3. Conceptual Design (ED2) - L-division-2019-2020-Even/Repo-04 GitHub Wiki

1. Function Tree


2. Function Clustering

Sub-systems Identified

1.Remote lighting unit

2.Musical system unit

3.Automatic popping unit


3. Morphological Chart


4.Concept Generation

1.Design 1

2.Design 2

3.Design 3

4.Design 4


5. Concept selection

Weightage to objective

Sl.no Objectives Weightages
1. Appearance 9
2. Portability 7
3. Ease of use 6
4. Interactive 5
5. Cost 3

6. Pugh chart

Objectives Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
Portability + + + Datum
Interactive - - + Datum
Cost + ++ - Datum
Appearance + - ++ Datum
Ease of use - - + Datum
+ score 19 13 27 0
- score -11 -20 -3 0
total 8 -7 24 0

7.Justification

Design idea no Objectives Score given Justification
1 Portability + It can be easily carried
Interactive - It is not much responsive due to usage of PIR sensor
Cost + It is cost-effective
Appearance - It is unique in design
2 Portability + It is easily portable
Interactive - Due to use of LDR it behaves differently in different lighting conditions
Cost ++ It is low in cost
Appearance - It has a very simple design structure
Ease of use + It is very easy to use
3 Portability + It is portable
Interactive + It is very responsive
Cost - It is not cost-effective
Appearance ++ The design is very attractive
Ease of use + It is very easy to use
4 Portability Datum It can be easily portable
Interactive Datum It is very interactive
Cost Datum The materials used are low in cost
Appearance Datum It is very unique in appearance
Ease of use Datum It is user-friendly

8. Selected design