meeting 2024 04 09 n57 - JacobPilawa/TriaxSchwarzschild_wiki_5 GitHub Wiki
Context
Summary
Here's a comparison of nu10 before and after correcting the distances to the SBF distances. The results are very consistent with one another, with the exception being N57 due to the large change in separation coming from the updated distance to the 10th neighbor.
Plot
Old Tables (HDC Distances)
First, I've added two columns to the tables we were looking at in our last meeting (for the group distances) which tabulates the numerator and denominator when computing nu10 for our galaxies.
In the tables below, the numerator is exactly how the numerator is defined here. The denominator in the tables is not 4/3 pi r10^3 but rather the enclosed volume out to that specific galaxy rather than always to the 10th neighbor.
As a quick reminder, if the galaxy is not in the HDC/LDC group, I assume it's at the same individual distance given in the 2MRS catalog.
Group Distances
NGC 1277
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 1277
49.9646
41.5733
77.538
70.6223
0
9.85
-24.5976
9.852
9.755
0.452
9.80472
-24.6926
-24.4897
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
NGC 1278
49.9758
41.5633
77.538
85.8271
0.018
9.2
-25.2476
9.196
9.107
0.452
9.15672
-25.3406
-25.5611
1.5597e+11
2.44284e-05
6.38476e+15
40935.9
3
3
2
WISEA J031947.80+413546.8
49.9487
41.5964
77.538
105.339
0.035
10.8
-23.6476
10.797
10.694
0.452
10.7437
-23.7536
-24.4189
4.39265e+11
0.00017959
2.44594e+15
11136.5
4
4
3
V Zw 339
50.0033
41.5536
77.538
73.584
0.047
11.24
-23.2076
11.238
11.171
0.452
11.2207
-23.2766
-23.1629
5.04946e+11
0.000434882
1.16111e+15
6898.42
5
5
4
NGC 1274
49.9188
41.5486
77.538
90.7599
0.057
10.51
-23.9376
10.514
10.442
0.452
10.4917
-24.0056
-24.3475
5.47276e+11
0.000775715
7.05511e+14
5156.53
6
6
5
CGCG 540-101
49.8925
41.5806
77.538
64.0106
0.074
10.06
-24.3876
10.062
9.952
0.452
10.0017
-24.4956
-24.0793
6.30116e+11
0.00169736
3.71234e+14
2945.76
7
7
6
NGC 1275
49.9508
41.5117
77.538
74.6686
0.085
8.35
-26.0976
8.353
8.068
0.452
8.11772
-26.3796
-26.2977
7.60204e+11
0.00257238
2.95526e+14
2332.47
8
8
7
NGC 1281
50.0254
41.63
77.538
61.2366
0.098
10.09
-24.3576
10.085
10.005
0.452
10.0547
-24.4426
-23.9301
1.49784e+12
0.00394236
3.79934e+14
1775.59
9
9
8
NGC 1273
49.8612
41.5406
77.538
76.3893
0.114
9.89
-24.5576
9.889
9.774
0.452
9.82372
-24.6736
-24.6412
1.62173e+12
0.00620572
2.61328e+14
1289.13
10
10
9
NGC 1279
49.9963
41.4794
77.538
102.867
0.131
10.83
-23.6176
10.83
10.663
0.452
10.7127
-23.7846
-24.3984
1.77499e+12
0.00941655
1.88497e+14
955.764
11
11
10
UGC 02665
49.8633
41.6353
77.538
110.032
0.132
11.24
-23.2076
11.239
11.089
0.452
11.1387
-23.3586
-24.1186
1.84258e+12
0.00963384
1.91261e+14
1038.01
NGC 1407
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 1407
55.0492
-18.5803
22.854
24.9034
0
6.83
-24.9648
6.831
6.678
0.187
6.69857
-25.1168
-25.3033
0
nan
nan
nan
2
10
9
NGC 1440
56.2617
-18.2661
22.854
21.4724
0.476
8.25
-23.5448
8.247
8.166
0.187
8.18657
-23.6288
-23.4934
2.30526e+11
0.45175
5.10295e+11
2.21361
3
11
10
NGC 1452
56.3425
-18.6336
22.854
24.3299
0.489
8.74
-23.0548
8.74
8.639
0.187
8.65957
-23.1558
-23.2917
2.89075e+11
0.489784
5.9021e+11
4.08344
4
20
19
NGC 1461
57.1129
-16.3931
22.854
20.3253
1.174
8.41
-23.3848
8.406
8.322
0.187
8.34257
-23.4728
-23.2182
3.26947e+11
6.7777
4.82387e+10
0.442628
5
21
20
NGC 1353
53.0125
-20.8192
22.854
21.2743
1.176
8.19
-23.6048
8.192
8.097
0.187
8.11757
-23.6978
-23.5423
3.7766e+11
6.81239
5.54372e+10
0.587165
6
27
26
NGC 1439
56.2083
-21.9206
22.854
23.36
1.401
8.72
-23.0748
8.718
8.561
0.187
8.58157
-23.2338
-23.2814
4.40051e+11
11.5184
3.82042e+10
0.434088
7
28
27
NGC 1426
55.7046
-22.1083
22.854
20.1376
1.428
8.76
-23.0348
8.756
8.665
0.187
8.68557
-23.1298
-22.855
4.80744e+11
12.1973
3.94141e+10
0.491914
8
29
28
NGC 1415
55.2367
-22.5644
22.854
22.1399
1.59
8.38
-23.4148
8.379
8.281
0.187
8.30157
-23.5138
-23.4449
5.1772e+11
16.8372
3.07486e+10
0.415747
9
35
34
NGC 1332
51.5717
-21.3353
22.854
21.243
1.705
7.11
-24.6848
7.111
7.041
0.187
7.06157
-24.7538
-24.5951
5.70385e+11
20.7611
2.74737e+10
0.385336
10
36
35
NGC 1395
54.6238
-23.0278
22.854
23.2453
1.781
7.02
-24.7748
7.016
6.886
0.187
6.90657
-24.9088
-24.9457
7.35399e+11
23.663
3.1078e+10
0.380341
11
38
37
NGC 1325
51.1067
-21.5442
22.854
22.1399
1.891
8.82
-22.9748
8.823
8.619
0.187
8.63957
-23.1758
-23.1069
9.25734e+11
28.3239
3.26839e+10
0.353059
NGC 1600
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 1600
67.9158
-5.0861
63.773
67.2434
0
8.13
-25.8932
8.128
8.026
0.118
8.03898
-25.9972
-26.1122
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
NGC 1601
67.9237
-5.0603
63.773
70.5806
0.03
10.95
-23.0732
10.948
10.858
0.118
10.871
-23.1652
-23.3854
5.18657e+11
0.000113095
4.58605e+15
8842.16
3
3
2
NGC 1603
67.9575
-5.0944
63.773
72.27
0.047
10.85
-23.1732
10.848
10.69
0.118
10.703
-23.3332
-23.6048
5.56858e+11
0.000434882
1.28048e+15
4598.95
4
4
3
NGC 1604
67.9942
-5.3697
63.773
64.2087
0.327
10
-24.0232
10.004
9.877
0.118
9.88998
-24.1462
-24.161
6.01453e+11
0.146461
4.10658e+12
20.4833
5
5
4
IC 0373
67.6779
-4.8703
63.773
56.7419
0.357
10.32
-23.7032
10.316
10.177
0.118
10.19
-23.8462
-23.5925
6.95746e+11
0.190582
3.65063e+12
20.9883
6
6
5
IC 0372
67.5175
-5.01
63.773
58.9423
0.45
10.9
-23.1232
10.903
10.809
0.118
10.822
-23.2142
-23.0431
7.67274e+11
0.381694
2.01018e+12
13.0995
7
8
7
NGC 1607
68.0129
-4.46
63.773
60.1416
0.705
10.87
-23.1532
10.867
10.692
0.118
10.705
-23.3312
-23.2039
8.07239e+11
1.46773
5.49993e+11
4.08796
8
9
8
IC 2080
67.9671
-5.7569
63.773
58.0246
0.749
10.85
-23.1732
10.852
10.755
0.118
10.768
-23.2682
-23.0631
8.51752e+11
1.76004
4.83938e+11
3.97718
9
10
9
NGC 1594
67.715
-5.7983
63.773
61.1844
0.823
10.26
-23.7632
10.259
9.881
0.118
9.89398
-24.1422
-24.0522
8.93755e+11
2.33495
3.82773e+11
3.4262
10
11
10
NGC 1609
68.1879
-4.3725
63.773
61.1636
0.85
9.74
-24.2832
9.744
9.621
0.118
9.63398
-24.4022
-24.3115
9.87701e+11
2.57238
3.83964e+11
3.49871
11
12
11
NGC 1580
67.0771
-5.1789
63.773
60.2667
0.936
10.5
-23.5232
10.497
10.362
0.118
10.375
-23.6612
-23.5384
1.10707e+12
3.43483
3.22306e+11
2.91135
NGC 3842
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 3842
176.009
19.9497
99.39
95.3484
0
9.2
-25.7867
9.201
9.074
0.059
9.08049
-25.9127
-25.8226
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
NGC 3841
176.009
19.9717
99.39
97.163
0.038
10.91
-24.0767
10.909
10.561
0.059
10.5675
-24.4257
-24.3765
4.79822e+11
0.000229842
2.08762e+15
4350.82
3
3
2
NGC 3845
176.023
19.9961
99.39
87.5061
0.084
11.07
-23.9167
11.069
10.96
0.059
10.9665
-24.0267
-23.7502
6.01799e+11
0.00248265
2.42402e+14
805.591
4
4
3
UGC 06697
175.954
19.9683
99.39
102.367
0.095
10.76
-24.2267
10.759
10.661
0.059
10.6675
-24.3257
-24.3898
6.86265e+11
0.00359127
1.91092e+14
835.358
5
5
4
NGC 3837
175.985
19.8944
99.39
95.9637
0.103
10.06
-24.9267
10.063
9.947
0.059
9.95349
-25.0397
-24.9635
7.9751e+11
0.00457709
1.7424e+14
873.918
6
6
5
NGC 3851
176.085
19.9808
99.39
98.6856
0.136
11.12
-23.8667
11.124
11.009
0.059
11.0155
-23.9777
-23.9623
1.01223e+12
0.0105365
9.60697e+13
474.543
7
7
6
NGC 3844
176.002
20.0292
99.39
103.942
0.138
10.89
-24.0967
10.888
10.792
0.059
10.7985
-24.1947
-24.2919
1.09297e+12
0.0110082
9.92874e+13
545.05
8
8
7
CGCG 097-101
176.079
19.8447
99.39
97.3611
0.215
11.11
-23.8767
11.114
10.992
0.059
10.9985
-23.9947
-23.9499
1.19157e+12
0.0416287
2.86238e+13
168.153
9
9
8
NGC 3840
175.996
20.0769
99.39
111.627
0.222
11.14
-23.8467
11.135
10.886
0.059
10.8925
-24.1007
-24.3529
1.27359e+12
0.0458286
2.77902e+13
174.563
10
10
9
CGCG 097-112
176.127
20.0767
99.39
102.607
0.293
10.99
-23.9967
10.991
10.921
0.059
10.9275
-24.0657
-24.1349
1.36401e+12
0.105361
1.2946e+13
85.4205
11
11
10
NGC 3860
176.205
19.795
99.39
86.1087
0.417
10.52
-24.4667
10.517
10.394
0.059
10.4005
-24.5927
-24.2812
1.45156e+12
0.303729
4.77914e+12
32.9241
NGC 4486
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
MESSIER 087
187.706
12.3911
20.788
20.5756
0
5.9
-25.6891
5.896
5.804
0.063
5.81093
-25.7851
-25.7628
0
nan
nan
nan
2
4
3
NGC 4478
187.572
12.3286
20.788
19.8351
0.052
8.4
-23.1891
8.396
8.346
0.063
8.35293
-23.2431
-23.1412
4.26619e+11
0.000588963
7.24356e+14
1697.9
3
12
11
NGC 4461
187.262
13.1839
20.788
21.0344
0.328
8.09
-23.4991
8.088
8.006
0.063
8.01293
-23.5831
-23.6087
4.67662e+11
0.147808
3.16397e+12
13.531
4
16
15
NGC 4438
186.94
13.0086
20.788
19.2303
0.352
7.37
-24.2191
7.374
7.255
0.063
7.26193
-24.3341
-24.1649
5.23798e+11
0.182686
2.8672e+12
16.4216
5
17
16
NGC 4435
186.919
13.0789
20.788
19.3033
0.374
7.39
-24.1991
7.385
7.287
0.063
7.29393
-24.3021
-24.1412
6.35907e+11
0.219125
2.90202e+12
18.2544
6
18
17
NGC 4473
187.454
13.4294
20.788
21.2951
0.387
7.26
-24.3291
7.259
7.147
0.063
7.15393
-24.4421
-24.4944
7.44759e+11
0.242779
3.06765e+12
20.5949
7
25
24
MESSIER 089
188.916
12.5561
20.788
20.2106
0.433
6.84
-24.7491
6.84
6.713
0.063
6.71993
-24.8761
-24.8149
8.68594e+11
0.340049
2.55432e+12
17.6445
8
26
25
NGC 4503
188.025
11.1764
20.788
20.4296
0.455
7.96
-23.6291
7.962
7.871
0.063
7.87793
-23.7181
-23.6803
1.05328e+12
0.394559
2.66952e+12
17.7413
9
27
26
MESSIER 086
186.549
12.9458
20.788
19.9394
0.456
6.27
-25.3191
6.273
6.093
0.063
6.09993
-25.4961
-25.4056
1.11685e+12
0.397166
2.81205e+12
20.1427
10
28
27
NGC 4477
187.509
13.6364
20.788
20.5756
0.457
7.4
-24.1891
7.353
7.216
0.063
7.22293
-24.3731
-24.3508
1.44377e+12
0.399785
3.61137e+12
22.5121
11
29
28
NGC 4388
186.445
12.6619
20.788
21.6393
0.457
8.16
-23.4291
8.159
7.992
0.063
7.99893
-23.5971
-23.6842
1.55998e+12
0.399785
3.90204e+12
25.0135
NGC 4649
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
MESSIER 060
190.917
11.5525
20.788
20.3044
0
5.82
-25.7691
5.816
5.73
0.072
5.73792
-25.8591
-25.808
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
NGC 4647
190.885
11.5825
20.788
19.9186
0.016
8.19
-23.3991
8.193
8.04
0.072
8.04792
-23.5491
-23.4563
4.56709e+11
1.71569e-05
2.66196e+16
58285.7
3
3
2
NGC 4638
190.697
11.4425
20.788
19.7309
0.088
8.24
-23.3491
8.242
8.2
0.072
8.20792
-23.3891
-23.2757
5.11115e+11
0.00285447
1.79058e+14
700.655
4
4
3
MESSIER 059
190.51
11.6469
20.788
19.3346
0.149
6.86
-24.7291
6.855
6.735
0.072
6.74292
-24.8541
-24.6967
5.58065e+11
0.013856
4.02762e+13
216.513
5
5
4
NGC 4660
191.133
11.1906
20.788
19.3867
0.152
8.23
-23.3591
8.235
8.194
0.072
8.20192
-23.3951
-23.2435
7.39049e+11
0.0147099
5.02417e+13
271.926
6
12
11
MESSIER 058
189.431
11.8181
20.788
20.148
0.536
6.61
-24.9791
6.608
6.472
0.072
6.47992
-25.1171
-25.0492
7.8626e+11
0.645018
1.21897e+12
7.75172
7
13
12
NGC 4654
190.985
13.1264
20.788
20.3879
0.572
7.92
-23.6691
7.923
7.726
0.072
7.73392
-23.8631
-23.8209
1.01685e+12
0.783909
1.29715e+12
7.65395
8
16
15
NGC 4568
189.143
11.2386
20.788
20.805
0.641
7.61
-23.9791
7.614
7.505
0.072
7.51292
-24.0841
-24.0858
1.0895e+12
1.10319
9.87587e+11
6.34521
9
17
16
NGC 4567
189.136
11.2578
20.788
20.8154
0.642
8.47
-23.1191
8.469
8.291
0.072
8.29892
-23.2981
-23.3009
1.17855e+12
1.10837
1.06332e+12
7.21784
10
18
17
NGC 4564
189.113
11.4394
20.788
20.0333
0.643
7.98
-23.6091
7.983
7.925
0.072
7.93292
-23.6641
-23.5838
1.22173e+12
1.11355
1.09714e+12
8.08224
11
24
23
NGC 4754
193.073
11.3136
20.788
20.0646
0.772
7.57
-24.0191
7.569
7.403
0.072
7.41092
-24.1861
-24.1091
1.28221e+12
1.92721
6.65319e+11
5.18884
NGC 4889
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 4889
195.033
27.9769
106.99
99.5824
0
8.54
-26.6067
8.542
8.404
0.026
8.40686
-26.7427
-26.5869
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
NGC 4898A
195.073
27.9553
106.99
104.63
0.077
10.77
-24.3767
10.774
10.672
0.026
10.6749
-24.4747
-24.4263
1.03058e+12
0.00191227
5.38927e+14
522.938
3
3
2
COMAi J125935.644+275733.96
194.898
27.9594
106.99
109.344
0.225
9.08
-26.0667
9.076
8.857
0.026
8.85986
-26.2897
-26.337
1.15818e+12
0.0477117
2.42746e+13
41.9184
4
4
3
IC 4042
195.178
27.9714
106.99
96.0993
0.239
11.07
-24.0767
11.073
10.759
0.026
10.7619
-24.3877
-24.1546
1.8372e+12
0.0571836
3.21281e+13
52.4626
5
5
4
NGC 4869
194.847
27.9117
106.99
102.534
0.331
10.79
-24.3567
10.792
10.608
0.026
10.6109
-24.5387
-24.4463
1.95498e+12
0.151901
1.28701e+13
26.3329
6
6
5
IC 4045
195.202
28.0908
106.99
104.734
0.351
11.01
-24.1367
11.008
10.896
0.026
10.8989
-24.2507
-24.2044
2.09034e+12
0.181134
1.15403e+13
27.6039
7
7
6
NGC 4864
194.804
27.9769
106.99
103.358
0.378
10.9
-24.2467
10.895
10.6
0.026
10.6029
-24.5467
-24.4717
2.19416e+12
0.226232
9.69873e+12
26.5215
8
8
7
NGC 4907
195.202
28.1583
106.99
90.6973
0.439
10.76
-24.3867
10.756
10.53
0.026
10.5329
-24.6167
-24.258
2.33052e+12
0.354382
6.57629e+12
19.7527
9
9
8
NGC 4911
195.233
27.7908
106.99
120.992
0.479
10.05
-25.0967
10.049
9.84
0.026
9.84286
-25.3067
-25.5738
2.47596e+12
0.460346
5.37847e+12
17.3782
10
10
9
WISEA J125957.75+281447.9
194.991
28.2464
106.99
102.367
0.508
10.64
-24.5067
10.639
10.387
0.026
10.3899
-24.7597
-24.6638
2.75054e+12
0.549122
5.00898e+12
16.3898
11
11
10
NGC 4860
194.766
28.1236
106.99
119.209
0.518
10.42
-24.7267
10.424
10.287
0.026
10.2899
-24.8597
-25.0945
2.91646e+12
0.582193
5.00943e+12
17.1764
NGC 5419
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 5419
210.912
-33.9783
57.521
55.8554
0
7.7
-26.0991
7.705
7.492
0.199
7.51389
-26.3071
-26.2433
0
nan
nan
nan
2
3
2
MCG -06-31-020
211.143
-33.9608
57.521
51.3816
0.194
9.98
-23.8191
9.977
9.871
0.199
9.89289
-23.9281
-23.683
6.89986e+11
0.0305832
2.25609e+13
32.6977
3
6
5
ABELL S0753:[WFC91] 037
210.544
-33.7908
57.521
52.706
0.36
10.76
-23.0391
10.759
10.685
0.199
10.7069
-23.1141
-22.9243
7.67119e+11
0.195427
3.92534e+12
10.234
4
7
6
IC 4366
211.298
-33.76
57.521
66.4404
0.389
10.72
-23.0791
10.722
10.253
0.199
10.2749
-23.5461
-23.8592
8.03564e+11
0.246562
3.25907e+12
12.1673
5
8
7
NGC 5397
210.294
-33.9458
57.521
56.2934
0.516
9.36
-24.4391
9.361
9.245
0.199
9.26689
-24.5541
-24.5073
8.57819e+11
0.575476
1.49063e+12
6.95077
6
9
8
ESO 384- G 049
211.529
-33.9233
57.521
64.094
0.517
10.05
-23.7491
10.05
9.941
0.199
9.96289
-23.8581
-24.0931
9.95109e+11
0.578828
1.71918e+12
8.63815
7
10
9
ESO 384- G 033
210.374
-34.2422
57.521
49.6921
0.519
10.98
-22.8191
10.983
10.74
0.199
10.7619
-23.0591
-22.7414
1.06743e+12
0.585571
1.82288e+12
10.2464
8
11
10
ABELL S0753:[WFC91] 082
211.519
-34.3103
57.521
64.6363
0.605
10.81
-22.9891
10.813
10.616
0.199
10.6379
-23.1831
-23.4364
1.10207e+12
0.927564
1.18813e+12
7.54665
9
12
11
ESO 384- G 035
210.637
-33.3994
57.521
54.3329
0.625
10.08
-23.7191
10.08
9.787
0.199
9.80889
-24.0121
-23.8883
1.14091e+12
1.02263
1.11566e+12
7.82298
10
13
12
ESO 384- G 036
210.804
-33.3578
57.521
68.9329
0.629
10.08
-23.7191
10.081
9.971
0.199
9.99289
-23.8281
-24.2211
1.22424e+12
1.04239
1.17446e+12
8.63402
11
14
13
ESO 384- G 029
210.196
-34.2247
57.521
45.6667
0.644
10.21
-23.5891
10.212
10.077
0.199
10.0989
-23.7221
-23.221
1.29459e+12
1.11876
1.15717e+12
8.9385
NGC 3091
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 3091
150.058
-19.6364
58.227
54.6457
0
8.18
-25.6456
8.177
8.079
0.119
8.09209
-25.7466
-25.6088
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
MCG -03-26-006
150.043
-19.6217
58.227
60.8611
0.021
10.4
-23.4256
10.397
10.293
0.119
10.3061
-23.5326
-23.6287
4.11756e+11
3.87914e-05
1.06146e+16
25778.9
3
3
2
NGC 3096
150.137
-19.6619
58.227
63.7707
0.08
10.63
-23.1956
10.634
10.544
0.119
10.5571
-23.2816
-23.4791
4.65341e+11
0.00214461
2.16982e+14
932.572
4
4
3
NGC 3085
149.871
-19.4922
58.227
60.2041
0.231
10.12
-23.7056
10.123
10.059
0.119
10.0721
-23.7666
-23.8391
5.07865e+11
0.0516314
9.83637e+12
58.1042
5
5
4
NGC 3072
149.35
-19.355
58.227
52.2263
0.737
9.71
-24.1156
9.706
9.612
0.119
9.62509
-24.2136
-23.9774
5.74337e+11
1.6768
3.42521e+11
2.3855
6
6
5
ESO 566- G 043
150.181
-20.3678
58.227
57.5031
0.752
10.62
-23.2056
10.625
10.47
0.119
10.4831
-23.3556
-23.3285
6.7467e+11
1.78128
3.78756e+11
2.80698
7
7
6
ESO 566- G 040
149.917
-20.7875
58.227
58.3791
1.178
10.38
-23.4456
10.38
10.298
0.119
10.3111
-23.5276
-23.5333
7.20194e+11
6.84721
1.05181e+11
0.876269
8
8
7
NGC 3124
151.666
-19.2217
58.227
52.6747
1.599
9.65
-24.1487
9.648
9.073
0.119
9.08609
-24.7545
-24.535
7.73532e+11
17.1247
4.51705e+10
0.408766
9
9
8
ESO 566- G 024
148.389
-19.5831
58.227
53.509
1.6
10.2
-23.5987
10.203
10.041
0.119
10.0541
-23.7865
-23.6011
9.38652e+11
17.1569
5.471e+10
0.466286
10
10
9
NGC 3076
149.406
-18.1786
58.227
54.3641
1.601
10.9
-22.8987
10.896
10.722
0.119
10.7351
-23.1055
-22.9546
1.00635e+12
17.189
5.85462e+10
0.523589
11
11
10
NGC 3052
148.616
-18.6389
58.227
57.0339
1.717
9.6
-24.1987
9.598
9.414
0.119
9.42709
-24.4135
-24.3667
1.04251e+12
21.2026
4.91691e+10
0.471641
NGC 7619
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 7619
350.06
8.2064
47.966
53.509
0
8.09
-25.3147
8.092
8.004
0.224
8.02864
-25.4007
-25.6381
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
NGC 7626
350.177
8.2169
47.966
48.5867
0.097
8.11
-25.2947
8.112
8.007
0.224
8.03164
-25.3977
-25.4256
2.99419e+11
0.0038229
7.83226e+13
261.582
3
3
2
NGC 7623
350.125
8.3958
47.966
53.2379
0.167
9.55
-23.8547
9.551
9.438
0.224
9.46264
-23.9667
-24.1931
5.98013e+11
0.0195086
3.06537e+13
102.519
4
4
3
NGC 7611
349.902
8.0631
47.966
46.4697
0.178
9.36
-24.0447
9.364
9.286
0.224
9.31064
-24.1187
-24.0499
6.77937e+11
0.0236231
2.8698e+13
126.994
5
5
4
UGC 12518
350.053
7.9322
47.966
39.9936
0.229
10.49
-22.9485
10.489
10.417
0.224
10.4416
-22.9876
-22.593
7.69872e+11
0.0503019
1.5305e+13
79.5199
6
7
6
NGC 7631
350.361
8.2175
47.966
53.4673
0.249
10.01
-23.3947
10.011
9.898
0.224
9.92264
-23.5067
-23.7424
8.02309e+11
0.064666
1.2407e+13
77.3204
7
8
7
NGC 7612
349.934
8.5764
47.966
46.1464
0.327
9.55
-23.8547
9.548
9.457
0.224
9.48164
-23.9477
-23.8637
8.5463e+11
0.146461
5.83522e+12
40.9666
8
9
8
NGC 7634
350.424
8.8869
47.966
46.0734
0.644
9.71
-23.6947
9.712
9.594
0.224
9.61864
-23.8107
-23.7233
9.33168e+11
1.11876
8.34113e+11
6.25695
9
10
9
CGCG 406-078
350.305
7.3664
47.966
43.9981
0.732
10.24
-23.1647
10.243
10.205
0.224
10.2296
-23.1997
-23.0122
1.0024e+12
1.6429
6.10138e+11
4.86944
10
12
11
NGC 7648
350.975
9.6675
47.966
50.7037
1.438
9.82
-23.5847
9.817
9.681
0.224
9.70564
-23.7237
-23.8442
1.04183e+12
12.4553
8.36456e+10
0.722584
11
13
12
NGC 7562
348.99
6.6875
47.966
50.151
1.551
8.36
-25.0785
8.358
8.287
0.224
8.31164
-25.1177
-25.2144
1.10573e+12
15.6284
7.07514e+10
0.639863
NGC 0057
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in LDC
Separation
K [LDC]
Mk [LDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 0057
3.87833
17.3283
74.47
76.4519
0
8.77
-25.5899
8.769
8.654
0.212
8.67732
-25.7059
-25.7629
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
IC 0004
3.36167
17.4864
74.47
70.372
0.673
10.67
-23.6899
10.667
10.481
0.212
10.5043
-23.8789
-23.756
3.96607e+11
1.2768
3.10625e+11
0.783208
3
3
2
NGC 0052
3.66708
18.5819
74.47
75.8053
1.65
9.53
-24.8299
9.533
9.479
0.212
9.50232
-24.8809
-24.9195
4.70322e+11
18.8161
2.49957e+10
0.106292
4
4
3
UGC 00181
4.75
19.3978
74.47
75.2526
2.897
11.21
-23.1499
11.213
11.112
0.212
11.1353
-23.2479
-23.2706
6.55829e+11
101.841
6.43973e+09
0.0294576
5
5
4
UGC_00164
4.34882
18.0842
-----
77.38
3.134
-----
--------
--------
11.198
0.212
-------
-23.2451
--------
6.97054e+11
128.936
5.4062e+09
0.0310231
6
6
5
CGCG_456-060
4.99314
19.4024
-----
75.5
3.216
-----
--------
--------
11.132
0.212
-------
-23.2577
--------
7.38173e+11
139.324
5.29825e+09
0.0358876
7
7
6
A0003+1704
1.45807
17.3534
-----
77.33
4.188
-----
--------
--------
11.429
0.212
-------
-23.0127
--------
7.79772e+11
307.679
2.53437e+09
0.0195008
8
8
7
UGC_00168
4.54393
18.2923
-----
78.49
4.305
-----
--------
--------
11.219
0.212
-------
-23.2551
--------
8.12967e+11
334.193
2.43263e+09
0.020946
9
9
8
00241620+1414126
6.06741
14.2368
-----
74.68
4.873
-----
--------
--------
11.179
0.212
-------
-23.187
--------
8.54466e+11
484.693
1.7629e+09
0.0165053
10
10
9
CGCG_434-004
5.82668
13.7021
-----
75.57
5.457
-----
--------
--------
11.198
0.212
-------
-23.1937
--------
8.93443e+11
680.675
1.31258e+09
0.0132222
11
11
10
00152684+1614069
3.8618
16.2351
-----
79.79
5.52
-----
--------
--------
11.446
0.212
-------
-23.0637
--------
9.3266e+11
704.523
1.32382e+09
0.014194
NGC 1550
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 1550
64.9075
2.4097
52.478
52.4244
0
8.85
-24.7499
8.846
8.727
0.365
8.76715
-24.8729
-24.8707
0
nan
nan
nan
2
5
4
UGC 03008
64.6671
2.5608
52.478
45.9379
0.26
9.79
-23.8099
9.792
9.641
0.365
9.68115
-23.9589
-23.6699
1.84145e+11
0.0736203
2.50128e+12
13.5832
3
6
5
CGCG 393-007
65.1804
2.3261
52.478
55.2089
0.261
10.31
-23.2899
10.305
10.25
0.365
10.2902
-23.3499
-23.46
2.63497e+11
0.0744731
3.53816e+12
26.8553
4
7
6
CGCG 393-008
65.2321
2.6336
52.478
56.064
0.361
10.07
-23.5299
10.066
9.888
0.365
9.92815
-23.7119
-23.8554
3.08783e+11
0.19706
1.56695e+12
15.2238
5
8
7
UGC 03006
64.355
2.3711
52.478
51.6944
0.507
9.61
-23.9899
9.606
9.503
0.365
9.54315
-24.0969
-24.0642
3.71989e+11
0.545886
6.81442e+11
7.32754
6
12
11
IC 0364
64.7779
3.1892
52.478
54.4893
0.724
10.72
-22.8799
10.723
10.585
0.365
10.6252
-23.0149
-23.0966
4.62097e+11
1.58962
2.90696e+11
3.1454
7
13
12
UGC 02998
64.1425
2.7592
52.478
47.2936
0.77
9.76
-23.8399
9.76
9.505
0.365
9.54515
-24.0949
-23.869
4.95359e+11
1.91227
2.59042e+11
3.13763
8
16
15
NGC 1542
64.3092
4.7817
52.478
52.414
2.24
10.29
-23.3096
10.294
10.202
0.365
10.2422
-23.3979
-23.3952
5.85301e+11
47.0784
1.24325e+10
0.148688
9
16
15
NGC 1589
67.6893
0.8636
------
51.72
2.991
-----
--------
------
8.209
0.365
-------
-25.3593
--------
6.32633e+11
112.08
5.6445e+09
0.0713778
10
16
15
NGC 1587
67.6663
0.6616
------
51.72
3.064
-----
--------
------
8.489
0.365
-------
-25.0793
--------
9.20851e+11
120.488
7.64267e+09
0.0746962
11
16
15
NGC 1593
68.0256
0.5674
------
51.72
3.378
-----
--------
------
10.388
0.365
-------
-23.1803
--------
1.14355e+12
161.457
7.0827e+09
0.061936
NGC 5516
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
0
NGC 5516
213.977
-48.115
63.237
60.152
0
8.34
-25.6649
8.341
8.236
0.557
8.29727
-25.7689
-25.6603
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
1
2MASX J14160456-4807385
214.019
-48.1275
63.237
53.947
0.033
10.81
-23.1949
10.81
10.756
0.557
10.8173
-23.2489
-22.9038
4.20301e+11
0.000150529
2.79216e+15
6643.25
3
3
2
ESO 221- G 033
213.863
-47.8458
63.237
63.9584
0.309
10.97
-23.0349
10.966
10.646
0.557
10.7073
-23.3589
-23.3835
4.61564e+11
0.123581
3.73489e+12
16.1837
4
4
3
ESO 221- G 037
214.544
-48.01
63.237
68.7034
0.433
8.94
-25.0649
8.935
8.845
0.557
8.90627
-25.1599
-25.3399
5.07226e+11
0.340049
1.49163e+12
8.82226
5
5
4
WISEA J141430.85-482654.0
213.629
-48.4483
63.237
62.2481
0.448
10.7
-23.3049
10.696
10.588
0.557
10.6493
-23.4169
-23.3826
7.47087e+11
0.376627
1.98362e+12
10.6206
6
6
5
ESO 271- G 026
213.94
-47.6411
63.237
70.4137
0.524
10.22
-23.7849
10.221
10.089
0.557
10.1503
-23.9159
-24.1493
7.95255e+11
0.602659
1.31958e+12
8.29657
7
6
6
ESO_222-_G_005
216.676
-49.6724
------
61.48
3.112
-----
--------
------
9.683
0.557
-------
-24.261
--------
8.71526e+11
126.24
6.90373e+09
0.0475286
8
6
7
14324350-4857200
218.181
-48.9554
------
61.48
3.619
-----
--------
------
10.735
0.557
-------
-23.209
--------
9.76336e+11
198.538
4.91763e+09
0.0352577
9
6
8
g1431546-460207
217.977
-46.0353
------
61.71
4.036
-----
--------
------
10.54
0.557
-------
-23.412
--------
1.01611e+12
275.379
3.68986e+09
0.0290508
10
6
9
WKK_4079
218.593
-50.0203
------
61.48
4.267
-----
--------
------
10.797
0.557
-------
-23.147
--------
1.06406e+12
325.421
3.2698e+09
0.0276565
11
6
10
g1351353-480136
207.897
-48.0266
------
63.34
4.488
-----
--------
------
9.285
0.557
-------
-24.723
--------
1.10163e+12
378.649
2.90937e+09
0.0264097
Updated Tables (SBF Distances)
In these tables, I've replaced the distances for the HDC/LDC groups by their respective surface brightness fluctuation distances when they exist. I'm using the following values:
HDC
N1277: 69.2 (using NGC1278's SBF from Jensen)
N1407: has 4 SBF distances so kept fixed
N1600: 71.7 (Jensen, SBF)
N3842: 87.5 (Jensen, SBF)
N4486: 16.8 (EHT/Liepold+23)
N4649: 16.5 (MASSIVE I, SBF)
N4889: 102.0 (MASSIVE I, SBF)
N5419: no SBF distance available?
HDC + LDC
N7619: 46.6 (Jensen, SBF)
NGC3091: no SBF distance available?
HDC + LDC + 2MRS
N0057: 66.9 (Jensen, SBF)
N1550: no SBF distance available?
N5516: no SBF distance available?
After replacing the distances to a given group, I recompute Mk based on these updated group distances, as well as the separations.
Group Distances
NGC 1277
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 1277
49.9646
41.5733
69.2
70.6223
0
9.85
-24.5976
9.852
9.755
0.452
9.80472
-24.4455
-24.4897
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
NGC 1278
49.9758
41.5633
69.2
85.8271
0.0157573
9.2
-25.2476
9.196
9.107
0.452
9.15672
-25.0935
-25.5611
1.24226e+11
1.6388e-05
7.5803e+15
61020.3
3
3
3
2
WISEA J031947.80+413546.8
49.9487
41.5964
69.2
105.339
0.0313798
10.8
-23.6476
10.797
10.694
0.452
10.7437
-23.5065
-24.4189
3.49864e+11
0.000129429
2.70314e+15
15452.5
4
4
4
3
V Zw 339
50.0033
41.5536
69.2
73.584
0.0422986
11.24
-23.2076
11.238
11.171
0.452
11.2207
-23.0295
-23.1629
4.02177e+11
0.000316998
1.26871e+15
9463.8
5
5
5
4
NGC 1274
49.9188
41.5486
69.2
90.7599
0.0510203
10.51
-23.9376
10.514
10.442
0.452
10.4917
-23.7585
-24.3475
4.35891e+11
0.000556299
7.83556e+14
7190.38
6
6
6
5
CGCG 540-101
49.8925
41.5806
69.2
64.0106
0.0657355
10.06
-24.3876
10.062
9.952
0.452
10.0017
-24.2485
-24.0793
5.01871e+11
0.00118981
4.21808e+14
4202.35
7
7
7
6
NGC 1275
49.9508
41.5117
69.2
74.6686
0.0754371
8.35
-26.0976
8.353
8.068
0.452
8.11772
-26.1325
-26.2977
6.05484e+11
0.00179818
3.36721e+14
3336.71
8
8
8
7
NGC 1281
50.0254
41.63
69.2
61.2366
0.087777
10.09
-24.3576
10.085
10.005
0.452
10.0547
-24.1955
-23.9301
1.19299e+12
0.00283282
4.21131e+14
2471.03
9
9
9
8
NGC 1273
49.8612
41.5406
69.2
76.3893
0.101453
9.89
-24.5576
9.889
9.774
0.452
9.82372
-24.4265
-24.6412
1.29167e+12
0.00437388
2.95314e+14
1829.04
10
10
10
9
NGC 1279
49.9963
41.4794
69.2
102.867
0.116975
10.83
-23.6176
10.83
10.663
0.452
10.7127
-23.5375
-24.3984
1.41374e+12
0.00670443
2.10866e+14
1342.4
11
11
11
10
UGC 02665
49.8633
41.6353
69.2
110.032
0.118223
11.24
-23.2076
11.239
11.089
0.452
11.1387
-23.1115
-24.1186
1.46757e+12
0.00692125
2.12038e+14
1444.83
NGC 1407
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 1407
55.0492
-18.5803
22.854
24.9034
0
6.83
-24.9648
6.831
6.678
0.187
6.69857
-25.1168
-25.3033
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
10
9
NGC 1440
56.2617
-18.2661
22.854
21.4724
0.475649
8.25
-23.5448
8.247
8.166
0.187
8.18657
-23.6288
-23.4934
2.30528e+11
0.450752
5.1143e+11
2.21851
3
3
11
10
NGC 1452
56.3425
-18.6336
22.854
24.3299
0.489355
8.74
-23.0548
8.74
8.639
0.187
8.65957
-23.1558
-23.2917
2.89078e+11
0.490852
5.88931e+11
4.07455
4
4
20
19
NGC 1461
57.1129
-16.3931
22.854
20.3253
1.17351
8.41
-23.3848
8.406
8.322
0.187
8.34257
-23.4728
-23.2182
3.26951e+11
6.76929
4.82991e+10
0.443178
5
5
21
20
NGC 1353
53.0125
-20.8192
22.854
21.2743
1.17563
8.19
-23.6048
8.192
8.097
0.187
8.11757
-23.6978
-23.5423
3.77664e+11
6.80598
5.54901e+10
0.587719
6
6
27
26
NGC 1439
56.2083
-21.9206
22.854
23.36
1.40095
8.72
-23.0748
8.718
8.561
0.187
8.58157
-23.2338
-23.2814
4.40056e+11
11.5172
3.82084e+10
0.434132
7
7
28
27
NGC 1426
55.7046
-22.1083
22.854
20.1376
1.42819
8.76
-23.0348
8.756
8.665
0.187
8.68557
-23.1298
-22.855
4.80749e+11
12.202
3.93991e+10
0.491721
8
8
29
28
NGC 1415
55.2367
-22.5644
22.854
22.1399
1.59039
8.38
-23.4148
8.379
8.281
0.187
8.30157
-23.5138
-23.4449
5.17725e+11
16.8495
3.07265e+10
0.415443
9
9
35
34
NGC 1332
51.5717
-21.3353
22.854
21.243
1.70458
7.11
-24.6848
7.111
7.041
0.187
7.06157
-24.7538
-24.5951
5.70391e+11
20.746
2.74941e+10
0.385617
10
10
36
35
NGC 1395
54.6238
-23.0278
22.854
23.2453
1.78063
7.02
-24.7748
7.016
6.886
0.187
6.90657
-24.9088
-24.9457
7.35406e+11
23.6482
3.10977e+10
0.380578
11
11
38
37
NGC 1325
51.1067
-21.5442
22.854
22.1399
1.89125
8.82
-22.9748
8.823
8.619
0.187
8.63957
-23.1758
-23.1069
9.25744e+11
28.3351
3.26713e+10
0.352919
NGC 1600
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 1600
67.9158
-5.0861
71.7
67.2434
0
8.13
-25.8932
8.128
8.026
0.118
8.03898
-26.2516
-26.1122
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
NGC 1601
67.9237
-5.0603
71.7
70.5806
0.0337545
10.95
-23.0732
10.948
10.858
0.118
10.871
-23.4196
-23.3854
6.55599e+11
0.000161091
4.06973e+15
6207.66
3
3
3
2
NGC 1603
67.9575
-5.0944
71.7
72.27
0.0530052
10.85
-23.1732
10.848
10.69
0.118
10.703
-23.5876
-23.6048
7.03887e+11
0.000623784
1.12841e+15
3206.24
4
4
4
3
NGC 1604
67.9942
-5.3697
71.7
64.2087
0.3681
10
-24.0232
10.004
9.877
0.118
9.88998
-24.4006
-24.161
7.60256e+11
0.208917
3.63903e+12
14.3598
5
5
5
4
IC 0373
67.6779
-4.8703
71.7
56.7419
0.401112
10.32
-23.7032
10.316
10.177
0.118
10.19
-24.1006
-23.5925
8.79445e+11
0.270317
3.25338e+12
14.7974
6
6
6
5
IC 0372
67.5175
-5.01
71.7
58.9423
0.505549
10.9
-23.1232
10.903
10.809
0.118
10.822
-23.4686
-23.0431
9.6986e+11
0.541213
1.79201e+12
9.23851
7
7
8
7
NGC 1607
68.0129
-4.46
71.7
60.1416
0.7928
10.87
-23.1532
10.867
10.692
0.118
10.705
-23.5856
-23.2039
1.02038e+12
2.08722
4.88868e+11
2.87463
8
8
9
8
IC 2080
67.9671
-5.7569
71.7
58.0246
0.841864
10.85
-23.1732
10.852
10.755
0.118
10.768
-23.5226
-23.0631
1.07664e+12
2.49922
4.30792e+11
2.80088
9
9
10
9
NGC 1594
67.715
-5.7983
71.7
61.1844
0.92568
10.26
-23.7632
10.259
9.881
0.118
9.89398
-24.3966
-24.0522
1.12974e+12
3.32247
3.40029e+11
2.40785
10
10
11
10
NGC 1609
68.1879
-4.3725
71.7
61.1636
0.955296
9.74
-24.2832
9.744
9.621
0.118
9.63398
-24.6566
-24.3115
1.24849e+12
3.65167
3.41895e+11
2.46463
11
11
12
11
NGC 1580
67.0771
-5.1789
71.7
60.2667
1.05176
10.5
-23.5232
10.497
10.362
0.118
10.375
-23.9156
-23.5384
1.39937e+12
4.87339
2.87145e+11
2.05196
NGC 3842
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 3842
176.009
19.9497
87.5
95.3484
0
9.2
-25.7867
9.201
9.074
0.059
9.08049
-25.636
-25.8226
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
NGC 3841
176.009
19.9717
87.5
97.163
0.0335976
10.91
-24.0767
10.909
10.561
0.059
10.5675
-24.149
-24.3765
3.71891e+11
0.000158855
2.34107e+15
6295.03
3
3
3
2
NGC 3845
176.023
19.9961
87.5
87.5061
0.0736544
11.07
-23.9167
11.069
10.96
0.059
10.9665
-23.75
-23.7502
4.66431e+11
0.00167369
2.78685e+14
1194.97
4
4
4
3
UGC 06697
175.954
19.9683
87.5
102.367
0.0839036
10.76
-24.2267
10.759
10.661
0.059
10.6675
-24.049
-24.3898
5.31898e+11
0.00247411
2.14985e+14
1212.56
5
5
5
4
NGC 3837
175.985
19.8944
87.5
95.9637
0.0912116
10.06
-24.9267
10.063
9.947
0.059
9.95349
-24.763
-24.9635
6.18119e+11
0.00317854
1.94466e+14
1258.44
6
6
6
5
NGC 3851
176.085
19.9808
87.5
98.6856
0.11898
11.12
-23.8667
11.124
11.009
0.059
11.0155
-23.701
-23.9623
7.84543e+11
0.00705497
1.11204e+14
708.72
7
7
7
6
NGC 3844
176.002
20.0292
87.5
103.942
0.121824
10.89
-24.0967
10.888
10.792
0.059
10.7985
-23.918
-24.2919
8.4712e+11
0.00757322
1.11857e+14
792.266
8
8
8
7
CGCG 097-101
176.079
19.8447
87.5
97.3611
0.189254
11.11
-23.8767
11.114
10.992
0.059
10.9985
-23.718
-23.9499
9.23542e+11
0.0283931
3.2527e+13
246.539
9
9
9
8
NGC 3840
175.996
20.0769
87.5
111.627
0.195149
11.14
-23.8467
11.135
10.886
0.059
10.8925
-23.824
-24.3529
9.87107e+11
0.0311297
3.17095e+13
256.989
10
10
10
9
CGCG 097-112
176.127
20.0767
87.5
102.607
0.257462
10.99
-23.9967
10.991
10.921
0.059
10.9275
-23.789
-24.1349
1.05719e+12
0.0714856
1.47889e+13
125.899
11
11
11
10
NGC 3860
176.205
19.795
87.5
86.1087
0.367501
10.52
-24.4667
10.517
10.394
0.059
10.4005
-24.316
-24.2812
1.12505e+12
0.207899
5.41151e+12
48.1002
NGC 4486
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
MESSIER 087
187.706
12.3911
16.8
20.5756
0
5.9
-25.6891
5.896
5.804
0.063
5.81093
-25.3225
-25.7628
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
4
3
NGC 4478
187.572
12.3286
16.8
19.8351
0.0425309
8.4
-23.1891
8.396
8.346
0.063
8.35293
-22.7805
-23.1412
2.78624e+11
0.000322249
8.64623e+14
3103.19
3
3
12
11
NGC 4461
187.262
13.1839
16.8
21.0344
0.264868
8.09
-23.4991
8.088
8.006
0.063
8.01293
-23.1205
-23.6087
3.05429e+11
0.0778332
3.92415e+12
25.696
4
4
16
15
NGC 4438
186.94
13.0086
16.8
19.2303
0.284234
7.37
-24.2191
7.374
7.255
0.063
7.26193
-23.8715
-24.1649
3.42091e+11
0.0961842
3.55663e+12
31.1901
5
5
17
16
NGC 4435
186.919
13.0789
16.8
19.3033
0.302211
7.39
-24.1991
7.385
7.287
0.063
7.29393
-23.8395
-24.1412
4.1531e+11
0.115614
3.59221e+12
34.5979
6
6
18
17
NGC 4473
187.454
13.4294
16.8
21.2951
0.312844
7.26
-24.3291
7.259
7.147
0.063
7.15393
-23.9795
-24.4944
4.86401e+11
0.128251
3.79257e+12
38.9861
7
7
25
24
MESSIER 089
188.916
12.5561
16.8
20.2106
0.349771
6.84
-24.7491
6.84
6.713
0.063
6.71993
-24.4135
-24.8149
5.67277e+11
0.179238
3.16494e+12
33.475
8
8
26
25
NGC 4503
188.025
11.1764
16.8
20.4296
0.367742
7.96
-23.6291
7.962
7.871
0.063
7.87793
-23.2555
-23.6803
6.87897e+11
0.208309
3.30229e+12
33.6039
9
9
27
26
MESSIER 086
186.549
12.9458
16.8
19.9394
0.368785
6.27
-25.3191
6.273
6.093
0.063
6.09993
-25.0335
-25.4056
7.29413e+11
0.210086
3.47197e+12
38.0796
10
10
28
27
NGC 4477
187.509
13.6364
16.8
20.5756
0.369445
7.4
-24.1891
7.353
7.216
0.063
7.22293
-23.9105
-24.3508
9.42923e+11
0.211216
4.46425e+12
42.6103
11
11
29
28
NGC 4388
186.445
12.6619
16.8
21.6393
0.369565
8.16
-23.4291
8.159
7.992
0.063
7.99893
-23.1345
-23.6842
1.01882e+12
0.211423
4.81887e+12
47.2986
NGC 4649
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
MESSIER 060
190.917
11.5525
16.5
20.3044
0
5.82
-25.7691
5.816
5.73
0.072
5.73792
-25.3574
-25.808
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
NGC 4647
190.885
11.5825
16.5
19.9186
0.0124959
8.19
-23.3991
8.193
8.04
0.072
8.04792
-23.0474
-23.4563
2.87719e+11
8.17291e-06
3.52039e+16
122355
3
3
3
2
NGC 4638
190.697
11.4425
16.5
19.7309
0.0696987
8.24
-23.3491
8.242
8.2
0.072
8.20792
-22.8874
-23.2757
3.21993e+11
0.00141825
2.27036e+14
1410.19
4
4
4
3
MESSIER 059
190.51
11.6469
16.5
19.3346
0.117988
6.86
-24.7291
6.855
6.735
0.072
6.74292
-24.3524
-24.6967
3.51571e+11
0.00688005
5.11e+13
436.043
5
5
5
4
NGC 4660
191.133
11.1906
16.5
19.3867
0.12075
8.23
-23.3591
8.235
8.194
0.072
8.20192
-22.8934
-23.2435
4.65587e+11
0.00737459
6.3134e+13
542.403
6
6
12
11
MESSIER 058
189.431
11.8181
16.5
20.148
0.425978
6.61
-24.9791
6.608
6.472
0.072
6.47992
-24.6154
-25.0492
4.95329e+11
0.323773
1.52987e+12
15.4429
7
7
13
12
NGC 4654
190.985
13.1264
16.5
20.3879
0.45364
7.92
-23.6691
7.923
7.726
0.072
7.73392
-23.3614
-23.8209
6.40596e+11
0.391031
1.63822e+12
15.344
8
8
16
15
NGC 4568
189.143
11.2386
16.5
20.805
0.508876
7.61
-23.9791
7.614
7.505
0.072
7.51292
-23.5824
-24.0858
6.86365e+11
0.551966
1.24349e+12
12.6819
9
9
17
16
NGC 4567
189.136
11.2578
16.5
20.8154
0.509854
8.47
-23.1191
8.469
8.291
0.072
8.29892
-22.7964
-23.3009
7.42466e+11
0.555157
1.3374e+12
14.4103
10
10
18
17
NGC 4564
189.113
11.4394
16.5
20.0333
0.510112
7.98
-23.6091
7.983
7.925
0.072
7.93292
-23.1624
-23.5838
7.69666e+11
0.556
1.38429e+12
16.187
11
11
24
23
NGC 4754
193.073
11.3136
16.5
20.0646
0.612403
7.57
-24.0191
7.569
7.403
0.072
7.41092
-23.6844
-24.1091
8.07769e+11
0.962031
8.3965e+11
10.3947
NGC 4889
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 4889
195.033
27.9769
102
99.5824
0
8.54
-26.6067
8.542
8.404
0.026
8.40686
-26.639
-26.5869
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
NGC 4898A
195.073
27.9553
102
104.63
0.0737176
10.77
-24.3767
10.774
10.672
0.026
10.6749
-24.371
-24.4263
9.367e+11
0.001678
5.58224e+14
595.947
3
3
3
2
COMAi J125935.644+275733.96
194.898
27.9594
102
109.344
0.214537
9.08
-26.0667
9.076
8.857
0.026
8.85986
-26.186
-26.337
1.05268e+12
0.0413604
2.54515e+13
48.3554
4
4
4
3
IC 4042
195.178
27.9714
102
96.0993
0.228184
11.07
-24.0767
11.073
10.759
0.026
10.7619
-24.284
-24.1546
1.66985e+12
0.0497659
3.35541e+13
60.2823
5
5
5
4
NGC 4869
194.847
27.9117
102
102.534
0.314703
10.79
-24.3567
10.792
10.608
0.026
10.6109
-24.435
-24.4463
1.7769e+12
0.130551
1.36108e+13
30.6393
6
6
6
5
IC 4045
195.202
28.0908
102
104.734
0.334121
11.01
-24.1367
11.008
10.896
0.026
10.8989
-24.147
-24.2044
1.89993e+12
0.15624
1.21604e+13
32.0021
7
7
7
6
NGC 4864
194.804
27.9769
102
103.358
0.360032
10.9
-24.2467
10.895
10.6
0.026
10.6029
-24.443
-24.4717
1.99429e+12
0.195479
1.02021e+13
30.6938
8
8
8
7
NGC 4907
195.202
28.1583
102
90.6973
0.418048
10.76
-24.3867
10.756
10.53
0.026
10.5329
-24.513
-24.258
2.11823e+12
0.306025
6.92174e+12
22.8739
9
9
9
8
NGC 4911
195.233
27.7908
102
120.992
0.456949
10.05
-25.0967
10.049
9.84
0.026
9.84286
-25.203
-25.5738
2.25042e+12
0.399651
5.63096e+12
20.0175
10
10
10
9
WISEA J125957.75+281447.9
194.991
28.2464
102
102.367
0.484285
10.64
-24.5067
10.639
10.387
0.026
10.3899
-24.656
-24.6638
2.49999e+12
0.475751
5.25484e+12
18.9175
11
11
11
10
NGC 4860
194.766
28.1236
102
119.209
0.494141
10.42
-24.7267
10.424
10.287
0.026
10.2899
-24.756
-25.0945
2.65079e+12
0.505395
5.24499e+12
19.7865
NGC 5419
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 5419
210.912
-33.9783
57.521
55.8554
0
7.7
-26.0991
7.705
7.492
0.199
7.51389
-26.3071
-26.2433
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
3
2
MCG -06-31-020
211.143
-33.9608
57.521
51.3816
0.19313
9.98
-23.8191
9.977
9.871
0.199
9.89289
-23.9281
-23.683
6.90006e+11
0.0301736
2.28679e+13
33.1416
3
3
6
5
ABELL S0753:[WFC91] 037
210.544
-33.7908
57.521
52.706
0.359858
10.76
-23.0391
10.759
10.685
0.199
10.7069
-23.1141
-22.9243
7.67141e+11
0.195196
3.9301e+12
10.2461
4
4
7
6
IC 4366
211.298
-33.76
57.521
66.4404
0.389306
10.72
-23.0791
10.722
10.253
0.199
10.2749
-23.5461
-23.8592
8.03587e+11
0.247144
3.25149e+12
12.1387
5
5
8
7
NGC 5397
210.294
-33.9458
57.521
56.2934
0.51562
9.36
-24.4391
9.361
9.245
0.199
9.26689
-24.5541
-24.5073
8.57844e+11
0.574204
1.49397e+12
6.96617
6
6
9
8
ESO 384- G 049
211.529
-33.9233
57.521
64.094
0.51678
10.05
-23.7491
10.05
9.941
0.199
9.96289
-23.8581
-24.0931
9.95139e+11
0.578089
1.72143e+12
8.64919
7
7
10
9
ESO 384- G 033
210.374
-34.2422
57.521
49.6921
0.519779
10.98
-22.8191
10.983
10.74
0.199
10.7619
-23.0591
-22.7414
1.06746e+12
0.588214
1.81475e+12
10.2004
8
8
11
10
ABELL S0753:[WFC91] 082
211.519
-34.3103
57.521
64.6363
0.604524
10.81
-22.9891
10.813
10.616
0.199
10.6379
-23.1831
-23.4364
1.1021e+12
0.925377
1.19098e+12
7.56449
9
9
12
11
ESO 384- G 035
210.637
-33.3994
57.521
54.3329
0.624924
10.08
-23.7191
10.08
9.787
0.199
9.80889
-24.0121
-23.8883
1.14094e+12
1.02225
1.1161e+12
7.82584
10
10
13
12
ESO 384- G 036
210.804
-33.3578
57.521
68.9329
0.629438
10.08
-23.7191
10.081
9.971
0.199
9.99289
-23.8281
-24.2211
1.22428e+12
1.04457
1.17205e+12
8.61602
11
11
14
13
ESO 384- G 029
210.196
-34.2247
57.521
45.6667
0.644562
10.21
-23.5891
10.212
10.077
0.199
10.0989
-23.7221
-23.221
1.29463e+12
1.12169
1.15418e+12
8.91513
NGC 3091
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 3091
150.058
-19.6364
58.227
54.6457
0
8.18
-25.6456
8.177
8.079
0.119
8.09209
-25.7466
-25.6088
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
MCG -03-26-006
150.043
-19.6217
58.227
60.8611
0.0207201
10.4
-23.4256
10.397
10.293
0.119
10.3061
-23.5326
-23.6287
4.11764e+11
3.72608e-05
1.10509e+16
26837.9
3
3
3
2
NGC 3096
150.137
-19.6619
58.227
63.7707
0.0799267
10.63
-23.1956
10.634
10.544
0.119
10.5571
-23.2816
-23.4791
4.6535e+11
0.00213872
2.17584e+14
935.14
4
4
4
3
NGC 3085
149.871
-19.4922
58.227
60.2041
0.231387
10.12
-23.7056
10.123
10.059
0.119
10.0721
-23.7666
-23.8391
5.07876e+11
0.0518916
9.78724e+12
57.8128
5
5
5
4
NGC 3072
149.35
-19.355
58.227
52.2263
0.736072
9.71
-24.1156
9.706
9.612
0.119
9.62509
-24.2136
-23.9774
5.74349e+11
1.67047
3.43825e+11
2.39454
6
6
6
5
ESO 566- G 043
150.181
-20.3678
58.227
57.5031
0.752506
10.62
-23.2056
10.625
10.47
0.119
10.4831
-23.3556
-23.3285
6.74683e+11
1.78487
3.78001e+11
2.80132
7
7
7
6
ESO 566- G 040
149.917
-20.7875
58.227
58.3791
1.17749
10.38
-23.4456
10.38
10.298
0.119
10.3111
-23.5276
-23.5333
7.20208e+11
6.83834
1.05319e+11
0.877405
8
8
8
7
NGC 3124
151.666
-19.2217
58.227
52.6747
1.5976
9.65
-24.1487
9.648
9.073
0.119
9.08609
-24.7526
-24.535
7.73548e+11
17.0799
4.52899e+10
0.409838
9
9
9
8
ESO 566- G 024
148.389
-19.5831
58.227
53.509
1.59861
10.2
-23.5987
10.203
10.041
0.119
10.0541
-23.7846
-23.6011
9.38382e+11
17.1123
5.48368e+10
0.467501
10
10
10
9
NGC 3076
149.406
-18.1786
58.227
54.3641
1.60859
10.9
-22.8987
10.896
10.722
0.119
10.7351
-23.1036
-22.9546
1.00597e+12
17.4347
5.76992e+10
0.516212
11
11
11
10
NGC 3052
148.616
-18.6389
58.227
57.0339
1.71581
9.6
-24.1987
9.598
9.414
0.119
9.42709
-24.4116
-24.3667
1.04206e+12
21.1587
4.92499e+10
0.47262
NGC 7619
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 7619
350.06
8.2064
46.6
53.509
0
8.09
-25.3147
8.092
8.004
0.224
8.02864
-25.3379
-25.6381
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
NGC 7626
350.177
8.2169
46.6
48.5867
0.0945696
8.11
-25.2947
8.112
8.007
0.224
8.03164
-25.3349
-25.4256
2.826e+11
0.00354268
7.97701e+13
282.272
3
3
3
2
NGC 7623
350.125
8.3958
46.6
53.2379
0.162683
9.55
-23.8547
9.551
9.438
0.224
9.46264
-23.9039
-24.1931
5.6442e+11
0.0180347
3.12964e+13
110.898
4
4
4
3
NGC 7611
349.902
8.0631
46.6
46.4697
0.17253
9.36
-24.0447
9.364
9.286
0.224
9.31064
-24.0559
-24.0499
6.39855e+11
0.0215115
2.97447e+13
139.46
5
5
5
4
UGC 12518
350.053
7.9322
46.6
39.9936
0.223084
10.49
-22.9485
10.489
10.417
0.224
10.4416
-22.9249
-22.593
7.26625e+11
0.0465034
1.56252e+13
86.0152
6
6
7
6
NGC 7631
350.361
8.2175
46.6
53.4673
0.242468
10.01
-23.3947
10.011
9.898
0.224
9.92264
-23.4439
-23.7424
7.57243e+11
0.0597092
1.26822e+13
83.7392
7
7
8
7
NGC 7612
349.934
8.5764
46.6
46.1464
0.317548
9.55
-23.8547
9.548
9.457
0.224
9.48164
-23.8849
-23.8637
8.06625e+11
0.134123
6.01406e+12
44.735
8
8
9
8
NGC 7634
350.424
8.8869
46.6
46.0734
0.626121
9.71
-23.6947
9.712
9.594
0.224
9.61864
-23.7479
-23.7233
8.80751e+11
1.02814
8.56643e+11
6.80839
9
9
10
9
CGCG 406-078
350.305
7.3664
46.6
43.9981
0.711138
10.24
-23.1647
10.243
10.205
0.224
10.2296
-23.1369
-23.0122
9.4609e+11
1.5064
6.28047e+11
5.31068
10
10
12
11
NGC 7648
350.975
9.6675
46.6
50.7037
1.3973
9.82
-23.5847
9.817
9.681
0.224
9.70564
-23.6609
-23.8442
9.8331e+11
11.4274
8.60487e+10
0.787583
11
11
13
12
NGC 7562
348.99
6.6875
46.6
50.151
1.50681
8.36
-25.0785
8.358
8.287
0.224
8.31164
-25.0549
-25.2144
1.04362e+12
14.3303
7.28258e+10
0.697821
NGC 0057
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in LDC
Separation
K [LDC]
Mk [LDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 0057
3.87833
17.3283
66.9
76.4519
0
8.77
-25.5899
8.769
8.654
0.212
8.67732
-25.4731
-25.7629
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
IC 0004
3.36167
17.4864
66.9
70.372
0.60451
10.67
-23.6899
10.667
10.481
0.212
10.5043
-23.6461
-23.756
3.20075e+11
0.925313
3.4591e+11
1.08072
3
3
3
2
NGC 0052
3.66708
18.5819
66.9
75.8053
1.48239
9.53
-24.8299
9.533
9.479
0.212
9.50232
-24.6481
-24.9195
3.79566e+11
13.6448
2.78177e+10
0.146576
4
4
4
3
UGC 00181
4.75
19.3978
66.9
75.2526
2.60213
11.21
-23.1499
11.213
11.112
0.212
11.1353
-23.0151
-23.2706
5.29277e+11
73.8013
7.17165e+09
0.0406497
5
5
5
4
UGC_00164
4.34882
18.0842
77.38
77.38
10.5379
-----
--------
--------
11.198
0.212
-------
-23.2451
--------
5.62547e+11
4901.68
1.14766e+08
0.000816047
6
6
6
5
CGCG_456-060
4.99314
19.4024
75.5
75.5
9.07193
-----
--------
--------
11.132
0.212
-------
-23.2577
--------
6.03667e+11
3127.35
1.93028e+08
0.0015988
7
7
7
6
A0003+1704
1.45807
17.3534
77.33
77.33
10.8257
-----
--------
--------
11.429
0.212
-------
-23.0127
--------
6.45267e+11
5314.29
1.21421e+08
0.00112903
8
8
8
7
UGC_00168
4.54393
18.2923
78.49
78.49
11.6815
-----
--------
--------
11.219
0.212
-------
-23.2551
--------
6.78464e+11
6676.83
1.01615e+08
0.0010484
9
9
9
8
00241620+1414126
6.06741
14.2368
74.68
74.68
9.04531
-----
--------
--------
11.179
0.212
-------
-23.187
--------
7.19962e+11
3099.9
2.32253e+08
0.00258073
10
10
10
9
CGCG_434-004
5.82668
13.7021
75.57
75.57
10.0416
-----
--------
--------
11.198
0.212
-------
-23.1937
--------
7.58939e+11
4241.19
1.78945e+08
0.00212205
11
11
11
10
00152684+1614069
3.8618
16.2351
79.79
79.79
12.9652
-----
--------
--------
11.446
0.212
-------
-23.0637
--------
7.98159e+11
9128.78
8.74332e+07
0.00109544
NGC 1550
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 1550
64.9075
2.4097
52.478
52.4244
0
8.85
-24.7499
8.846
8.727
0.365
8.76715
-24.8729
-24.8707
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
5
4
UGC 03008
64.6671
2.5608
52.478
45.9379
0.259891
9.79
-23.8099
9.792
9.641
0.365
9.68115
-23.9589
-23.6699
1.84143e+11
0.073528
2.50439e+12
13.6003
3
3
6
5
CGCG 393-007
65.1804
2.3261
52.478
55.2089
0.261214
10.31
-23.2899
10.305
10.25
0.365
10.2902
-23.3499
-23.46
2.63494e+11
0.0746563
3.52943e+12
26.7894
4
4
7
6
CGCG 393-008
65.2321
2.6336
52.478
56.064
0.360935
10.07
-23.5299
10.066
9.888
0.365
9.92815
-23.7119
-23.8554
3.08779e+11
0.196954
1.56778e+12
15.232
5
5
8
7
UGC 03006
64.355
2.3711
52.478
51.6944
0.506835
9.61
-23.9899
9.606
9.503
0.365
9.54315
-24.0969
-24.0642
3.71985e+11
0.545352
6.821e+11
7.33472
6
6
12
11
IC 0364
64.7779
3.1892
52.478
54.4893
0.723726
10.72
-22.8799
10.723
10.585
0.365
10.6252
-23.0149
-23.0966
4.62091e+11
1.58782
2.91022e+11
3.14898
7
7
13
12
UGC 02998
64.1425
2.7592
52.478
47.2936
0.769679
9.76
-23.8399
9.76
9.505
0.365
9.54515
-24.0949
-23.869
4.95353e+11
1.90988
2.59363e+11
3.14156
8
8
16
15
NGC 1542
64.3092
4.7817
52.478
52.414
2.24015
10.29
-23.3096
10.294
10.202
0.365
10.2422
-23.3979
-23.3952
5.85294e+11
47.0879
1.24298e+10
0.148658
9
9
16
15
NGC 1589
67.6893
0.8636
51.72
51.72
2.99017
-----
--------
------
8.209
0.365
-------
-25.3593
--------
6.32626e+11
111.987
5.64911e+09
0.071437
10
10
16
15
NGC 1587
67.6663
0.6616
51.72
51.72
3.06371
-----
--------
------
8.489
0.365
-------
-25.0793
--------
9.20841e+11
120.454
7.64478e+09
0.0747176
11
11
16
15
NGC 1593
68.0256
0.5674
51.72
51.72
3.37778
-----
--------
------
10.388
0.365
-------
-23.1803
--------
1.14354e+12
161.426
7.084e+09
0.061948
NGC 5516
Neighbor #
Name
RA
Dec
Group Distance
Distance in HDC
Separation
K [HDC]
Mk [HDC]
Matched K
Matched K_tc
Av
k_m_ext = K_tc + 0.11*Av
Mk [K_tc & Group D]
Mk [K_tc & Individual D]
numerator
denominator
nu_i
rho_i
1
1
1
0
NGC 5516
213.977
-48.115
63.237
60.152
0
8.34
-25.6649
8.341
8.236
0.557
8.29727
-25.7689
-25.6603
0
nan
nan
nan
2
2
2
1
2MASX J14160456-4807385
214.019
-48.1275
63.237
53.947
0.0338808
10.81
-23.1949
10.81
10.756
0.557
10.8173
-23.2489
-22.9038
4.20284e+11
0.000162906
2.57991e+15
6138.5
3
3
3
2
ESO 221- G 033
213.863
-47.8458
63.237
63.9584
0.308821
10.97
-23.0349
10.966
10.646
0.557
10.7073
-23.3589
-23.3835
4.61545e+11
0.123366
3.74126e+12
16.2119
4
4
4
3
ESO 221- G 037
214.544
-48.01
63.237
68.7034
0.433987
8.94
-25.0649
8.935
8.845
0.557
8.90627
-25.1599
-25.3399
5.07206e+11
0.342381
1.48141e+12
8.76218
5
5
5
4
WISEA J141430.85-482654.0
213.629
-48.4483
63.237
62.2481
0.44794
10.7
-23.3049
10.696
10.588
0.557
10.6493
-23.4169
-23.3826
7.47057e+11
0.376475
1.98435e+12
10.6249
6
6
6
5
ESO 271- G 026
213.94
-47.6411
63.237
70.4137
0.523756
10.22
-23.7849
10.221
10.089
0.557
10.1503
-23.9159
-24.1493
7.95223e+11
0.601816
1.32137e+12
8.30818
7
7
6
6
ESO_222-_G_005
216.676
-49.6724
61.48
61.48
3.11226
-----
--------
------
9.683
0.557
-------
-24.2607
--------
8.71491e+11
126.272
6.90172e+09
0.0475166
8
8
6
7
14324350-4857200
218.181
-48.9554
61.48
61.48
3.61876
-----
--------
------
10.735
0.557
-------
-23.2087
--------
9.76269e+11
198.499
4.91826e+09
0.0352647
9
9
6
8
g1431546-460207
217.977
-46.0353
61.71
61.71
4.03538
-----
--------
------
10.54
0.557
-------
-23.4118
--------
1.01603e+12
275.252
3.69127e+09
0.0290642
10
10
6
9
WKK_4079
218.593
-50.0203
61.48
61.48
4.2667
-----
--------
------
10.797
0.557
-------
-23.1467
--------
1.06397e+12
325.352
3.27022e+09
0.0276624
11
11
6
10
g1351353-480136
207.897
-48.0266
63.34
63.34
4.48779
-----
--------
------
9.285
0.557
-------
-24.7234
--------
1.10153e+12
378.597
2.9095e+09
0.0264133
Magntiude Cutoff Exploration
One of the questions we had was how sensitive our results are to the cutoff of -23.0/how this impacts neighbors being filtered out. It was a bit hard to quantify this, but I've at least made some plots so that we can see where the most egregious changes would happen. All in all, I think sticking with our ~-23.0 is the simplest thing to do for consisntency with the other environment papers.
First, here's a series of plots showing the neighbor distributions for different cutoffs. The original neighbors for the -23.0 cutoff have the black outlines, and the original "too faint" galaxies are displayed with red x's. The different cutoffs imposed in the table below are now marked with purple x's instead.
One thing that is helpful to look at is what happens to the nearby neighbors if we nudge the magnitude cutoff in a given direction.
Note that I only checked this so far for the HDC only galaxies just to get a sense of how much things bounce around:
Change to -23.25:
N1407: loses 5 neighbors
N1600: loses 2 neighbors
M87: loses 1 neihbor
N5419: loses 3 neighbors
Change to -22.75:
N1600: gains 1 close neighbor
N4486: gains 2 close neighbors
N4649: gains 1 close neighbor
N5419: gains 3 close neighbors
Cut
-23.75
-23.50
-23.25
-23.00
-22.75
-22.50
-22.25
I've created some image cutouts to help better contextualize these plots above. Note that I wasn't able to produce one for N5516 or N57 in time due to the large volume of the neighbors of these galaxies occupy (I run out of RAM when trying to reproject the WCS coordinates).
Image Cutouts
Galaxy
Plot
NGC 4649
NGC 4486
NGC 1277
NGC 1407
NGC 1550
NGC 1600
NGC 3091
NGC 3842
NGC 4889
NGC 5419
NGC 5516
NGC 7619
And here are histograms showing our current -23.0 cutoff neighbors in orange, with the rest of the neighbors from the full HDC/LDC catalogs shown in blue. There is one plot zoomed in close to the cutoff of -23.0, and one larger one without as drastic of a zoom.