5:CONCEPT SELECTION - Q-Div-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-5 GitHub Wiki

PUGH CHART

DESIGN OBJESCTIVE WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3
low cost 3 2+ 1+ datum
installation 1 1- 0 datum
saftey 10 2+ 1+ datum
ease of use 4 1+ 2+ datum
maintainance 5 2- 0 datum
space 2 2+ 1+ datum
less weight 7 2+ 1+ datum
speed 9 1- 0 datum
score(+) ------ 60 29 ----
score(-) ----- 20 0 ----
total ----- 40 29 0

5.1 JUSTIFICATIONS FOR THE SCORES GIVEN

objectives score alloted justification for score alloted
low cost 3 the price comes around a average cost
installation 1 installation is done only one time
safety 10 as it is a machine safety will be our top priority
ease of use 4 as it is automatic it can be used by knowledge
maintenance 5 it requires proper maintenance
space 2 space doesnot required more
less weight 7 maintaining the low weight of machine is important
speed 9 as it is automatic machine speed will be high

5.2 SELECTED DESIGN

IMG_20230318_143637 (1)

5.3 PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE

5.4 FUNCTION CLUSTERING

image

Subsystems

sl no subsysytem
1 handling unit
2 moving or sorting unit
3 releasing

5.5 INTERACTION BETWEEN THE SUBSYSTEMS

Subsystems handling moving and sorting releasing indication
handling ----- material --- -----
moving and sorting unit ---- ----- spatial -----
releasing ----- ----- ------ data