0 Datum
Beat sound 0 Datum
Size of bot 0 Datum
Cost 0 Datum
4 (1754) Safety 0 similar as datum in case of safety
Ease of Use -8 little complicated as compare to datum
Beat sound 18 It can beat the drum with different tunes compared to datum
Size of bot -6 It occupies more space compared to datum
Cost 9 It expensive as compare datum

Final Design Selection: