3. Concept Evaluation And Selected Concept - P-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-01 GitHub Wiki

3.1 ASSIGN WEIGHTS TO THE OBJECTIVE

Sl.no objective weight
1 Safety 9
2 User-friendly 8
3 Reliable 9
4 Portability 8

3.2 PUGH CHART

sl.no design objective weights design 1 design 2 design 3 design 4
1 safety 9 + * - -
2 User-Friendly 8 + * * *
3 Reliable 9 + + * *
4 Portability 8 + + - -
total 34 38 36 32 32

3.3 JUSTIFICATION FOR WEIGHTS GIVEN

Design objective score justification for the score
1 safety 10 high due to solenoid lock
User-friendly 9 Single level security system
Reliable 10 Solenoid lock is used
Portability 9 more Portable because less equipment are used
Design objective score justification for the score
2 Safety 9 --
User-friendly 8 --
Reliable 10 Good Quality Lock
Portability 9 Few types of equipment are used
Design objective score justification for the score
3 safety 8 can be easily exploited
User-friendly 8 --
Reliable 9 --
Portability 7 Less due to more types of equipment
Design objective score justification for the score
4 safety 8 double security
User-Friendly 8 --
Reliable 9 --
Portability 7 Less Due to more types of equipment

3.4 Selected Design

https://i.postimg.cc/nhq39BSd/Design-1.jpg

3.5 Function Clustering

https://i.postimg.cc/9Fzs8T9Q/Smart-locker-Diagram-3.jpg

3.6 Subsystem List

Sl.No Subsystems
1 Opening and closing Unit
2 Verification and Indication Unit
3 Control unit

3.7 Interaction Between Subsystems

Opening and Closing Unit Verification and Indication Unit Control Unit
Material Input
Data Input
Spatial Input
Verification and Indication Unit Opening and Closing Unit Control Unit
Material Input
Data Input
Spatial Input
Control Unit Verification and Indication Unit Opening and Closing Unit
Material Input
Data Input
Spatial Input