5.Concept evaluation and project architecture. - O-division-2021-2022-Even/Repo-13 GitHub Wiki
Assign weight to the objectives:
| Objectives |
Weights |
| semi-automatic |
5 |
| user friendly |
7 |
| portability |
4 |
| asethetic |
5 |
| Design objectives |
Weight |
Conceptual design 1 |
Conceptual design 2 |
Conceptual design 3 |
Conceptual design 4 |
| Semi-automatic |
5 |
+ |
- |
datum |
+ |
| user friendly |
7 |
- |
+ |
datum |
- |
| Portability |
4 |
+ |
- |
datum |
-- |
| aesthetic |
5 |
- |
- |
datum |
+ |
| Score(+) |
|
9 |
7 |
0 |
10 |
| Score(-) |
|
12 |
14 |
0 |
15 |
| Total |
|
-3 |
-7 |
0 |
-5 |
Justification for the scores given:
| Design No |
Obective |
Score allowted |
Justification for the score |
| 1. |
Semi-automatic |
6 |
dispenses the cards easily |
|
user friendly |
-5 |
little bit complicated |
|
portability |
4 |
the machine is easily portable |
|
aesthetic |
-3 |
not so aesthetically pleasing |
| 2. |
Semi-automatic |
-6 |
comparatively is slow |
|
user friendly |
5 |
easy to use |
|
portability |
-4 |
cannot be easily portable |
|
aesthetic |
-4 |
less attractive |
| 3. |
Semi-automatic |
0 |
datum |
|
user friendly |
0 |
datum |
|
portability |
0 |
datum |
|
aesthetic |
0 |
datum |
| 4. |
Semi-automatic |
6 |
dispenses the cards easily |
|
user friendly |
-5 |
It is a bit complicated |
|
portability |
-8 |
cannot be easily portable |
|
aesthetic |
3 |
attractive |
Justification:
AMONG THE FOUR GENERATED DESIGNS,DESIGN 3 SEEMS TO BE MORE EFFICIENT,AFFORDABLE,MORE RELIABLE,USER FRIENDLY AND HAS BETTER FUNCTIONING AND IS ONE STEP AHEAD IN ALL THE FEATURES.
1.Semi-automatic : dispenses the cards easily.
2.user friendly : easy to use.
3.portability : can be carried
4.aesthetic : aesthetically pleasing.
Sub-system list:
| Sl.No. |
Sub-System |
| 1. |
Handling unit |
| 2. |
Dealing unit |
| 3. |
Sensing unit |
Function clustering:
Interaction of sub-systems:
| Cards handling unit |
Cards dealing unit |
Sensing unit |
| Spatial generation |
No |
No |
| Data |
No |
Yes |
| Material |
Yes |
No |
| Sensing unit |
Cards handling unit |
Cards dealing unit |
| Spatial generation |
No |
No |
| Data |
Yes |
Yes |
| Material |
No |
No |
| Cards dealing unit |
Sensing unit |
Cards handling |
| Spatial generation |
No |
No |
| Data |
Yes |
Yes |
| Material |
No |
Yes |
| Casing unit |
Cards dealing |
Sensing unit |
Cards handling |
| Spatial generation |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
| Data |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
| Material |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |