5. Concept Selection - K-Division-2020-21-Even/Repo-10 GitHub Wiki

PUGH CHART

Objectives	Weightage	Design 1	Design 2	Design 3	Design 4	Design 5
Cost	5	DATUM	-	++	+	-
Setup	6	DATUM	0	+	+	++
Maintainence	4	DATUM	+	+	+	+
Portability	9	DATUM	+	0	+	-
Speed	6	DATUM	+	0	0	-
Safety	8	DATUM	+	--	-	-
Score(+)		0	27	26	15	22
Score(-)		0	5	16	17	26
Total		0	22	4	-2	-4

Justification

Design No	Objecyive	Score Alloted	Justification
1	Cost	0	DATUM
	Maintenance	0	DATUM
	Safety	0	DATUM
	Portability	0	DATUM
	Speed	0	DATUM
2	Cost	-5	It is much costlier compare to other designs
	Maintenance	4	Maintenance will not be easy
	Safety	8	Very safe due to design
	Portability	9	Small and portable
	Speed	6
3	Cost	10	Design will cost less
	Setup	6	Setup will be easy
	Maintenance	4	Not much maintenance required
	Safety	-16	Not much safe due to design
	Portability	-9	Not easily portable
	Speed	6
4	Cost	5	Design will cast less
	Setup	6	Setup will be less complicated
	Maintenance	4	Maintenance will be easy
	Safety	-8	Not very safe design
	Portability	-9	Not easy to carry due to size
	Speed	0
5	Cost	-5	Will cost more
	Setup	12	Setup will be easy
	Maintenance	4	Maintenance will be easy
	Safety	-8	Not very safe
	Portability	-18	Not very portable
	Speed	6

Best Design:

Design Number : 2