5. CONCEPT SELECTION - Q-Div-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-1 GitHub Wiki
5.1 WEIGHTAGE
Objectives | Weights |
---|---|
User Friendly(Ease of use) | 10 |
Safety | 7 |
Aesthetic look | 5 |
Weight | 4 |
Portability | 8 |
Semi Automatic | 3 |
5.2 PUGH CHART
Design Objectives | Weights | Design 1 | Design 2 | Design 3 | Design 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
User Friendly(Ease of use) | 10 | plus | DATUM | minus | plus |
Safety | 7 | minus minus | DATUM | minus | plus |
Portability | 8 | minus | DATUM | plus plus | minus minus |
Weight | 4 | plus | DATUM | plus | minus |
Aesthetic look | 5 | plus | DATUM | minus | minus |
Automatic | 3 | Minus | DATUM | Minus | Minus |
Score(+) | 34 | 19 | 0 | 20 | 17 |
Score(-) | 0 | -25 | 0 | -25 | -28 |
Total | 34 | -6 | 0 | -5 | -11 |
5.3 JUSTIFICATION OF SCORE
Design No. | Objective | Score Allocated | Justification for the Score |
---|---|---|---|
1 | User friendly(ease of use) | plus | it is moderately safe to use as it involves complex programming |
Safety | minus minus | It is less safe | |
Portability | minus | as the bot has to many wire connections it is difficult to carry | |
weight | plus | It is moderately heavy as it uses many standard parts | |
Aesthethical look | plus | With proper architecture it looks good | |
Automatic | Minus | It is not completely automatic because it needs manual help | |
2 | User Friendly | 0 | This was used as datum |
Safety | 0 | This was used as datum | |
Portability | 0 | This was used as datum | |
Weight | 0 | This was used as datum | |
Aesthetic Look | 0 | This was used as datum | |
Automatic | 0 | This was used as datum | |
3 | Safety | minus | As more electrical components are used it is not safe |
Portability | plus plus | Wheels are used hence it is easily portable | |
Weight | plus | As sensors are used and light weight wheel are used the weight is less | |
User friendly | minus | As more electrical devices are used it's not user friendly | |
Aesthetic look | plus | As the design has considerably good aesthetic look | |
Automatic | Minus | there is no inbuilt mechanism for filling back the rangoli when it gets over | |
4 | Safety | plus | No harmful materials used |
Portability | Minus minus | Bot is heavy to carry | |
weight | minus | heavy weight | |
user friendly | minus | High more electric parts used | |
asthetic look | minus | conisidderably good | |
automatic | minus | not fully automatic |
5.4 SELECTED DESIGN
5.5 FUNCTION CLUSTERING