6.Concept Evaluation And Product Architecture - P-Division-2024-25-Odd/Repo-11 GitHub Wiki

PUGH CHAT

Design Objectives	Weights	Design 1	Design 2	Design 3	Design 4
ease to use	7	+	DATUM	+	+
portability	5	0	DATUM	0	0
cost	6	+	DATUM	-	+
storage of coil	6	+	DATUM	++	-
build quality	9	-	DATUM	+	+


score +		19		28	22
score -		9		6	6
Total		10		22	16

Design no.	Objective	score Allocated	Justification for score
1	ease to use	+	it has digital display and gives clear instructions
	portability	0	heavy to carry
	cost	+	reasonable price for customer
	storage of coil	+	there is proper place to store the winded coils
	build quality	-	its made using wooden board
2	ease to use	DATUM	DATUM
	portability	DATUM	DATUM
	cost	DATUM	DATUM
	storage of coil	DATUM	DATUM
	build quality	DATUM	DATUM
3	ease to use	+	It is operated through single nextion HMI display
	portability	0	Each design are made portable
	cost	-	Since more Motors & sensors are used and option of multicolor is also available it comes with high manufacturing cost
	storage of coil	++	It is stored in spoon or bobbin holder
	build quality	+	Wooden circular board with multiple pegs
4	ease to use	+	It is operated through analogue display
	portability	0	We can carry every where
	cost	+	Not used more motors & sensors
	storage of coil	-	It is stored in bobbin
	build quality	+	It is made using pullies & coil winding bobbin

selected design