meeting 2024 01 12 n57 - JacobPilawa/TriaxSchwarzschild_wiki_5 GitHub Wiki

Context

  • Here's a few new tests/a reminder of where we are with N57!

Current Best Fits/Diagnostic Plots

First, here was the before-and-after imposing a prior on Tmaj cornerplot. As a quick reminder, these cornerplots were produced by running Emily's thinning routine on all scaled models (selecting best scaled version), but they differ in that the updated version uses a Gaussian prior with mean 0.55 and width 0.1 to avoid the bimodality.
Original Imposed Prior
Best Fit kinematics
Plot
Best Fit Sigma Profile
Plot

Choice of nu

  • Before the break, Emily had been experimenting with the parameters of the GPR fit, including the parameter nu. Previously, I had been using a fixed nu = 3/2 for this, but I've added the 0.5 case below, both with and without the modified prior on Tmaj.
Nu = 0.5 case
No Prior Prior Imposed

Finalized Enviornmental Measure

  • I had re-run the environmental calculation with the proper distances. Specifically, we wanted to rescale all the HDC/LDC/redshift distances to better match the more accurate distances listed in the survey papers. We looked at this briefly before break, but wanted this here for completeness:

  • First, here are the tables showing the neighbors using corrected distances (top tables) compared to Melanie's distances (bottom tables).

NGC0057
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_0057' 3.8787 17.32841 66.9 -25.47 0.0 8.654 5440 77.34 74.47 nan 66.9 nan nan
b'IC_0004' 3.36226 17.48644 66.9 -23.65 0.6 10.481 5004 71.17 74.47 nan nan 11.62 0.04
b'NGC_0052' 3.66711 18.58203 66.9 -24.65 1.48 9.479 5392 76.66 74.47 nan nan 10.59 -0.83
b'UGC_00181' 4.75033 19.39787 66.9 -23.02 2.61 11.112 5354 76.12 74.47 nan nan 9.88 -1.39
b'UGC_00164' 4.34882 18.08417 69.51 -23.01 2.81 11.198 5443 77.38 nan nan nan 9.81 -1.37
b'CGCG_456-060' 4.99314 19.40237 67.83 -23.02 2.89 11.132 5310 75.5 nan nan nan 9.79 -1.31
b'A0003+1704' 1.45807 17.35343 69.47 -22.78 3.76 11.429 5439 77.33 nan nan nan 9.47 -1.57
b'UGC_00168' 4.54393 18.29227 70.51 -23.02 3.86 11.219 5521 78.49 nan nan nan 9.46 -1.54
b'00241620+1414126' 6.06741 14.23678 67.09 -22.95 4.37 11.179 5252 74.68 nan nan nan 9.31 -1.64
b'CGCG_434-004' 5.82668 13.70211 67.89 -22.96 4.9 11.198 5315 75.57 nan nan nan 9.18 -1.74
b'00152684+1614069' 3.8618 16.23509 71.68 -22.83 4.96 11.446 5613 79.79 nan nan nan 9.18 -1.71
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_0057' 3.8787 17.32841 74.47 -25.71 0.0 8.654 5440 77.34 74.47 nan 66.9 nan nan
b'IC_0004' 3.36226 17.48644 74.47 -23.88 0.67 10.481 5004 71.17 74.47 nan nan 11.57 -0.1
b'NGC_0052' 3.66711 18.58203 74.47 -24.88 1.65 9.479 5392 76.66 74.47 nan nan 10.54 -0.97
b'UGC_00181' 4.75033 19.39787 74.47 -23.25 2.9 11.112 5354 76.12 74.47 nan nan 9.83 -1.53
b'UGC_00164' 4.34882 18.08417 77.38 -23.25 3.13 11.198 5443 77.38 nan nan nan 9.76 -1.51
b'CGCG_456-060' 4.99314 19.40237 75.5 -23.26 3.22 11.132 5310 75.5 nan nan nan 9.75 -1.45
b'A0003+1704' 1.45807 17.35343 77.33 -23.01 4.19 11.429 5439 77.33 nan nan nan 9.42 -1.71
b'UGC_00168' 4.54393 18.29227 78.49 -23.26 4.3 11.219 5521 78.49 nan nan nan 9.41 -1.68
b'00241620+1414126' 6.06741 14.23678 74.68 -23.19 4.87 11.179 5252 74.68 nan nan nan 9.27 -1.78
b'CGCG_434-004' 5.82668 13.70211 75.57 -23.19 5.46 11.198 5315 75.57 nan nan nan 9.14 -1.88
b'00152684+1614069' 3.8618 16.23509 79.79 -23.06 5.52 11.446 5613 79.79 nan nan nan 9.14 -1.85
NGC1277
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1277' 49.96454 41.57352 71.0 -24.5 0.0 9.755 5066 72.05 75.62 77.54 71.0 nan nan
b'NGC_1278' 49.97563 41.5634 71.0 -25.15 0.02 9.107 6090 86.54 75.62 77.54 nan 16.16 4.59
b'03194779+4135468' 49.94921 41.59637 71.0 -23.56 0.03 10.694 7457 105.86 75.62 77.54 nan 15.69 4.36
b'03200087+4133135' 50.00362 41.55374 71.0 -23.09 0.05 11.171 5272 74.96 75.62 77.54 nan 15.06 3.87
b'03194055+4132550' 49.91896 41.54863 71.0 -23.81 0.05 10.442 6423 91.25 75.62 77.54 nan 14.88 3.76
b'03193423+4134499' 49.89261 41.58055 71.0 -24.3 0.06 9.952 4492 63.91 75.62 77.54 nan 14.76 3.66
b'NGC_1275' 49.95098 41.51168 71.0 -26.19 0.07 8.068 5264 74.85 75.62 77.54 nan 14.88 3.56
b'03200610+4137480' 50.02546 41.63002 71.0 -24.25 0.09 10.005 4219 60.04 75.62 77.54 nan 14.63 3.34
b'03192674+4132257' 49.8614 41.54053 71.0 -24.48 0.1 9.774 5371 76.37 75.62 77.54 nan 14.54 3.27
b'NGC_1279' 49.99611 41.47953 71.0 -23.59 0.12 10.663 7285 103.43 75.62 77.54 nan 14.34 3.11
b'03192737+4138069' 49.86402 41.6353 71.0 -23.17 0.12 11.089 7755 110.06 75.62 77.54 nan 14.35 3.15
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1277' 49.96454 41.57352 77.54 -24.69 0.0 9.755 5066 72.05 75.62 77.54 71.0 nan nan
b'NGC_1278' 49.97563 41.5634 77.54 -25.34 0.02 9.107 6090 86.54 75.62 77.54 nan 16.12 4.47
b'03194779+4135468' 49.94921 41.59637 77.54 -23.75 0.03 10.694 7457 105.86 75.62 77.54 nan 15.65 4.25
b'03200087+4133135' 50.00362 41.55374 77.54 -23.28 0.05 11.171 5272 74.96 75.62 77.54 nan 15.02 3.76
b'03194055+4132550' 49.91896 41.54863 77.54 -24.01 0.06 10.442 6423 91.25 75.62 77.54 nan 14.84 3.65
b'03193423+4134499' 49.89261 41.58055 77.54 -24.5 0.07 9.952 4492 63.91 75.62 77.54 nan 14.72 3.54
b'NGC_1275' 49.95098 41.51168 77.54 -26.38 0.08 8.068 5264 74.85 75.62 77.54 nan 14.84 3.45
b'03200610+4137480' 50.02546 41.63002 77.54 -24.44 0.1 10.005 4219 60.04 75.62 77.54 nan 14.59 3.22
b'03192674+4132257' 49.8614 41.54053 77.54 -24.67 0.11 9.774 5371 76.37 75.62 77.54 nan 14.5 3.16
b'NGC_1279' 49.99611 41.47953 77.54 -23.78 0.13 10.663 7285 103.43 75.62 77.54 nan 14.3 2.99
b'03192737+4138069' 49.86402 41.6353 77.54 -23.36 0.13 11.089 7755 110.06 75.62 77.54 nan 14.31 3.04
NGC1407
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1407' 55.0496 -18.58038 28.1 -25.57 0.0 6.678 1779 25.36 23.08 22.86 28.1 nan nan
b'NGC_1440' 56.26214 -18.26604 28.1 -24.08 0.59 8.166 1597 22.77 23.08 22.86 nan 11.71 0.07
b'NGC_1452' 56.34296 -18.63363 28.1 -23.6 0.6 8.639 1737 24.76 23.08 22.86 nan 11.73 0.34
b'g0348271-162334' 57.11308 -16.3929 28.1 -23.92 1.44 8.322 1394 19.88 23.08 22.86 nan 10.66 -0.62
b'g0332030-204908' 53.0126 -20.81916 28.1 -24.15 1.45 8.097 1545 22.03 23.08 22.86 nan 10.72 -0.5
b'NGC_1439' 56.20813 -21.92057 28.1 -23.68 1.72 8.561 1670 23.81 23.08 22.86 nan 10.53 -0.63
b'NGC_1426' 55.70461 -22.10837 28.1 -23.58 1.76 8.665 1443 20.58 23.08 22.86 nan 10.54 -0.58
b'g0354389-203008' 58.6622 -20.50245 28.37 -23.8 1.94 8.469 1698 24.21 23.08 nan nan 10.44 -0.64
b'g0340569-223352' 55.2369 -22.56448 28.1 -23.96 1.95 8.281 1658 23.64 23.08 22.86 nan 10.47 -0.59
b'g0326173-212007' 51.57217 -21.33537 28.1 -25.2 2.1 7.041 1570 22.39 23.08 22.86 nan 10.48 -0.64
b'g0338297-230139' 54.62412 -23.02769 28.1 -25.36 2.19 6.886 1636 23.33 23.08 22.86 nan 10.52 -0.64
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1407' 55.0496 -18.58038 22.86 -25.12 0.0 6.678 1779 25.36 23.08 22.86 28.1 nan nan
b'NGC_1440' 56.26214 -18.26604 22.86 -23.63 0.48 8.166 1597 22.77 23.08 22.86 nan 11.8 0.33
b'NGC_1452' 56.34296 -18.63363 22.86 -23.16 0.49 8.639 1737 24.76 23.08 22.86 nan 11.82 0.61
b'g0348271-162334' 57.11308 -16.3929 22.86 -23.47 1.17 8.322 1394 19.88 23.08 22.86 nan 10.75 -0.35
b'g0332030-204908' 53.0126 -20.81916 22.86 -23.7 1.18 8.097 1545 22.03 23.08 22.86 nan 10.81 -0.24
b'NGC_1439' 56.20813 -21.92057 22.86 -23.23 1.4 8.561 1670 23.81 23.08 22.86 nan 10.62 -0.36
b'NGC_1426' 55.70461 -22.10837 22.86 -23.13 1.43 8.665 1443 20.58 23.08 22.86 nan 10.63 -0.31
b'g0354389-203008' 58.6622 -20.50245 23.08 -23.35 1.58 8.469 1698 24.21 23.08 nan nan 10.53 -0.37
b'g0340569-223352' 55.2369 -22.56448 22.86 -23.51 1.59 8.281 1658 23.64 23.08 22.86 nan 10.56 -0.32
b'g0326173-212007' 51.57217 -21.33537 22.86 -24.75 1.71 7.041 1570 22.39 23.08 22.86 nan 10.57 -0.37
b'g0338297-230139' 54.62412 -23.02769 22.86 -24.91 1.78 6.886 1636 23.33 23.08 22.86 nan 10.61 -0.37
NGC1550
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1550' 64.90806 2.40993 51.6 -24.84 0.0 8.727 3714 52.87 52.48 52.48 51.6 nan nan
b'UGC_03008' 64.66727 2.56082 51.6 -23.92 0.26 9.641 3251 46.3 52.48 52.48 nan 12.56 1.16
b'CGCG_393-007' 65.18106 2.32596 51.6 -23.31 0.26 10.25 3912 55.68 52.48 52.48 nan 12.63 1.46
b'CGCG_393-008' 65.23261 2.63348 51.6 -23.68 0.35 9.888 3973 56.55 52.48 52.48 nan 12.29 1.21
b'UGC_03006' 64.35535 2.37109 51.6 -24.06 0.5 9.503 3664 52.16 52.48 52.48 nan 11.93 0.88
b'IC_0364' 64.77785 3.18902 51.6 -22.98 0.71 10.585 3862 54.97 52.48 52.48 nan 11.51 0.53
b'UGC_02998' 64.14293 2.75907 51.6 -24.06 0.76 9.505 3349 47.69 52.48 52.48 nan 11.49 0.52
b'NGC_1542' 64.30908 4.78164 51.6 -23.36 2.2 10.202 3714 52.87 52.48 nan nan 10.14 -0.81
b'NGC_1589' 67.68935 0.86368 50.85 -25.32 2.94 8.209 3793 53.99 50.68 51.72 nan 9.92 -1.12
b'NGC_1587' 67.66637 0.66168 50.85 -25.04 3.01 8.489 3694 52.59 50.68 51.72 nan 9.99 -1.1
b'NGC_1593' 68.02562 0.56744 50.85 -23.14 3.32 10.388 3772 53.7 50.68 51.72 nan 9.87 -1.19
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1550' 64.90806 2.40993 52.48 -24.87 0.0 8.727 3714 52.87 52.48 52.48 51.6 nan nan
b'UGC_03008' 64.66727 2.56082 52.48 -23.96 0.26 9.641 3251 46.3 52.48 52.48 nan 12.55 1.13
b'CGCG_393-007' 65.18106 2.32596 52.48 -23.35 0.26 10.25 3912 55.68 52.48 52.48 nan 12.62 1.43
b'CGCG_393-008' 65.23261 2.63348 52.48 -23.71 0.36 9.888 3973 56.55 52.48 52.48 nan 12.28 1.19
b'UGC_03006' 64.35535 2.37109 52.48 -24.1 0.51 9.503 3664 52.16 52.48 52.48 nan 11.92 0.86
b'IC_0364' 64.77785 3.18902 52.48 -23.01 0.72 10.585 3862 54.97 52.48 52.48 nan 11.5 0.5
b'UGC_02998' 64.14293 2.75907 52.48 -24.09 0.77 9.505 3349 47.69 52.48 52.48 nan 11.49 0.5
b'NGC_1542' 64.30908 4.78164 52.48 -23.4 2.24 10.202 3714 52.87 52.48 nan nan 10.13 -0.83
b'NGC_1589' 67.68935 0.86368 51.72 -25.36 2.99 8.209 3793 53.99 50.68 51.72 nan 9.92 -1.15
b'NGC_1587' 67.66637 0.66168 51.72 -25.08 3.06 8.489 3694 52.59 50.68 51.72 nan 9.98 -1.12
b'NGC_1593' 68.02562 0.56744 51.72 -23.18 3.38 10.388 3772 53.7 50.68 51.72 nan 9.86 -1.21
NGC1600
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1600' 67.91609 -5.08612 64.0 -26.0 0.0 8.026 4681 66.59 65.36 63.77 64.0 nan nan
b'NGC_1601' 67.92392 -5.0603 64.0 -23.17 0.03 10.858 4997 71.07 65.36 63.77 nan 15.69 3.94
b'g0431500-050540' 67.95814 -5.09442 64.0 -23.34 0.05 10.69 5123 72.85 65.36 63.77 nan 15.06 3.58
b'g0431586-052211' 67.99418 -5.36971 64.0 -24.15 0.33 9.877 4425 62.96 65.36 63.77 nan 12.66 1.29
b'A0428-0458' 67.67828 -4.87025 64.0 -23.85 0.36 10.177 4014 57.13 65.36 63.77 nan 12.59 1.31
b'A0427-0507' 67.51765 -5.00998 64.0 -23.22 0.45 10.809 4171 59.36 65.36 63.77 nan 12.32 1.11
b'g0432031-042736' 68.01289 -4.45994 64.0 -23.34 0.71 10.692 4335 61.68 65.36 63.77 nan 11.75 0.6
b'g0431521-054525' 67.96726 -5.7569 64.0 -23.28 0.75 10.755 4134 58.83 65.36 63.77 nan 11.7 0.59
b'g0430516-054754' 67.71508 -5.79829 64.0 -24.15 0.82 9.881 4344 61.81 65.36 63.77 nan 11.63 0.53
b'A0430-0428' 68.1879 -4.3724 64.0 -24.41 0.85 9.621 4327 61.57 65.36 63.77 nan 11.63 0.54
b'g0428185-051044' 67.077 -5.17877 64.0 -23.67 0.94 10.362 4251 60.49 65.36 63.77 nan 11.52 0.45
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_1600' 67.91609 -5.08612 63.77 -26.0 0.0 8.026 4681 66.59 65.36 63.77 64.0 nan nan
b'NGC_1601' 67.92392 -5.0603 63.77 -23.17 0.03 10.858 4997 71.07 65.36 63.77 nan 15.69 3.95
b'g0431500-050540' 67.95814 -5.09442 63.77 -23.33 0.05 10.69 5123 72.85 65.36 63.77 nan 15.06 3.58
b'g0431586-052211' 67.99418 -5.36971 63.77 -24.15 0.33 9.877 4425 62.96 65.36 63.77 nan 12.66 1.3
b'A0428-0458' 67.67828 -4.87025 63.77 -23.85 0.36 10.177 4014 57.13 65.36 63.77 nan 12.59 1.31
b'A0427-0507' 67.51765 -5.00998 63.77 -23.21 0.45 10.809 4171 59.36 65.36 63.77 nan 12.33 1.12
b'g0432031-042736' 68.01289 -4.45994 63.77 -23.33 0.71 10.692 4335 61.68 65.36 63.77 nan 11.75 0.6
b'g0431521-054525' 67.96726 -5.7569 63.77 -23.27 0.75 10.755 4134 58.83 65.36 63.77 nan 11.7 0.6
b'g0430516-054754' 67.71508 -5.79829 63.77 -24.14 0.82 9.881 4344 61.81 65.36 63.77 nan 11.63 0.54
b'A0430-0428' 68.1879 -4.3724 63.77 -24.4 0.85 9.621 4327 61.57 65.36 63.77 nan 11.63 0.54
b'g0428185-051044' 67.077 -5.17877 63.77 -23.66 0.94 10.362 4251 60.49 65.36 63.77 nan 11.53 0.46
NGC3091
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_3091' 150.05891 -19.63644 51.3 -25.47 0.0 8.079 3964 56.42 57.51 58.22 51.3 nan nan
b'g1000103-193719' 150.04289 -19.62181 51.3 -23.26 0.02 10.293 4035 57.43 57.51 58.22 nan 16.2 4.64
b'NGC_3096' 150.13795 -19.66198 51.3 -23.01 0.07 10.544 4228 60.17 57.51 58.22 nan 14.43 3.13
b'NGC_3085' 149.87158 -19.49227 51.3 -23.49 0.2 10.059 4005 57.0 57.51 58.22 nan 13.11 1.93
b'g0957239-192118' 149.34955 -19.35498 51.3 -23.94 0.65 9.612 3462 49.29 57.51 58.22 nan 11.65 0.54
b'g1000434-202205' 150.18095 -20.36793 51.3 -23.08 0.66 10.47 3816 54.32 57.51 58.22 nan 11.67 0.62
b'g0959401-204715' 149.91711 -20.78752 51.3 -23.25 1.04 10.298 3836 54.6 57.51 58.22 nan 11.11 0.11
b'g1006399-191318' 151.66624 -19.22158 50.67 -24.45 1.53 9.073 3449 49.11 57.51 nan nan 10.68 -0.33
b'g0953334-193459' 148.38921 -19.58316 50.67 -23.48 1.53 10.041 3518 50.09 57.51 nan nan 10.71 -0.28
b'g0957376-181043' 149.40675 -18.17869 50.67 -22.8 1.54 10.722 3641 51.84 57.51 nan nan 10.72 -0.23
b'g0954279-183820' 148.61639 -18.63888 50.67 -24.11 1.63 9.414 3762 53.55 57.51 nan nan 10.69 -0.26
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_3091' 150.05891 -19.63644 58.22 -25.75 0.0 8.079 3964 56.42 57.51 58.22 51.3 nan nan
b'g1000103-193719' 150.04289 -19.62181 58.22 -23.53 0.02 10.293 4035 57.43 57.51 58.22 nan 16.14 4.47
b'NGC_3096' 150.13795 -19.66198 58.22 -23.28 0.08 10.544 4228 60.17 57.51 58.22 nan 14.37 2.97
b'NGC_3085' 149.87158 -19.49227 58.22 -23.77 0.23 10.059 4005 57.0 57.51 58.22 nan 13.05 1.77
b'g0957239-192118' 149.34955 -19.35498 58.22 -24.21 0.74 9.612 3462 49.29 57.51 58.22 nan 11.6 0.37
b'g1000434-202205' 150.18095 -20.36793 58.22 -23.36 0.75 10.47 3816 54.32 57.51 58.22 nan 11.61 0.45
b'g0959401-204715' 149.91711 -20.78752 58.22 -23.53 1.18 10.298 3836 54.6 57.51 58.22 nan 11.05 -0.06
b'g1006399-191318' 151.66624 -19.22158 57.51 -24.73 1.74 9.073 3449 49.11 57.51 nan nan 10.63 -0.5
b'g0953334-193459' 148.38921 -19.58316 57.51 -23.76 1.74 10.041 3518 50.09 57.51 nan nan 10.66 -0.44
b'g0957376-181043' 149.40675 -18.17869 57.51 -23.08 1.75 10.722 3641 51.84 57.51 nan nan 10.66 -0.4
b'g0954279-183820' 148.61639 -18.63888 57.51 -24.38 1.85 9.414 3762 53.55 57.51 nan nan 10.64 -0.42
NGC3842
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'11440216+1956593' 176.009 19.94982 98.0 -25.88 0.0 9.074 6234 88.58 99.64 99.39 98.0 nan nan
b'11440216+1958189' 176.009 19.97185 98.0 -24.4 0.04 10.561 6323 89.84 99.64 99.39 nan 15.36 3.59
b'11440546+1959459' 176.02271 19.99613 98.0 -24.0 0.08 10.96 5649 80.3 99.64 99.39 nan 14.51 2.99
b'UGC_06697' 175.95462 19.96839 98.0 -24.3 0.09 10.661 6725 95.52 99.64 99.39 nan 14.42 3.01
b'11435642+1953404' 175.98508 19.89456 98.0 -25.01 0.1 9.947 6301 89.53 99.64 99.39 nan 14.39 3.0
b'11442042+1958511' 176.08505 19.98083 98.0 -23.95 0.14 11.009 6329 89.92 99.64 99.39 nan 13.98 2.66
b'11440079+2001456' 176.00322 20.02929 98.0 -24.16 0.14 10.792 6800 96.58 99.64 99.39 nan 14.02 2.74
b'11441895+1950407' 176.0789 19.84467 98.0 -23.96 0.22 10.992 6371 90.51 99.64 99.39 nan 13.46 2.21
b'11435896+2004373' 175.99571 20.07705 98.0 -24.07 0.22 10.886 7359 104.47 99.64 99.39 nan 13.49 2.27
b'11443055+2004360' 176.12727 20.07663 98.0 -24.04 0.29 10.921 6717 95.41 99.64 99.39 nan 13.16 1.96
b'NGC_3860' 176.20494 19.79501 98.0 -24.56 0.41 10.394 5595 79.54 99.64 99.39 nan 12.72 1.53
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'11440216+1956593' 176.009 19.94982 99.39 -25.91 0.0 9.074 6234 88.58 99.64 99.39 98.0 nan nan
b'11440216+1958189' 176.009 19.97185 99.39 -24.43 0.04 10.561 6323 89.84 99.64 99.39 nan 15.35 3.57
b'11440546+1959459' 176.02271 19.99613 99.39 -24.03 0.08 10.96 5649 80.3 99.64 99.39 nan 14.51 2.97
b'UGC_06697' 175.95462 19.96839 99.39 -24.33 0.09 10.661 6725 95.52 99.64 99.39 nan 14.42 2.99
b'11435642+1953404' 175.98508 19.89456 99.39 -25.04 0.1 9.947 6301 89.53 99.64 99.39 nan 14.38 2.98
b'11442042+1958511' 176.08505 19.98083 99.39 -23.98 0.14 11.009 6329 89.92 99.64 99.39 nan 13.98 2.64
b'11440079+2001456' 176.00322 20.02929 99.39 -24.19 0.14 10.792 6800 96.58 99.64 99.39 nan 14.02 2.72
b'11441895+1950407' 176.0789 19.84467 99.39 -23.99 0.22 10.992 6371 90.51 99.64 99.39 nan 13.46 2.2
b'11435896+2004373' 175.99571 20.07705 99.39 -24.1 0.22 10.886 7359 104.47 99.64 99.39 nan 13.49 2.25
b'11443055+2004360' 176.12727 20.07663 99.39 -24.07 0.29 10.921 6717 95.41 99.64 99.39 nan 13.15 1.94
b'NGC_3860' 176.20494 19.79501 99.39 -24.59 0.42 10.394 5595 79.54 99.64 99.39 nan 12.71 1.51
NGC4486
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'MESSIER_087' 187.70593 12.3911 16.8 -25.32 0.0 5.804 1307 18.64 20.11 20.78 16.8 nan nan
b'NGC_4478' 187.5726 12.32854 16.8 -22.78 0.04 8.346 1349 19.24 20.11 20.78 17.0 15.04 3.56
b'NGC_4461' 187.26254 13.18385 16.8 -23.12 0.27 8.006 1931 27.53 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.63 1.4
b'NGC_4438' 186.94022 13.00859 16.8 -23.87 0.28 7.255 71 3.0 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.64 1.5
b'NGC_4435' 186.91875 13.079 16.8 -23.84 0.3 7.287 801 11.43 20.11 20.78 16.7 12.64 1.55
b'NGC_4473' 187.45366 13.42932 16.8 -23.98 0.32 7.147 2244 31.98 20.11 20.78 15.3 12.64 1.58
b'MESSIER_089' 188.91618 12.55604 16.8 -24.41 0.35 6.713 340 4.85 20.11 20.78 15.8 12.59 1.53
b'NGC_4503' 188.02586 11.17643 16.8 -23.26 0.36 7.871 1342 19.14 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.56 1.54
b'MESSIER_086' 186.54922 12.94597 16.8 -25.03 0.37 6.093 -244 3.0 20.11 20.78 16.8 12.64 1.57
b'NGC_4477' 187.50945 13.63645 16.8 -23.91 0.37 7.216 1355 19.32 20.11 20.78 nan 12.67 1.62
b'NGC_4388' 186.44508 12.66207 16.8 -23.13 0.37 7.992 2524 35.96 20.11 20.78 38.0 12.69 1.67
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'MESSIER_087' 187.70593 12.3911 20.78 -25.78 0.0 5.804 1307 18.64 20.11 20.78 16.8 nan nan
b'NGC_4478' 187.5726 12.32854 20.78 -23.24 0.05 8.346 1349 19.24 20.11 20.78 17.0 14.95 3.28
b'NGC_4461' 187.26254 13.18385 20.78 -23.58 0.33 8.006 1931 27.53 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.54 1.12
b'NGC_4438' 186.94022 13.00859 20.78 -24.33 0.35 7.255 71 3.0 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.55 1.22
b'NGC_4435' 186.91875 13.079 20.78 -24.3 0.37 7.287 801 11.43 20.11 20.78 16.7 12.54 1.28
b'NGC_4473' 187.45366 13.42932 20.78 -24.44 0.39 7.147 2244 31.98 20.11 20.78 15.3 12.54 1.3
b'MESSIER_089' 188.91618 12.55604 20.78 -24.88 0.43 6.713 340 4.85 20.11 20.78 15.8 12.5 1.26
b'NGC_4503' 188.02586 11.17643 20.78 -23.72 0.45 7.871 1342 19.14 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.47 1.26
b'MESSIER_086' 186.54922 12.94597 20.78 -25.5 0.46 6.093 -244 3.0 20.11 20.78 16.8 12.55 1.29
b'NGC_4477' 187.50945 13.63645 20.78 -24.37 0.46 7.216 1355 19.32 20.11 20.78 nan 12.58 1.34
b'NGC_4388' 186.44508 12.66207 20.78 -23.6 0.46 7.992 2524 35.96 20.11 20.78 38.0 12.6 1.39
NGC4649
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'MESSIER_060' 190.9167 11.55261 15.7 -25.25 0.0 5.73 1117 15.93 20.11 20.78 15.7 nan nan
b'12433249+1134566' 190.88559 11.58247 15.7 -22.94 0.02 8.04 1395 19.89 20.11 20.78 nan 16.3 4.84
b'NGC_4638' 190.69762 11.44247 15.7 -22.78 0.07 8.2 1164 16.6 20.11 20.78 17.5 14.38 3.18
b'MESSIER_059' 190.50967 11.64693 15.7 -24.24 0.11 6.735 410 5.85 20.11 20.78 14.9 13.84 2.69
b'NGC_4660' 191.13326 11.19052 15.7 -22.79 0.11 8.194 1083 15.45 20.11 20.78 15.0 13.87 2.82
b'MESSIER_058' 189.43166 11.81809 15.7 -24.51 0.41 6.472 1517 21.63 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.31 1.24
b'12435657+1307360' 190.98599 13.12635 15.7 -23.25 0.43 7.726 1048 14.95 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.27 1.25
b'12363426+1114199' 189.14288 11.23863 15.7 -23.47 0.48 7.505 2232 31.81 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.15 1.17
b'12363270+1115287' 189.13626 11.25787 15.7 -22.69 0.48 8.291 2271 32.37 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.17 1.23
b'NGC_4564' 189.11247 11.43929 15.7 -23.05 0.48 7.925 1142 16.29 20.11 20.78 15.8 12.19 1.28
b'NGC_4754' 193.07318 11.31366 15.7 -23.58 0.58 7.403 1347 19.21 20.11 20.78 16.1 11.98 1.08
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'MESSIER_060' 190.9167 11.55261 20.78 -25.86 0.0 5.73 1117 15.93 20.11 20.78 15.7 nan nan
b'12433249+1134566' 190.88559 11.58247 20.78 -23.55 0.02 8.04 1395 19.89 20.11 20.78 nan 16.18 4.47
b'NGC_4638' 190.69762 11.44247 20.78 -23.39 0.09 8.2 1164 16.6 20.11 20.78 17.5 14.26 2.82
b'MESSIER_059' 190.50967 11.64693 20.78 -24.85 0.15 6.735 410 5.85 20.11 20.78 14.9 13.72 2.33
b'NGC_4660' 191.13326 11.19052 20.78 -23.39 0.15 8.194 1083 15.45 20.11 20.78 15.0 13.74 2.45
b'MESSIER_058' 189.43166 11.81809 20.78 -25.12 0.54 6.472 1517 21.63 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.19 0.88
b'12435657+1307360' 190.98599 13.12635 20.78 -23.86 0.57 7.726 1048 14.95 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.15 0.89
b'12363426+1114199' 189.14288 11.23863 20.78 -24.08 0.64 7.505 2232 31.81 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.03 0.8
b'12363270+1115287' 189.13626 11.25787 20.78 -23.3 0.64 8.291 2271 32.37 20.11 20.78 16.5 12.05 0.86
b'NGC_4564' 189.11247 11.43929 20.78 -23.66 0.64 7.925 1142 16.29 20.11 20.78 15.8 12.07 0.91
b'NGC_4754' 193.07318 11.31366 20.78 -24.19 0.77 7.403 1347 19.21 20.11 20.78 16.1 11.86 0.72
NGC4889
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'13000812+2758370' 195.03378 27.97698 103.0 -26.66 0.0 8.404 6446 91.58 104.54 107.0 103.0 nan nan
b'NGC_4898_NED01' 195.0737 27.95528 103.0 -24.39 0.08 10.672 6903 98.03 104.54 107.0 nan 14.75 2.72
b'12593570+2757333' 194.89877 27.95938 103.0 -26.21 0.22 8.857 7167 101.76 104.54 107.0 102.0 13.57 1.64
b'13004275+2758165' 195.17818 27.97127 103.0 -24.31 0.23 10.759 6372 90.53 104.54 107.0 nan 13.55 1.76
b'NGC_4869' 194.84727 27.91161 103.0 -24.46 0.32 10.608 6859 97.41 104.54 107.0 nan 13.16 1.47
b'13004864+2805266' 195.20274 28.09072 103.0 -24.17 0.34 10.896 6967 98.94 104.54 107.0 nan 13.1 1.49
b'NGC_4864' 194.80467 27.97694 103.0 -24.46 0.37 10.6 6755 95.94 104.54 107.0 nan 13.02 1.47
b'13004880+2809300' 195.20322 28.15827 103.0 -24.53 0.42 10.53 5806 82.52 104.54 107.0 nan 12.86 1.34
b'13005605+2747271' 195.23373 27.79078 103.0 -25.22 0.46 9.84 7972 113.12 104.54 107.0 nan 12.79 1.29
b'12595775+2814480' 194.99063 28.24655 103.0 -24.68 0.49 10.387 6707 95.26 104.54 107.0 nan 12.74 1.26
b'12590390+2807253' 194.7663 28.12364 103.0 -24.78 0.5 10.287 7930 112.53 104.54 107.0 nan 12.74 1.28
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'13000812+2758370' 195.03378 27.97698 107.0 -26.74 0.0 8.404 6446 91.58 104.54 107.0 103.0 nan nan
b'NGC_4898_NED01' 195.0737 27.95528 107.0 -24.47 0.08 10.672 6903 98.03 104.54 107.0 nan 14.73 2.67
b'12593570+2757333' 194.89877 27.95938 107.0 -26.29 0.23 8.857 7167 101.76 104.54 107.0 102.0 13.56 1.59
b'13004275+2758165' 195.17818 27.97127 107.0 -24.39 0.24 10.759 6372 90.53 104.54 107.0 nan 13.53 1.71
b'NGC_4869' 194.84727 27.91161 107.0 -24.54 0.33 10.608 6859 97.41 104.54 107.0 nan 13.14 1.42
b'13004864+2805266' 195.20274 28.09072 107.0 -24.25 0.35 10.896 6967 98.94 104.54 107.0 nan 13.09 1.44
b'NGC_4864' 194.80467 27.97694 107.0 -24.55 0.38 10.6 6755 95.94 104.54 107.0 nan 13.01 1.42
b'13004880+2809300' 195.20322 28.15827 107.0 -24.62 0.44 10.53 5806 82.52 104.54 107.0 nan 12.84 1.29
b'13005605+2747271' 195.23373 27.79078 107.0 -25.31 0.48 9.84 7972 113.12 104.54 107.0 nan 12.77 1.24
b'12595775+2814480' 194.99063 28.24655 107.0 -24.76 0.51 10.387 6707 95.26 104.54 107.0 nan 12.72 1.21
b'12590390+2807253' 194.7663 28.12364 107.0 -24.86 0.52 10.287 7930 112.53 104.54 107.0 nan 12.72 1.23
NGC5328
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'g1352533-282922' 208.22217 -28.48932 64.1 -25.57 0.0 8.467 4713 67.04 61.42 72.53 64.1 nan nan
b'g1352592-282814' 208.24663 -28.47066 64.1 -23.56 0.04 10.475 4784 68.05 61.42 72.53 nan 15.34 3.73
b'A135009.6-281220' 208.25073 -28.45177 64.1 -22.84 0.05 11.194 5047 71.78 61.42 72.53 nan 14.84 3.51
b'A135024.4-281054' 208.31259 -28.42761 64.1 -23.5 0.11 10.534 4427 62.99 61.42 72.53 nan 13.88 2.67
b'ESO_445-_G_064' 208.08784 -27.89433 64.1 -24.07 0.68 9.966 4907 69.79 61.42 72.53 nan 11.64 0.48
b'g1349209-281204' 207.33711 -28.2012 64.1 -23.52 0.93 10.51 5021 71.41 61.42 72.53 nan 11.27 0.17
b'g1349005-303732' 207.25192 -30.62561 63.29 -23.08 2.68 10.926 5035 71.61 nan nan nan 9.91 -1.13
b'g1350237-303913' 207.59883 -30.65367 63.06 -22.81 2.69 11.193 5017 71.35 nan nan nan 9.93 -1.06
b'g1352460-295547' 208.19185 -29.92975 59.77 -23.96 4.6 9.918 4676 66.52 61.42 67.63 nan 9.27 -1.71
b'g1348215-293735' 207.08955 -29.6264 59.77 -23.31 4.63 10.573 4529 64.43 61.42 67.63 nan 9.29 -1.66
b'g1350461-295955' 207.69193 -29.99868 59.77 -23.22 4.66 10.667 4275 60.83 61.42 67.63 nan 9.3 -1.63
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'g1352533-282922' 208.22217 -28.48932 72.53 -25.84 0.0 8.467 4713 67.04 61.42 72.53 64.1 nan nan
b'g1352592-282814' 208.24663 -28.47066 72.53 -23.83 0.04 10.475 4784 68.05 61.42 72.53 nan 15.29 3.57
b'A135009.6-281220' 208.25073 -28.45177 72.53 -23.11 0.06 11.194 5047 71.78 61.42 72.53 nan 14.79 3.34
b'A135024.4-281054' 208.31259 -28.42761 72.53 -23.77 0.13 10.534 4427 62.99 61.42 72.53 nan 13.83 2.51
b'ESO_445-_G_064' 208.08784 -27.89433 72.53 -24.34 0.77 9.966 4907 69.79 61.42 72.53 nan 11.58 0.32
b'g1349209-281204' 207.33711 -28.2012 72.53 -23.79 1.05 10.51 5021 71.41 61.42 72.53 nan 11.22 0.01
b'g1349005-303732' 207.25192 -30.62561 71.61 -23.35 3.03 10.926 5035 71.61 nan nan nan 9.86 -1.29
b'g1350237-303913' 207.59883 -30.65367 71.35 -23.07 3.04 11.193 5017 71.35 nan nan nan 9.87 -1.23
b'g1352460-295547' 208.19185 -29.92975 67.63 -24.23 5.21 9.918 4676 66.52 61.42 67.63 nan 9.22 -1.87
b'g1348215-293735' 207.08955 -29.6264 67.63 -23.58 5.24 10.573 4529 64.43 61.42 67.63 nan 9.24 -1.83
b'g1350461-295955' 207.69193 -29.99868 67.63 -23.48 5.27 10.667 4275 60.83 61.42 67.63 nan 9.25 -1.79
NGC5419
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_5419' 210.91154 -33.97839 56.2 -26.26 0.0 7.492 4126 58.72 58.32 57.52 56.2 nan nan
b'MCG_-06-31-020' 211.14308 -33.96075 56.2 -23.88 0.19 9.871 3849 54.79 58.32 57.52 nan 13.44 1.57
b'g1402107-334727' 210.54469 -33.79072 56.2 -23.06 0.35 10.685 3900 55.51 58.32 57.52 nan 12.62 1.04
b'g1405115-334536' 211.29784 -33.76011 56.2 -23.5 0.38 10.253 4597 65.4 58.32 57.52 nan 12.55 1.11
b'g1401105-335645' 210.29359 -33.94582 56.2 -24.5 0.51 9.245 4078 58.04 58.32 57.52 nan 12.24 0.86
b'g1406070-335524' 211.52904 -33.92344 56.2 -23.81 0.51 9.941 4461 63.47 58.32 57.52 nan 12.27 0.96
b'g1401298-341432' 210.37404 -34.2422 56.2 -23.01 0.51 10.74 3748 53.36 58.32 57.52 nan 12.28 1.04
b'g1406046-341837' 211.51935 -34.31018 56.2 -23.13 0.6 10.616 4491 63.9 58.32 57.52 nan 12.09 0.9
b'g1402332-332358' 210.63814 -33.39941 56.2 -23.96 0.61 9.787 4024 57.27 58.32 57.52 nan 12.1 0.93
b'g1403130-332128' 210.80423 -33.35777 56.2 -23.78 0.62 9.971 4612 65.61 58.32 57.52 nan 12.1 0.96
b'g1400472-341329' 210.19646 -34.22477 56.2 -23.67 0.63 10.077 3415 48.63 58.32 57.52 nan 12.1 0.99
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_5419' 210.91154 -33.97839 57.52 -26.31 0.0 7.492 4126 58.72 58.32 57.52 56.2 nan nan
b'MCG_-06-31-020' 211.14308 -33.96075 57.52 -23.93 0.19 9.871 3849 54.79 58.32 57.52 nan 13.43 1.54
b'g1402107-334727' 210.54469 -33.79072 57.52 -23.11 0.36 10.685 3900 55.51 58.32 57.52 nan 12.61 1.01
b'g1405115-334536' 211.29784 -33.76011 57.52 -23.55 0.39 10.253 4597 65.4 58.32 57.52 nan 12.54 1.08
b'g1401105-335645' 210.29359 -33.94582 57.52 -24.55 0.52 9.245 4078 58.04 58.32 57.52 nan 12.23 0.83
b'g1406070-335524' 211.52904 -33.92344 57.52 -23.86 0.52 9.941 4461 63.47 58.32 57.52 nan 12.26 0.93
b'g1401298-341432' 210.37404 -34.2422 57.52 -23.06 0.52 10.74 3748 53.36 58.32 57.52 nan 12.27 1.01
b'g1406046-341837' 211.51935 -34.31018 57.52 -23.18 0.61 10.616 4491 63.9 58.32 57.52 nan 12.08 0.87
b'g1402332-332358' 210.63814 -33.39941 57.52 -24.01 0.62 9.787 4024 57.27 58.32 57.52 nan 12.09 0.9
b'g1403130-332128' 210.80423 -33.35777 57.52 -23.83 0.63 9.971 4612 65.61 58.32 57.52 nan 12.09 0.93
b'g1400472-341329' 210.19646 -34.22477 57.52 -23.72 0.64 10.077 3415 48.63 58.32 57.52 nan 12.09 0.96
NGC5516
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_5516' 213.97789 -48.11485 58.4 -25.6 0.0 8.236 4123 58.68 63.24 63.24 58.4 nan nan
b'2MASX_J14160456-4807385' 214.019 -48.12731 58.4 -23.08 0.03 10.756 4170 59.34 63.24 63.24 nan 15.65 4.05
b'g1415271-475045' 213.86298 -47.84594 58.4 -23.19 0.29 10.646 4653 66.19 63.24 63.24 nan 12.64 1.31
b'ESO_221-_G_037' 214.54398 -48.01007 58.4 -24.99 0.4 8.845 4424 62.95 63.24 63.24 nan 12.39 1.06
b'g1414309-482654' 213.62859 -48.44835 58.4 -23.24 0.42 10.588 4570 65.02 63.24 63.24 nan 12.35 1.12
b'g1415457-473827' 213.94022 -47.64095 58.4 -23.74 0.48 10.089 4905 69.76 63.24 63.24 nan 12.2 1.03
b'ESO_222-_G_005' 216.67612 -49.67245 56.77 -24.09 2.87 9.683 3998 56.9 61.48 nan nan 9.92 -1.22
b'14324350-4857200' 218.18146 -48.95543 56.77 -23.04 3.34 10.735 4346 61.84 61.48 nan nan 9.74 -1.35
b'g1431546-460207' 217.97754 -46.03531 56.99 -23.24 3.73 10.54 4337 61.71 nan nan nan 9.62 -1.43
b'WKK_4079' 218.59334 -50.02032 56.77 -22.97 3.94 10.797 4436 63.12 61.48 nan nan 9.56 -1.46
b'g1351353-480136' 207.89694 -48.0266 58.49 -24.55 4.15 9.285 3620 51.54 63.33 63.34 nan 9.56 -1.48
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_5516' 213.97789 -48.11485 63.24 -25.77 0.0 8.236 4123 58.68 63.24 63.24 58.4 nan nan
b'2MASX_J14160456-4807385' 214.019 -48.12731 63.24 -23.25 0.03 10.756 4170 59.34 63.24 63.24 nan 15.61 3.95
b'g1415271-475045' 213.86298 -47.84594 63.24 -23.36 0.31 10.646 4653 66.19 63.24 63.24 nan 12.61 1.2
b'ESO_221-_G_037' 214.54398 -48.01007 63.24 -25.16 0.43 8.845 4424 62.95 63.24 63.24 nan 12.35 0.95
b'g1414309-482654' 213.62859 -48.44835 63.24 -23.42 0.45 10.588 4570 65.02 63.24 63.24 nan 12.32 1.02
b'g1415457-473827' 213.94022 -47.64095 63.24 -23.92 0.52 10.089 4905 69.76 63.24 63.24 nan 12.17 0.93
b'ESO_222-_G_005' 216.67612 -49.67245 61.48 -24.26 3.11 9.683 3998 56.9 61.48 nan nan 9.89 -1.32
b'14324350-4857200' 218.18146 -48.95543 61.48 -23.21 3.62 10.735 4346 61.84 61.48 nan nan 9.71 -1.45
b'g1431546-460207' 217.97754 -46.03531 61.71 -23.41 4.04 10.54 4337 61.71 nan nan nan 9.59 -1.54
b'WKK_4079' 218.59334 -50.02032 61.48 -23.15 4.27 10.797 4436 63.12 61.48 nan nan 9.53 -1.56
b'g1351353-480136' 207.89694 -48.0266 63.34 -24.72 4.49 9.285 3620 51.54 63.33 63.34 nan 9.52 -1.58
NGC6086
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_6086' 243.14809 29.4848 138.0 -25.74 0.0 9.96 9549 135.34 nan nan 138.0 nan nan
b'16123884+2938368' 243.1618 29.64351 138.97 -24.87 1.04 10.848 9617 136.29 nan nan nan 11.1 -0.67
b'16101693+2907328' 242.57056 29.12584 139.27 -24.27 1.97 11.448 9638 136.59 nan nan nan 10.34 -1.2
b'16140229+2829488' 243.50955 28.49684 138.88 -24.4 2.65 11.31 9610 136.2 nan nan nan 10.02 -1.42
b'16123406+2819082' 243.14192 28.31901 135.93 -23.99 3.47 11.673 9405 133.31 nan nan nan 9.71 -1.64
b'16103103+2729589' 242.62933 27.49959 137.98 -24.48 4.9 11.217 9548 135.32 nan nan nan 9.32 -1.99
b'KUG_1607+281' 242.40634 28.05188 142.06 -24.32 5.59 11.44 9832 139.32 nan nan nan 9.19 -2.09
b'16094306+3027094' 242.4294 30.45263 133.03 -24.51 5.66 11.113 9203 130.47 nan nan nan 9.22 -2.04
b'16124692+2759143' 243.19557 27.98734 142.98 -25.48 6.19 10.298 9896 140.22 nan nan nan 9.2 -2.09
b'16111411+2655242' 242.80879 26.92345 138.32 -25.43 6.23 10.274 9571 135.65 nan nan nan 9.27 -2.05
b'16094059+2700468' 242.41919 27.01299 136.32 -24.11 6.34 11.562 9432 133.69 nan nan nan 9.27 -2.03
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_6086' 243.14809 29.4848 135.34 -25.7 0.0 9.96 9549 135.34 nan nan 138.0 nan nan
b'16123884+2938368' 243.1618 29.64351 136.29 -24.82 1.02 10.848 9617 136.29 nan nan nan 11.11 -0.65
b'16101693+2907328' 242.57056 29.12584 136.59 -24.23 1.93 11.448 9638 136.59 nan nan nan 10.35 -1.18
b'16140229+2829488' 243.50955 28.49684 136.2 -24.36 2.6 11.31 9610 136.2 nan nan nan 10.03 -1.39
b'16123406+2819082' 243.14192 28.31901 133.31 -23.95 3.4 11.673 9405 133.31 nan nan nan 9.72 -1.61
b'16103103+2729589' 242.62933 27.49959 135.32 -24.44 4.81 11.217 9548 135.32 nan nan nan 9.33 -1.97
b'KUG_1607+281' 242.40634 28.05188 139.32 -24.28 5.48 11.44 9832 139.32 nan nan nan 9.2 -2.06
b'16094306+3027094' 242.4294 30.45263 130.47 -24.46 5.55 11.113 9203 130.47 nan nan nan 9.23 -2.01
b'16124692+2759143' 243.19557 27.98734 140.22 -25.44 6.07 10.298 9896 140.22 nan nan nan 9.21 -2.07
b'16111411+2655242' 242.80879 26.92345 135.65 -25.39 6.11 10.274 9571 135.65 nan nan nan 9.28 -2.03
b'16094059+2700468' 242.41919 27.01299 133.69 -24.07 6.22 11.562 9432 133.69 nan nan nan 9.28 -2.0
NGC7619
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_7619' 350.06049 8.20626 51.5 -25.56 0.0 8.004 3762 53.55 48.72 47.96 51.5 nan nan
b'NGC_7626' 350.17722 8.217 51.5 -25.55 0.11 8.007 3405 48.48 48.72 47.96 54.0 14.12 2.29
b'NGC_7623' 350.12491 8.39573 51.5 -24.12 0.18 9.438 3739 53.23 48.72 47.96 nan 13.49 1.89
b'NGC_7611' 349.9025 8.06324 51.5 -24.27 0.19 9.286 3252 46.31 48.72 47.96 nan 13.47 2.0
b'NGC_7631' 350.36115 8.21764 51.5 -23.66 0.27 9.898 3754 53.44 48.72 47.96 nan 13.07 1.69
b'NGC_7612' 349.93417 8.57639 51.5 -24.1 0.35 9.457 3213 45.76 48.72 47.96 nan 12.75 1.43
b'NGC_7634' 350.42401 8.88692 51.5 -23.97 0.69 9.594 3225 45.93 48.72 47.96 nan 11.92 0.64
b'CGCG_406-078' 350.30444 7.36643 51.5 -23.35 0.78 10.205 3075 43.8 48.72 47.96 nan 11.76 0.54
b'NGC_7648' 350.9751 9.66749 51.5 -23.88 1.55 9.681 3559 50.67 48.72 47.96 nan 10.9 -0.29
b'NGC_7562' 348.98959 6.68752 54.76 -25.41 3.69 8.287 3608 51.37 48.72 51.0 nan 9.86 -1.37
b'NGC_7518' 348.30304 6.32166 54.76 -23.66 4.04 10.028 3536 50.35 48.72 51.0 nan 9.76 -1.44
name ra dec d mk r k v dZ dCL dCH dSV nu_i rho_i
b'NGC_7619' 350.06049 8.20626 47.96 -25.4 0.0 8.004 3762 53.55 48.72 47.96 51.5 nan nan
b'NGC_7626' 350.17722 8.217 47.96 -25.4 0.1 8.007 3405 48.48 48.72 47.96 54.0 14.15 2.38
b'NGC_7623' 350.12491 8.39573 47.96 -23.97 0.17 9.438 3739 53.23 48.72 47.96 nan 13.52 1.99
b'NGC_7611' 349.9025 8.06324 47.96 -24.12 0.18 9.286 3252 46.31 48.72 47.96 nan 13.5 2.09
b'NGC_7631' 350.36115 8.21764 47.96 -23.51 0.25 9.898 3754 53.44 48.72 47.96 nan 13.1 1.79
b'NGC_7612' 349.93417 8.57639 47.96 -23.95 0.33 9.457 3213 45.76 48.72 47.96 nan 12.78 1.52
b'NGC_7634' 350.42401 8.88692 47.96 -23.81 0.64 9.594 3225 45.93 48.72 47.96 nan 11.95 0.74
b'CGCG_406-078' 350.30444 7.36643 47.96 -23.2 0.73 10.205 3075 43.8 48.72 47.96 nan 11.79 0.63
b'NGC_7648' 350.9751 9.66749 47.96 -23.72 1.44 9.681 3559 50.67 48.72 47.96 nan 10.93 -0.19
b'NGC_7562' 348.98959 6.68752 51.0 -25.25 3.44 8.287 3608 51.37 48.72 51.0 nan 9.89 -1.28
b'NGC_7518' 348.30304 6.32166 51.0 -23.51 3.76 10.028 3536 50.35 48.72 51.0 nan 9.79 -1.35
  • After rescaling the distances, my new nu10 values are quite close to Melanie's, differing by ~0.1 dex or so:

  • And here's the Mbh vs. Environment plot with these updated distances:

V(R, Theta) Plots

  • I ended up running Emily's V(R, Theta) fitting routine for a few choices of bins and with/without the Mitchell data included.
  • I'll begin just by summarizing results previously found for N57 from MASSIVE VII, X, and XIV:

    • 1+d_g = 2.3

    • nu_10 = 4.9

    • M_K = -25.75

    • PA_Kin_GMOS = 100 +/- 22

    • PA_Kin_mitchell = N/A

    • PA_Phot = 40.2 +/- 0.5

    • Psi = 59.3 +/- 22

    • Note that these values (for the angles) are more or less in agreement with what I am finding below for V(R, Theta) fitting.

Results considering only the GMOS data alone with a varied number of radial bins:
5 Bins 7 Bins 9 Bins 11 Bins
And a few examples of only using the Mitchell data:
2 Bins 4 Bins 6 Bins 8 Bins
And here's a case where I've included the Mitchell data as well -- didn't spend too long making this look too pretty because the bounds were a bit hard to get rid. I can return to this if we want Mitchell's V in our final plot.
Plot

Things Left to Do:

  • The only major open question is how thoroughly we want to test the impact on the parameters if we mask a few of the bins near the GMOS/Mitchell boundary. We noticed that there was a slight systematic shift between these data (notably in the sigma profiles), and we had suggested re-computing a subset of the models to test masking these.

  • Here are some details and diagnostics on the problematic bins:

First, here are some plots without any masks applied.
GMOS Bin Map Kinematic Maps One-sided radial plot Two-sided radial plot
And lastly, here's what I think ends up looking the best -- this has the GMOS corners masked, as well as the two additional bins along the perimeter. I also masked the two innermost Mitchell bins, and this GREATLY improves how the radial profiles appear.
GMOS Bin Map Kinematic Maps One-sided radial plot Two-sided radial plot
  • And here, for reference, are all models within certain chi2 cutoffs for us to decide what to quickly recompute for this test (if we want):
1sigma (139 models) 2sigma (768 models) 3sigma (1722 models) 4sigma (3048 models)
⚠️ **GitHub.com Fallback** ⚠️