4. Concept Selection and Product Architecture - P-Odd-2022/Repo-17 GitHub Wiki

CONCEPT SELECTION

4.1 WEIGHTAGE GIVEN TO EACH OBJECTIVE

Sl.No Objectives Weightage
1. Budget 8
2. Fabrication of Parts 7
3. Semi Automatic 9
4. User Friendly 9
5. Portability 6
6. Different type of Patterns 8
7. Power Efficient 7
8. Aesthetics 2
9. Working Capacity 6
10. Smooth Motion Of Bot 7

4.2 PUGH CHART

Presentation Nidhi 1

4.3 Justification for Selected Concept

Concept 1 has been selected based on its overall performance in the PUGH chart. The bot can be manufactured on a lower budget with lesser number of parts to be fabricated. It is convenient to use due to its simple mechanism and architecture. Due to the presence of wheels, the bot has smooth motion which enhances the quality of pattern drawn. The light weight of the bot makes it easily portable.

Sl.No Objectives Assigned Score Justification
1. Budget + The selected concept compared to the Datum is cheap
2. Fabrication Of parts + The selected concept has less Number of parts compared to the Datum
3. Bot should be semi Automatic + The selected Bot is semi automatic and it receives orders through the program
4. User Friendly + The selected design when compared to the Datum is simpler to use
5. Portability ++ The selected concept has lesser weight than that of the Datum and can be easily carried place to place
6. Different types Of Patterns + The selected concept is more flexible than that of Datum and it can easily draw a wide range of patterns
7. Power efficient + The selected concept is more Power efficient compared to the Datum
8. Aesthetics + The selected concept has a very nice and clear outlook as compared to the Datum
9. Working Capacity - The selected concept works for less number of hours as compared to the Datum
10. Smooth Motion Of Bot + The selected concept has the smooth motion as compared to the Datum, as it has wheels for smooth transitions

4.4 Selected Concept

NIDHI PRJT

4.5 Functional Clustering

funcclusterlatest

4.6 Sub-System list

S.No Sub-System
1. User Input Section
2. Handling and Controlling section
3. Drawing Pattern Section
4. Indication Section

4.7 Interaction Details

User Input Section Handling and controlling system Drawing Pattern Section Indication Section
Material Interaction Yes Yes Yes
Digital Interaction No Yes Yes
Special Interaction Yes No No
Handling and controlling system Drawing Pattern Section Indication Section User Input Section
Material Interaction Yes Yes Yes
Digital Interaction Yes Yes No
Special Interaction Yes No No
Drawing Pattern Section Indication Section User Input Section Handling and controlling system
Material Interaction Yes Yes Yes
Digital Interaction Yes Yes No
Special Interaction No Yes No
Indication Section User Input Section Handling and controlling system Drawing Pattern section
Material Interaction Yes Yes Yes
Digital Interaction Yes No Yes
Special Interaction No Yes No