5. Concept Selection - K-Division-2020-21-Even/Repo-10 GitHub Wiki

PUGH CHART

Objectives Weightage Design 1 Design 220210728_095006360 Design 3 Design 4 Design 5
Cost 5 DATUM - ++ + -
Setup 6 DATUM 0 + + ++
Maintainence 4 DATUM + + + +
Portability 9 DATUM + 0 + -
Speed 6 DATUM + 0 0 -
Safety 8 DATUM + -- - -
Score(+) 0 27 26 15 22
Score(-) 0 5 16 17 26
Total 0 22 4 -2 -4

Justification

Design No Objecyive Score Alloted Justification
1 Cost 0 DATUM
Maintenance 0 DATUM
Safety 0 DATUM
Portability 0 DATUM
Speed 0 DATUM
2 Cost -5 It is much costlier compare to other designs
Maintenance 4 Maintenance will not be easy
Safety 8 Very safe due to design
Portability 9 Small and portable
Speed 6
3 Cost 10 Design will cost less
Setup 6 Setup will be easy
Maintenance 4 Not much maintenance required
Safety -16 Not much safe due to design
Portability -9 Not easily portable
Speed 6
4 Cost 5 Design will cast less
Setup 6 Setup will be less complicated
Maintenance 4 Maintenance will be easy
Safety -8 Not very safe design
Portability -9 Not easy to carry due to size
Speed 0
5 Cost -5 Will cost more
Setup 12 Setup will be easy
Maintenance 4 Maintenance will be easy
Safety -8 Not very safe
Portability -18 Not very portable
Speed 6

Best Design:

Design Number : 220210728_095006360