meeting 2024 05 06 n57 - JacobPilawa/TriaxSchwarzschild_wiki_5 GitHub Wiki

N315 Nu10 Calculation

N315 HDC Member Table (After Cuts)
Neighbor # Name RA Dec Group Distance Distance in LDC Separation K [LDC] Mk [LDC] Matched K Matched K_tc Av k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av Mk [K_tc & Group D] Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
0 NGC 0315 14.4537 30.3522 68.1 69.7567 0 8.03 -26.1357 8.027 7.932 0.177 7.95147 -26.2337 -26.2859
1 NGC 0311 14.3858 30.2808 68.1 71.2689 0.11 9.8 -24.3657 9.797 9.712 0.177 9.73147 -24.4537 -24.5525
2 NGC 0318 14.5213 30.4256 68.1 74.6581 0.111 10.97 -23.1957 10.967 10.882 0.177 10.9015 -23.2837 -23.4834
3 NGC 0338 15.1517 30.6689 68.1 67.3477 0.808 9.31 -24.8557 9.312 9.24 0.177 9.25947 -24.9257 -24.9016
4 IC 0066 15.1354 30.7972 68.1 67.9317 0.875 10.85 -23.3157 10.852 10.722 0.177 10.7415 -23.4437 -23.4384
5 IC 0069 15.3483 31.0408 68.1 70.6119 1.227 11.12 -23.0457 11.118 10.84 0.177 10.8595 -23.3257 -23.4044
N315 LDC Member Table (After Cuts)
Neighbor # Name RA Dec Group Distance Distance in LDC Separation K [LDC] Mk [LDC] Matched K Matched K_tc Av k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av Mk [K_tc & Group D] Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
0 NGC 0315 14.4537 30.3522 68.1 69.7567 0 8.03 -26.1357 8.027 7.932 0.177 7.95147 -26.2337 -26.2859
1 NGC 0311 14.3858 30.2808 68.1 71.2689 0.11 9.8 -24.3657 9.797 9.712 0.177 9.73147 -24.4537 -24.5525
2 NGC 0318 14.5213 30.4256 68.1 74.6581 0.111 10.97 -23.1957 10.967 10.882 0.177 10.9015 -23.2837 -23.4834
3 NGC 0338 15.1517 30.6689 68.1 67.3477 0.808 9.31 -24.8557 9.312 9.24 0.177 9.25947 -24.9257 -24.9016
4 IC 0066 15.1354 30.7972 68.1 67.9317 0.875 10.85 -23.3157 10.852 10.722 0.177 10.7415 -23.4437 -23.4384
5 IC 0069 15.3483 31.0408 68.1 70.6119 1.227 11.12 -23.0457 11.118 10.84 0.177 10.8595 -23.3257 -23.4044
6 UGC 00598 14.4583 31.4847 68.1 70.4867 1.346 10.16 -24.0057 10.164 10.035 0.177 10.0545 -24.1307 -24.2055
7 UGC 00556 13.7096 29.2467 68.1 65.1681 1.522 10.4 -23.7657 10.392 10.298 0.177 10.3175 -23.8677 -23.7722
8 NGC 0296 13.7812 31.5422 68.1 76.7856 1.572 9.22 -24.9457 9.216 9.115 0.177 9.13447 -25.0507 -25.3114
9 UGC 00633 15.3379 31.5078 68.1 78.4124 1.643 11.01 -23.1557 11.009 10.741 0.177 10.7605 -23.4247 -23.7309
10 CGCG 501-034 13.3958 31.4197 68.1 76.9316 1.666 11.05 -23.1157 11.054 10.771 0.177 10.7905 -23.3947 -23.6595
11 UGC 00542 13.3604 29.2703 68.1 63.4891 1.71 10.17 -23.9957 10.173 10.087 0.177 10.1065 -24.0787 -23.9265
12 UGC 00540 13.2429 29.0325 68.1 70.0904 2.006 11.19 -22.9757 11.186 11.076 0.177 11.0955 -23.0897 -23.1523
13 UGC 00669 16.3292 31.6819 68.1 82.3336 2.479 11.11 -23.0557 11.108 10.975 0.177 10.9945 -23.1907 -23.6029
14 UGC 00646 15.86 32.2372 68.1 74.5747 2.657 10.53 -23.6357 10.533 10.402 0.177 10.4215 -23.7637 -23.961
15 CGCG 501-070 15.5421 32.4517 68.1 59.7974 2.728 10.78 -23.3857 10.782 10.714 0.177 10.7335 -23.4517 -23.1694
16 NGC 0287 13.3679 32.4822 68.1 77.6199 2.761 10.57 -23.5957 10.575 10.459 0.177 10.4785 -23.7067 -23.9909
17 CGCG 501-077 16.3921 32.4297 68.1 72.5203 3.156 11.21 -22.9557 11.212 10.902 0.177 10.9215 -23.2637 -23.4003
18 NGC 0384 16.8542 32.2928 68.1 60.4753 3.355 10.09 -24.0757 10.093 10.006 0.177 10.0255 -24.1597 -23.9019
19 NGC 0385 16.8629 32.3197 68.1 70.0487 3.383 10.06 -24.1057 10.058 9.898 0.177 9.91747 -24.2677 -24.329
20 UGC 00501 12.2583 28.2181 68.1 71.5921 3.407 10.82 -23.3457 10.82 10.719 0.177 10.7385 -23.4467 -23.5553
21 NGC 0383 16.8538 32.4125 68.1 71.394 3.453 8.57 -25.5957 8.574 8.456 0.177 8.47547 -25.7097 -25.8123
22 CGCG 501-102 17.3062 31.9794 68.1 72.8019 3.486 11.13 -23.0357 11.126 11 0.177 11.0195 -23.1657 -23.3107
23 NGC 0380 16.8229 32.4828 68.1 62.2481 3.49 9.36 -24.8057 9.358 9.236 0.177 9.25547 -24.9297 -24.7346
24 NGC 0379 16.815 32.5203 68.1 77.2861 3.517 9.44 -24.7257 9.436 9.369 0.177 9.38847 -24.7967 -25.0715
25 UGC 00714 17.3083 32.1514 68.1 65.3871 3.603 11.23 -22.9357 11.231 10.9 0.177 10.9195 -23.2657 -23.1775
26 NGC 0374 16.7742 32.7953 68.1 70.8621 3.735 10.11 -24.0557 10.107 9.961 0.177 9.98047 -24.2047 -24.2911
27 UGC 00743 17.8271 31.8886 68.1 73.5631 3.887 10.57 -23.5957 10.574 10.406 0.177 10.4255 -23.7597 -23.9273
28 UGC 00724 17.4971 32.3683 68.1 72.8227 3.908 10.49 -23.6757 10.489 10.335 0.177 10.3545 -23.8307 -23.9763
29 NGC 0399 17.2462 32.6344 68.1 72.7393 3.919 10.4 -23.7657 10.404 10.197 0.177 10.2165 -23.9687 -24.1118
30 IC 1584 11.8271 27.8278 68.1 67.0453 4.054 10.52 -23.6457 10.524 9.96 0.177 9.97947 -24.2057 -24.1718
31 NGC 0403 17.3087 32.7522 68.1 71.6651 4.061 9.39 -24.7757 9.386 9.282 0.177 9.30147 -24.8837 -24.9945
32 NGC 0252 12.0062 27.6239 68.1 70.1843 4.121 9.15 -25.0157 9.145 9.023 0.177 9.04247 -25.1427 -25.2082
33 NGC 0420 18.04 32.1231 68.1 69.6837 4.208 9.69 -24.4757 9.695 9.516 0.177 9.53547 -24.6497 -24.6997
34 NGC 0392 17.0971 33.1336 68.1 66.211 4.249 9.65 -24.5157 9.648 9.535 0.177 9.55447 -24.6307 -24.5697
35 NGC 0394 17.1088 33.1481 68.1 62.3941 4.27 10.62 -23.5457 10.617 10.547 0.177 10.5665 -23.6187 -23.4287
36 CGCG 501-120 17.7971 32.7017 68.1 72.5411 4.389 10.97 -23.1957 10.97 10.736 0.177 10.7555 -23.4297 -23.5669
37 IC 1654 18.7992 30.195 68.1 68.839 4.463 10.99 -23.1757 10.992 10.471 0.177 10.4905 -23.6947 -23.7182
38 UGC 00697 17.0192 33.4533 68.1 66.2736 4.503 11.11 -23.0557 11.108 10.925 0.177 10.9445 -23.2407 -23.1817
39 NGC 0407 17.6525 33.1264 68.1 78.4229 4.617 9.86 -24.3057 9.861 9.781 0.177 9.80047 -24.3847 -24.6912
40 NGC 0410 17.745 33.1519 68.1 74.533 4.704 8.47 -25.6957 8.471 8.359 0.177 8.37847 -25.8067 -26.0027
41 NGC 0414 NED01 17.8221 33.1139 68.1 76.7647 4.728 10.45 -23.7157 10.448 10.352 0.177 10.3715 -23.8137 -24.0738
42 IC 1652 18.7346 31.9486 68.1 72.8123 4.748 10.53 -23.6357 10.534 10.436 0.177 10.4555 -23.7297 -23.875
43 NGC 0452 19.0617 31.0339 68.1 69.7776 4.777 9.64 -24.5257 9.636 9.557 0.177 9.57647 -24.6087 -24.6616
44 CGCG 501-119 17.7817 33.2269 68.1 67.9839 4.792 11.12 -23.0457 11.117 10.991 0.177 11.0105 -23.1747 -23.171
45 IC 1636 NED01 17.9062 33.3542 68.1 80.1123 4.986 11.23 -22.9357 11.234 11.128 0.177 11.1475 -23.0377 -23.3905
46 IC 1638 18.0908 33.3642 68.1 67.7961 5.126 10.74 -23.4257 10.74 10.48 0.177 10.4995 -23.6857 -23.676
47 IC 1648 18.4254 33.2181 68.1 78.037 5.261 11.22 -22.9457 11.223 11.152 0.177 11.1715 -23.0137 -23.3095
48 NGC 0447 18.9067 33.0678 68.1 78.7357 5.537 9.73 -24.4357 9.729 9.459 0.177 9.47847 -24.7067 -25.0219
49 NGC 0443 18.7817 33.3775 68.1 67.4207 5.656 10.55 -23.6157 10.546 10.357 0.177 10.3765 -23.8087 -23.787
50 IC 1666 19.9721 32.4675 68.1 68.6826 6.133 11.06 -23.1057 11.061 10.723 0.177 10.7425 -23.4427 -23.4612
51 NGC 0472 20.1192 32.7089 68.1 74.7207 6.383 10.33 -23.8357 10.326 10.168 0.177 10.1875 -23.9977 -24.1992
52 UGC 00901 20.4054 32.6061 68.1 66.8054 6.597 10.94 -23.2257 10.939 10.874 0.177 10.8935 -23.2917 -23.2501
53 IC 1673 20.1929 33.0447 68.1 71.6339 6.623 10.96 -23.2057 10.958 10.912 0.177 10.9315 -23.2537 -23.3636
54 UGC 00862 20.0546 33.5064 68.1 73.0521 6.776 11.11 -23.0557 11.115 10.909 0.177 10.9285 -23.2567 -23.4092
55 IC 1680 20.4629 33.2825 68.1 62.561 6.992 11.08 -23.0857 11.08 10.974 0.177 10.9935 -23.1917 -23.0075
56 IC 1682 20.5546 33.2603 68.1 61.904 7.06 10.71 -23.4557 10.712 10.597 0.177 10.6165 -23.5687 -23.3616
57 NGC 0483 20.4846 33.5208 68.1 84.3359 7.149 10.05 -24.1157 10.048 9.926 0.177 9.94547 -24.2397 -24.7041
58 NGC 0494 20.7304 33.1739 68.1 76.8273 7.17 9.45 -24.7157 9.454 9.368 0.177 9.38747 -24.7977 -25.0596
59 UGC 00878 20.2625 33.8983 68.1 56.9087 7.202 9.73 -24.4357 9.728 9.649 0.177 9.66847 -24.5167 -24.1269
60 IC 1689 20.9492 33.0553 68.1 64.3234 7.306 11.01 -23.1557 11.011 10.837 0.177 10.8565 -23.3287 -23.2048
61 NGC 0504 20.8658 33.2042 68.1 59.5993 7.306 10.15 -24.0157 10.155 10.053 0.177 10.0725 -24.1127 -23.8232
62 IC 1687 20.8296 33.2775 68.1 70.6431 7.313 10.93 -23.2357 10.931 10.785 0.177 10.8045 -23.3807 -23.4604
63 NGC 0495 20.7333 33.4714 68.1 58.0663 7.335 10.09 -24.0757 10.091 9.94 0.177 9.95947 -24.2257 -23.8796
64 UGC 00987 21.3813 32.1364 68.1 65.554 7.347 10.04 -24.1257 10.041 9.987 0.177 10.0065 -24.1787 -24.096
65 IC 1690 20.9563 33.1561 68.1 64.2609 7.363 11.15 -23.0157 11.145 10.999 0.177 11.0185 -23.1667 -23.0407
66 NGC 0503 20.8687 33.3317 68.1 84.2524 7.376 11.23 -22.9357 11.23 11.046 0.177 11.0655 -23.1197 -23.5819
67 NGC 0507 20.9158 33.2561 68.1 69.4543 7.378 8.45 -25.7157 8.446 8.28 0.177 8.29947 -25.8857 -25.9285
68 NGC 0499 20.7971 33.46 68.1 62.0187 7.384 8.81 -25.3557 8.809 8.71 0.177 8.72947 -25.4557 -25.2526
69 NGC 0508 20.9192 33.2806 68.1 77.7241 7.394 9.8 -24.3657 9.802 9.703 0.177 9.72247 -24.4627 -24.7498
70 NGC 0501 20.8429 33.4328 68.1 70.5284 7.409 11.21 -22.9557 11.21 11.09 0.177 11.1095 -23.0757 -23.1518
71 NGC 0496 20.7983 33.5292 68.1 84.4297 7.424 11.14 -23.0257 11.136 10.702 0.177 10.7215 -23.4637 -23.9305
72 IC 1675 20.2492 34.2486 68.1 71.8841 7.433 10.57 -23.5957 10.566 10.51 0.177 10.5295 -23.6557 -23.7732
73 ARK 039 20.9937 33.3133 68.1 70.81 7.477 11.25 -22.9157 11.251 11.118 0.177 11.1375 -23.0477 -23.1325
74 NGC 0517 21.1825 33.4294 68.1 58.8067 7.706 9.88 -24.2857 9.876 9.769 0.177 9.78847 -24.3967 -24.0781
75 NGC 0515 21.1604 33.4725 68.1 76.6396 7.71 9.98 -24.1857 9.985 9.847 0.177 9.86647 -24.3187 -24.5753
76 NGC 0512 20.9983 33.9078 68.1 68.5679 7.819 9.8 -24.3657 9.797 9.748 0.177 9.76747 -24.4177 -24.4326
77 NGC 0513 21.1117 33.7994 68.1 82.1459 7.851 9.93 -24.2357 9.929 9.892 0.177 9.91147 -24.2737 -24.6809
78 IC 1683 20.6617 34.4369 68.1 68.3489 7.891 10.46 -23.7057 10.464 10.377 0.177 10.3965 -23.7887 -23.7967
79 UGC 00913 20.5625 34.6689 68.1 72.6663 7.981 11.14 -23.0257 11.143 11.067 0.177 11.0865 -23.0987 -23.2397
80 NGC 0528 21.39 33.6714 68.1 68.7034 8.019 9.64 -24.5257 9.64 9.559 0.177 9.57847 -24.6067 -24.6259
81 NGC 0523 21.3358 34.0253 68.1 67.0349 8.176 9.77 -24.3957 9.771 9.695 0.177 9.71447 -24.4707 -24.4365
82 NGC 0529 21.4179 34.7131 68.1 68.5157 8.683 9.21 -24.9557 9.206 9.093 0.177 9.11247 -25.0727 -25.086
83 NGC 0536 21.5908 34.7031 68.1 73.0626 8.816 9.34 -24.8257 9.339 9.224 0.177 9.24347 -24.9417 -25.0945
84 NGC 0531 21.5783 34.7542 68.1 65.7 8.839 10.62 -23.5457 10.618 10.492 0.177 10.5115 -23.6737 -23.5958
85 NGC 0561 22.0783 34.3086 68.1 65.8564 8.975 10.21 -23.9557 10.211 10.063 0.177 10.0825 -24.1027 -24.03
86 NGC 0582 22.9917 33.4764 68.1 61.2574 9.369 9.86 -24.3057 9.858 9.766 0.177 9.78547 -24.3997 -24.1698
87 NGC 0579 22.9438 33.6156 68.1 70.2781 9.385 10.64 -23.5257 10.635 10.336 0.177 10.3555 -23.8297 -23.8981
88 NGC 0608 23.8671 33.6567 68.1 72.5516 10.254 10.03 -24.1357 10.03 9.921 0.177 9.94047 -24.2447 -24.3822
89 NGC 0614 23.9679 33.6819 68.1 71.1854 10.357 9.89 -24.2757 9.889 9.767 0.177 9.78647 -24.3987 -24.495
90 NGC 0587 23.1388 35.3586 68.1 63.8333 10.499 9.97 -24.1957 9.968 9.808 0.177 9.82747 -24.3577 -24.2172
91 NGC 0591 23.3796 35.6681 68.1 64.24 10.892 10.17 -23.9957 10.172 10.047 0.177 10.0665 -24.1187 -23.992
92 NGC 0621 24.2042 35.5122 68.1 72.7184 11.476 9.84 -24.3257 9.84 9.696 0.177 9.71547 -24.4697 -24.6122
93 UGC 01166 24.645 34.9919 68.1 67.4311 11.569 10.43 -23.7357 10.432 10.348 0.177 10.3675 -23.8177 -23.7963
94 NGC 0634 24.5775 35.3647 68.1 69.4021 11.709 9.77 -24.3957 9.774 9.714 0.177 9.73347 -24.4517 -24.4929
95 UGC 01178 25.1158 34.6253 68.1 77.4113 11.811 10.54 -23.6257 10.536 10.45 0.177 10.4695 -23.7157 -23.994
96 NGC 0653 25.6067 35.6383 68.1 76.9837 12.74 10.04 -24.1257 10.042 9.987 0.177 10.0065 -24.1787 -24.445
NGC 0315: Nu10 Calculation
Neighbor # Name RA Dec Group Distance Distance in LDC Separation K [LDC] Mk [LDC] Matched K Matched K_tc Av k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av Mk [K_tc & Group D] Mk [K_tc & Individual D] numerator denominator nu_i rho_i
1 0 NGC 0315 14.4537 30.3522 68.1 69.7567 0 8.03 -26.1357 8.027 7.932 0.177 7.95147 -26.2337 -26.2859 0 nan nan nan
2 1 NGC 0311 14.3858 30.2808 68.1 71.2689 0.109797 9.8 -24.3657 9.797 9.712 0.177 9.73147 -24.4537 -24.5525 1.25168e+11 0.00554437 2.25757e+13 180.363
3 2 NGC 0318 14.5213 30.4256 68.1 74.6581 0.111421 10.97 -23.1957 10.967 10.882 0.177 10.9015 -23.2837 -23.4834 1.67777e+11 0.00579402 2.89569e+13 345.184
4 3 NGC 0338 15.1517 30.6689 68.1 67.3477 0.807803 9.31 -24.8557 9.312 9.24 0.177 9.25947 -24.9257 -24.9016 3.61104e+11 2.20797 1.63546e+11 1.35871
5 4 IC 0066 15.1354 30.7972 68.1 67.9317 0.875427 10.85 -23.3157 10.852 10.722 0.177 10.7415 -23.4437 -23.4384 4.10478e+11 2.8102 1.46067e+11 1.42338
6 5 IC 0069 15.3483 31.0408 68.1 70.6119 1.22709 11.12 -23.0457 11.118 10.84 0.177 10.8595 -23.3257 -23.4044 4.54767e+11 7.73942 5.87598e+10 0.646043
7 6 UGC 00598 14.4583 31.4847 68.1 70.4867 1.34604 10.16 -24.0057 10.164 10.035 0.177 10.0545 -24.1307 -24.2055 5.47726e+11 10.2153 5.36181e+10 0.587352
8 7 UGC 00556 13.7096 29.2467 68.1 65.1681 1.52163 10.4 -23.7657 10.392 10.298 0.177 10.3175 -23.8677 -23.7722 6.20688e+11 14.7574 4.20595e+10 0.474339
9 8 NGC 0296 13.7812 31.5422 68.1 76.7856 1.57172 9.22 -24.9457 9.216 9.115 0.177 9.13447 -25.0507 -25.3114 8.37605e+11 16.2632 5.1503e+10 0.491907
10 9 UGC 00633 15.3379 31.5078 68.1 78.4124 1.64287 11.01 -23.1557 11.009 10.741 0.177 10.7605 -23.4247 -23.7309 8.86122e+11 18.5732 4.77098e+10 0.48457
11 10 CGCG 501-034 13.3958 31.4197 68.1 76.9316 1.66555 11.05 -23.1157 11.054 10.771 0.177 10.7905 -23.3947 -23.6595 9.33317e+11 19.3529 4.82261e+10 0.516717
  • And here's the updated environmental plot with NGC 315 added on:
Plot

Trying Kinemetry Still

  • Last time, I had been running the global PA code from Capppellari, but I found an additiona kinemetry code (in Python) from Krajnovic, which I think is how kinemetry was run for MASSIVE X.

  • I've been trying to reproduce Irina's work with mixed success -- I'm having trouble getting the same outer PA as she quotes in the paper, but the coefficients for the kinemetry fit are quite close:

  • Here are the plots she had posted on BOX:

Plot 1 Plot2
  • And here are my attempts with and without the outer 4 Mitchell bins:
with without

Other Miscellaneous Plots

Plot
⚠️ **GitHub.com Fallback** ⚠️