05.CONCEPT EVALUATION AND PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE - Q-Div-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-9 GitHub Wiki
ASSIGNING WEIGHTAGE TO OBJESTIVES
Sl>NO | Objectives | Weightage |
---|---|---|
01. | Easy to use | 6 |
02. | Safety | 7 |
03. | Portability | 4 |
04. | Standard parts | 2 |
05. | Cost | 5 |
06. | Asthetic | 3 |
07. | User friendly | 8 |
PUGH CHART
Serial.no | Objectives | Weightage | Design 1 | Design 2 | Design 3 | Design 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
01 | Easy to use | 6 | - | + | - | Datum |
02 | Cost | 5 | - | - | + | Datum |
03 | Saftey | 7 | - | ++ | -- | Datum |
04 | Portablity | 4 | + | + | - | Datum |
05 | Asthetic | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | Datum |
06 | User friendly | 8 | ++ | ++ | ++ | Datum |
07 | Standard Parts | 2 | -- | -- | -- | Datum |
Positive | 20 | 40 | 21 | 0 | ||
Negative | -22 | -9 | -28 | 0 | ||
Total | -2 | 31 | -7 | 0 |
5.1 JUSTIFICATIONS FOR SCORES GIVEN
Design | Objectives | Score Given | Justification |
---|---|---|---|
01. | User friendly | 16 | Its not harmful |
Cost | -5 | The design is more expensive | |
Portabilty | 4 | It has wheels for movement | |
Asthetic | 4 | The machine is bulky and requires lot of space | |
Safety | -7 | The machine has safety covering over it | |
Easy to use | -6 | This machine is easy to use as it uses different sensors | |
Standard Parts | -4 | This machine doesn't use all the parts required | |
02. | User friendly | 16 | Its not harmful |
Cost | -5 | The design is more expensive | |
Portability | 4 | Its easy to use as it has wheels for movement | |
Asthetic | 6 | The machine is light,compact and requires less space | |
Safety | 14 | It has a safety covering over it | |
Easy to use | 6 | The machine is easy to use as it is run on adapter | |
Standard Parts | -4 | Different sensers are being use to control the machine | |
03. | User friendly | 16 | Its not harmful |
Cost | 5 | The cost is less compared to datum | |
Portability | -4 | due to the absence of wheels it is not portable | |
Asthetic | 6 | this machine is bulky and requires lot of space | |
Safety | -14 | The machine doesn't have safety covering over it | |
Easy to use | -6 | This machine being bulky is not easy to use | |
Standard Parts | -4 | This machine doesn't use many sensors so it's not safe | |
04. | User friendly | 0 | Datum |
Cost | 0 | Datum | |
Portability | 0 | Datum | |
Aesthetic | 0 | Datum | |
Safety | 0 | Datum | |
Easy to use | 0 | Datum | |
Standard Parts | 0 |
5.2 SELECTED DESIGN
FRONT VIEW
BACK VIEW
5.3 FUNCTION CLUSTERING
5.3 PROUCT ARCHITECTURE
Sub-Systems
Subsystems identified:
SL>NO | Sub-system |
---|---|
01. | Conveyor system |
02. | Threshing unit |
03. | Mechanism unit |
04. | Other functions |
5.5 INTERACTION BETWEEN SUBSYSTEMS
Interaction of subsystems with each other:
Thresher unit | Crop handling unit | Seeds handling unit | Seeds storing unit |
---|---|---|---|
Material Interaction | Yes | Yes | No |
Data Interaction | No | No | Yes |
Spatial Interaction | Yes | No | No |
Crop handling unit | Seeds handling unit | Seeds storing unit | Thresher unit |
---|---|---|---|
Material Interaction | No | No | Yes |
Data Interaction | Yes | No | Yes |
Spatial Interaction | Yes | No | Yes |
Seeds handling unit | Seeds storing unit | Thresher unit | Crop handling unit |
---|---|---|---|
Material Interaction | Yes | Yes | No |
Data Interaction | Yes | Yes | No |
Spatial Interaction | Yes | No | No |
Seeds storing unit | Threshing unit | Crop handling unit | Seeds handling unit |
---|---|---|---|
Material Interaction | No | No | Yes |
Data Interaction | No | No | Yes |
Spatial Interaction | No | No | Yes |