2020.04.07 Editors Meeting - OCFL/spec GitHub Wiki

Call-in

See invite

Attendees

  • Julian Morley (Stanford)
  • Rosy Metz (Emory)
  • Simeon Warner (Cornell)
  • Andrew Woods (Lyrasis) *
  • Andrew Hankinson (Bodleian Libraries)
  • Neil Jefferies (Bodleian Libraries)

(* indicates the notetaker)

Agenda and Notes

  1. When does this call happen
  2. Next community meeting demo
  3. PASIG Meeting
    1. Delayed. Who can attend now?
  4. Open Spec Pull Requests and Open Extension Pull Requests
  5. Open 1.0 Spec Issues and Open Extensions Issues
  6. Releasing 1.0
    1. Status of validators
    2. Status of fixture objects
    3. Status of test suite
    4. Two institutions backing the project

Notes

  1. Editors call happens on the 1st and 3rd Tuesday of each month
    • ACTION: Andrew to cancel existing calendar series
    • ACTION: Rosy to create new calendar series
    • Community call is 2nd Wednesday of each month
  2. Tomorrow's community meeting
    • Michael has confirmed availability for demo
    • Additionally, editors updates on progress towards 1.0 release
  3. Open pull-requests
    • None on core spec
    • Extensions has one PR-3
      • Vague concern about over-specification
      • Next editors meeting to focus on PR-3
      • ACTION: All editors to review PR-3
  4. Release of 1.0
    • Validator
      • Goal to consolidate validator efforts around common set of fixtures
    • Fixtures
      • ACTION: Simeon to rename 'objects/' to 'good-objects/'
      • ACTION: Julian to retool for updated error codes
      • ACTION: Julian to align and link validation-codes.md with anchors in spec ...sooner
      • ACTION: Julian to rename bad objects with error codes ...a little later
    • Test suite
      • Embedded in validators
      • In order for a validator to be valid it must identify all error conditions and no others

Action Items

  • Andrew to cancel existing calendar series
  • Rosy to create new calendar series
  • All editors to review PR-3
  • Simeon to rename 'objects/' to 'good-objects/' - done
  • Julian to retool for updated error codes
  • Julian to align and link validation-codes.md with anchors in spec ...sooner
  • Julian to rename bad objects with error codes ...a little later

Previous Action Items

  • AH to create issue for error code consolidation
  • NJ to update Extension Parameters with suggestions - JSON examples, typos