meeting 2023 08 10 n57 - JacobPilawa/TriaxSchwarzschild_wiki_5 GitHub Wiki
Production Plots for N57 + Scaling Corrections + Misc. Diagnostics
Context
I've been putting together a set of final plots for the N57 paper. Many of them are currently in the Overleaf document, but I wanted to put them here as well for ease of access and discussion.
Diagnostics to Disucss
I got Emily's scaling procedure working and have a few diagnostic plots here -- in short, it doesn't seem like the scaled models are causing us any issue with regard to our bi-modal posterior, nor does it seem to be influencing the shape. Running through the scaling routine, we trim from 56,307 total models to ~5000 within a delta chi2 of 45 of the minimum, and the results taking the best scaled models agree with our naive results quite well. Note that these results still have the line of Lipka models, but I ran a test case without the Lipka results and nothing changed (plus, the Lipka models are only ~1% of the total number of models we have). Statistics from the Cube
Cube Name
N
min(x2)
N( < 1276.7 + 20)
N( < 1276.7 + 50)
N( < 1276.7 + 100)
n57
9710
1276.7
2211
4681
5629
cube_A1_s1p00
1000
1284.4
4
53
216
cube_A1_s0p90
1000
1294.9
1
41
137
cube_A1_s0p92
1000
1290.4
3
45
186
cube_A1_s0p93
1000
1289.4
5
46
219
cube_A1_s0p94
1000
1285.6
2
52
234
cube_A1_s0p97
1000
1289.4
4
55
224
cube_A1_s0p98
1000
1289.6
4
54
234
cube_A1_s1p02
1000
1290.4
2
47
223
cube_A1_s1p03
1000
1291.3
2
45
204
cube_A1_s1p05
1000
1292.4
1
53
197
cube_A1_s1p07
1000
1296.2
1
54
178
cube_A1_s1p08
1000
1290.8
1
50
166
cube_A1_s1p10
1000
1289.5
7
43
151
cube_A2_s1p00
998
1296.1
1
37
162
cube_A2_s0p90
1000
1291.2
2
41
183
cube_A2_s0p92
1000
1290.1
4
48
201
cube_A2_s0p93
1000
1292.3
4
44
194
cube_A2_s0p94
1000
1292.5
3
44
197
cube_A2_s0p97
1000
1293.5
1
39
201
cube_A2_s0p98
1000
1290.4
1
42
177
cube_A2_s1p02
1000
1287.8
1
35
149
cube_A2_s1p03
1000
1286.2
3
27
132
cube_A2_s1p05
1000
1287.7
2
22
105
cube_A2_s1p07
1000
1290.7
1
15
80
cube_A2_s1p08
1000
1300.1
0
8
62
cube_A2_s1p10
1000
1304.8
0
5
44
cube_B_s1p00
995
1281.9
155
975
995
cube_B_s0p90
991
1349.5
0
0
6
cube_B_s0p92
989
1315.1
0
2
98
cube_B_s0p93
995
1294.8
1
49
366
cube_B_s0p94
985
1285.0
17
235
750
cube_B_s0p97
994
1284.9
75
545
967
cube_B_s0p98
995
1282.3
145
913
995
cube_B_s1p02
995
1279.6
131
824
995
cube_B_s1p03
990
1282.2
67
512
940
cube_B_s1p05
995
1286.2
10
201
700
cube_B_s1p07
987
1301.5
0
45
349
cube_B_s1p08
992
1324.3
0
2
114
cube_B_s1p10
991
1355.9
0
0
14
cube_Bprime_s1p00
982
1281.4
167
937
980
cube_Bprime_s0p90
982
1372.5
0
0
1
cube_Bprime_s0p92
982
1336.3
0
0
45
cube_Bprime_s0p93
982
1313.1
0
17
330
cube_Bprime_s0p94
982
1292.6
4
180
775
cube_Bprime_s0p97
982
1283.7
41
523
979
cube_Bprime_s0p98
982
1281.6
137
897
982
cube_Bprime_s1p02
982
1283.7
130
853
971
cube_Bprime_s1p03
982
1285.7
43
510
947
cube_Bprime_s1p05
982
1291.3
6
169
726
cube_Bprime_s1p07
941
1304.8
0
25
323
cube_Bprime_s1p08
982
1326.0
0
1
87
cube_Bprime_s1p10
982
1357.7
0
0
5
cube_C_s1p00
1000
1279.4
414
994
1000
cube_C_s0p98
1000
1281.2
205
969
997
cube_C_s1p02
1000
1279.9
214
976
999
Lipka_s1p00
639
1287.2
25
192
393
cube_D_s1p00
994
1276.7
972
993
994
1d profiles
BH
ML
Rho
T
Tmaj
Tmin
Cornerplots for a few nu/few cutoff K
K=30
K=35
K=40
nu=0.5
nu=1.5
Slice plots for the cases above
K=30
K=35
K=40
nu=0.5
nu=1.5
I also did a bit of work comparing the deprojected luminosity densities for a few of the galaxies we have been working with so far. Here's that plot:
