5.Concept Selection - Q-Div-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-6 GitHub Wiki

A. Pugh Chart

Design objectives	Weights	Design 1	Design 2	Design 3	Design 4	Design 5
Semi automatic	7	++	datum	-	-	-
Portable	6	+	datum	0	+	+
Labeling on sorting compartment	9	0	datum	-	0	0
User friendly	10	-	datum	++	+	+
Maintanance	5	+	datum	+	-	-
Score(+)		+
Score(-)				-	-	-
Total	40	23	0	12	2	2

B. Justification

We have chosen design 1. As this machine is user-friendly and easily operatable we have chosen this design and it involves easy mechanisms. It's also lightweight so it can be portable as well. Therefore this design is feasible in every aspect.

C. Selected Design

D. Product architecture

1)Subsystem list

Sl.no	Subsystem
1	Switch
2	Storing
3	Sensing
4	Sorting

2)Interaction details

Subsystem	Subsystem 1	Subsystem 2	Subsystem 3	Subsystem 4
Spatial	✔	x	x	x
Data	x	✔	✔	x
Material	✔	x	x	✔

3. Function Clustering