3. Concept Selection - Q-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-01 GitHub Wiki

Task 1: Assign weights to the objectives

Objectives	Weights
Protability	9
Safe to Play	8
Light Wieght	7
Low Cost	6
Water Resistance	5

Task 2:PUGH Chart

Design Objectives	Weights	Design 1	Design 2	Design 3	Design 4
Protability	9	Datum	++	--	+
Safe to Play	8	Datum	+	++	+
Light Wieght	7	Datum	++	--	-
Low Cost	6	Datum	+	+	+
Water Resistance	5	Datum	--	+	+
Score(+)
Score(-)
Total			25	22	28

Task 3: Justification for the scores given

Design No	objective	score allocated	Justification for the score
1
	Protability	(0)	REFERENCE.
	Safe to Play	(0)	REFERENCE.
	Light Wieght	(0)	REFERENCE.
	Low Cost	(0)	REFERENCE.
	Water Resistance	(0)	REFERENCE .
2
	Protability	(++)	Easy to move around
	Safe to Play	(+)	No sharp objects used.
	Light Wieght	(++)	Cardboard casing makes it light
	Low Cost	(+)	Little costly
	Water Resistance	(--)	Less water-resistance
3
	Protability	(--)	Not easy to carry around
	Safe to Play	(++)	Highly safe
	Light Wieght	(-)	Little bit heavier than second design
	Low Cost	(+)	Less costlier.
	Water Resistance	(+)	Highly resistant
4
	Protability	(+)	Little less portable than others
	Safe to Play	(+)	Completely safe for kids
	Light Wieght	(-)	Hard to move due to heavy weight.
	Low Cost	(+)	Little costly
	Water Resistance	(-)	Less water-resistant.

Task 4: Selected Design