5. CONCEPT SELECTION - P-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-05 GitHub Wiki

4.1 ASSIGN WEIGHTS TO THE OBJECTIVE

SL.NO OBJECTIVE WEIGHTS
1 SAFETY 6
2 EASY OF USE 6
3 PORTABILITY 7
4 STANDARD PARTS AND MATERIAL 8
5 TOTAL DIGITAL LOCK 8

4.2 PUGH CHART

[(*)is datum here]

SL.NO DESIGN OBJECTIVE WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 DESIGN4
1 SAFETY 6 * ++ - -
2 EASY OF USE 6 * ++ - +
3 PORTABILITY 7 * - * *
4 STANDARD PARTS AND MATERIAL 8 * * * --
5 TOTAL DIGITAL LOCK 8 * ++ - +
> TOTAL WEIGHT 35 35 40 33 33

4.3 JUSTIFICATION FOR WEIGHTS GIVEN

DESIGN OBJECTIVE SCORE JUSTIFICATION FOR THE SCORE
1 SAFETY 6 *
EASY OF USE 6 *
PORTABILITY 7 *
STANDARD PARTS AND MATERIAL 8 *
TOTAL DIGITAL LOCK 8 *
2 SAFETY 8 more safe because of better alarm arrangement
EASY OF USE 8 battery box outside, alarm easily heard
PORTABILITY 6 useage of screw to attach if needed makes it less portable
STANDARD PARTS AND MATERIAL 8 similar type and quality parts used
TOTAL DIGITAL LOCK 10 2 digital locks used
3 SAFETY 5 no drawers and secret compartments
EASY OF USE 5 circuit distributed
PORTABILITY 7 almost portability is same
STANDARD PARTS AND MATERIAL 8 almost same material used
TOTAL DIGITAL LOCK 8 semi digital as datum
4 SAFETY 5 locks can be easily manupilated
EASY OF USE 7 easy usage because
PORTABILITY 7 portability same
STANDARD PARTS AND MATERIAL 6 traditional lock
TOTAL DIGITAL LOCK 8 semi digital as datum

4.4 SELECTED DESIGN

122222006-77e54b80-cecf-11eb-8b51-9705a28d3484


4.4 FUNCTION CLUSTERING

122559400-e4da1c00-d05c-11eb-8218-03e8962a046e

***#

4.5 SUBSYSTEM LIST

SL.NO SUBSYSTEM
1 INDICATION SECTION
2 USER INPUT AND PROCESSING SECTION
3 CONSTRUCTION SECTION

4.6 INTERACTION DETAILS

Screenshot 2021-06-16 231136