3. Concept Evaluation And Selected Concept - P-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-01 GitHub Wiki

3.1 ASSIGN WEIGHTS TO THE OBJECTIVE

Sl.no objective weight
1 Safety 9
2 User-friendly 8
3 Reliable 9
4 Portability 8

3.2 PUGH CHART

sl.no design objective weights design 1 design 2 design 3 design 4
1 safety 9 + * - -
2 User-Friendly 8 + * * *
3 Reliable 9 + + * *
4 Portability 8 + + - -
total 34 38 36 32 32

3.3 JUSTIFICATION FOR WEIGHTS GIVEN

Design objective score justification for the score
1 safety 10 high due to solenoid lock
User-friendly 9 Single level security system
Reliable 10 Solenoid lock is used
Portability 9 more Portable because less equipment are used
Design objective score justification for the score
2 Safety 9 --
User-friendly 8 --
Reliable 10 Good Quality Lock
Portability 9 Few types of equipment are used
Design objective score justification for the score
3 safety 8 can be easily exploited
User-friendly 8 --
Reliable 9 --
Portability 7 Less due to more types of equipment
Design objective score justification for the score
4 safety 8 double security
User-Friendly 8 --
Reliable 9 --
Portability 7 Less Due to more types of equipment

3.4 Selected Design

https://i.postimg.cc/nhq39BSd/Design-1.jpg

3.5 Function Clustering

https://i.postimg.cc/9Fzs8T9Q/Smart-locker-Diagram-3.jpg

3.6 Subsystem List

Sl.No Subsystems
1 Opening and closing Unit
2 Verification and Indication Unit
3 Control unit

3.7 Interaction Between Subsystems

Opening and Closing Unit Verification and Indication Unit Control Unit
Material Input ❌ ❌
Data Input ✅ ✅
Spatial Input ✅ ❌
Verification and Indication Unit Opening and Closing Unit Control Unit
Material Input ❌ ❌
Data Input ✅ ❌
Spatial Input ✅ ❌
Control Unit Verification and Indication Unit Opening and Closing Unit
Material Input ❌ ❌
Data Input ✅ ✅
Spatial Input ❌ ✅