5. CONCEPT SELECTION - J-division-2020-2021-even/Repo-17 GitHub Wiki
Weightage to Objective:-
SL.NO | Objective | Weightage |
---|---|---|
1 | Portable | 8 |
2 | Aesthetic | 7 |
3 | Easy to use | 6 |
4 | Use of standard parts | 5 |
5 | Lightweight | 3 |
6 | Battery | 2 |
A. PUGH CHART
SL.NO | Objective | Weightage | design 1 | design 2 | design 3 | design 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Portable | 8 | Datum | + | + | + |
2 | Aesthetic | 7 | Datum | + | + | ++ |
3 | Easy to use | 6 | Datum | + | - | ++ |
4 | Use of standard parts | 5 | Datum | - | + | + |
5 | Lightweight | 3 | Datum | -- | -- | + |
6 | Battery | 2 | Datum | -- | -- | - |
positive score | 21 | 20 | 41 | |||
negative score | 14 | 16 | 2 | |||
total score | 0 | 7 | 4 | 39 |
B. Justification
Design Idea | Objective | Score given | Justification |
---|---|---|---|
1 | Portable | Datum | It is portable. |
Aesthetic | Datum | It can be customized and good looking. | |
Easy to use | Datum | Easy for kids but can't be used for bulk. | |
Use of standard parts | Datum | It doesn't contain standard parts like motor. | |
Lightweight | Datum | It weighs less. | |
Battery | Datum | Uses less energy. | |
2 | Portable | + | It is portable |
Aesthetic | + | More aesthetic than datum design wise | |
Easy to use | + | EASY to be used by a freshie in tech field | |
Use of standard parts | - | few standard parts are used | |
Lightweight | -- | Heavy as many applications are present | |
Battery | -- | Consumes much energy as compared to datum | |
3 | Portable | + | It is portable due to wheels. |
Aesthetic | + | Can be customized with few designs only | |
Easy to use | - | Complicated to use by lay man | |
Use of standard parts | + | Some standard parts are used | |
Lightweight | -- | It is heavy as use of many tools | |
Battery | -- | uses much energy as compared to datum | |
4 | Portable | + | It is portable. |
Aesthetic | ++ | It can be customized with different designs. | |
Easy to use | ++ | Easy to use even for the common man with basic knowledge. | |
Use of standard parts | + | It contains standard parts. | |
Lightweight | + | It has more components to heavy more than datum. | |
Battery | - | Uses some energy. |
C. Selected design
Design 4
D. Product Architecture
D.1 Function Clustering:-
Subsystems
- Coin sorting subsystem
- Indication subsystem
- Collection and counting subsystem
D.1. Coin Sorting Subsystem
Coin sorting | Indication | Collection and counting |
---|---|---|
Material Interaction | Yes | Yes |
Data Interaction | Yes | Yes |
Spatial Interaction | Yes | Yes |
D.2. Indication Subsystem
Indication | Coin Sorting | Collection and Counting |
---|---|---|
Material Interaction | Yes | Yes |
Data Interaction | Yes | Yes |
Spatial Interaction | No | No |
D.3. Collection and Counting Subsystem
Collection and Counting | Indication | Coin Sorting |
---|---|---|
Material | Yes | Yes |
Data | Yes | Yes |
Spatial | Yes | Yes |