4 CONCEPT EVALUATION - P-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-14 GitHub Wiki

PUGH CHART

OBJECTIVES WEIGHTAGE DESIGN IDEA 1 DESIGH IDEA 2 DESIGH IDEA 3 DESIGH IDEA 4
safety 5 - - 0 DATUM - -
ease of use 4 - 0 DATUM ++
potability 2 - - - DATUM -
Use of standard parts 1 - - DATUM -
cost 3 - + DATUM +
+ score 0 3 11
- score -20 -5 -13
total -20 -2 -2

B. JUSTIFICATION

Design concept NO Objective Score Given Justification
1 Safety – It is not safe because the belt can hit user
Ease of Use - It is easy to use but the effort is required to pull the belt
Portability - Belt can be weaken after certain days of use
Use of standard parts - No use of standard parts
Cost - Cost is cheaper than design 3
2 Safety 0 It is safe to use
Ease of Use 0 Easy to use
Portability + It is little bit heavy from design 3
Use of standard parts - It requires extra tyre then design 3
Cost + little but costly from Design 3
3 Safety Datum It is safe to use
Ease of Use Datum It is easy to use
Portability Datum Movable
Use of standard parts Datum All parts are available in market
Cost Datum Cost are affordable
4 Safety – If the two wheels crash due to gravity or loose connection it can hit user
Ease of Use ++ Easy to use
Portability - It is not portable compared to Design 3
Use of standard parts - No standard parts
Cost + Cost is not affordable

C. The concept we have selected is Design concept 3

Team members ROLL NO
1 Varsha patil 1663
2 Aditi hiremath 1661
3 Aditya G 1626
4 Allhabakash G 1637
⚠️ **GitHub.com Fallback** ⚠️