05.CONCEPT EVALUATION AND PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE - Q-Division-2021-2022/Repo-03 GitHub Wiki

Assign weights to the objectives

Objectives weights
Safety 9
Ease of use 7
Portability 5
cost 3

PUGH CHART

Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
Safety 9 + Datum +
Ease of use 7 - Datum -- +
Portability 5 - Datum + 0
cost 3 0 Datum - +
Score(+) +9 0 +14 +10
Score(-) -16 0 -17 -13
Total -7 0 -3 -3

5.1 JUSTIFICATION FOR THE GIVEN CHART

Design No. Objective Score Allocated Justification for the score
1 Safety + the outer frame maintains safety
Ease of use - mechanism makes it difficult to draw
Portability - difficult to carry along
Cost 0 same cost
2 Safety Datum Used for comparison
Ease of use Datum Used for comparison
Portability Datum Used for comparison
cost Datum Used for comparison
3 Safety + battery used is of low voltage and it does not have electrical hazards
Ease of use -- the intreface is difficult for the user
Portability + light weight easy to carry
Cost - it is very expensive
4 Safety - it has gear drive containig sharp edges
Ease of use + it has wheels which make it easy to move
Portability 0 easy to move
Cost + only one sensor is used which is of low cost

5.2 Selected Design

1645186453156

5.3 PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE

FUNCTION CLUSTRING

INTRACTION BETWEEN SUBSYSTEMS

Sensing unit designing unit indication unit
Special yes yes
Data yes no
Meterial no yes
designing unit indication unit sensing unit
special no yes
Data no no
Meterial yes no
indecation unit sensing unit designing unit
Special no yes
Data yes no
meterial yes no

Circuit diagram