PUGH CHART - Gdiv-exploration/Repo_PHR_5 GitHub Wiki
Phase 2: Conceptual Design.
Design a device for a pharmacist which will fetch the medicines and help them save their time and minimize their work.
Below are the identified and prioritised objectives
-
Safety
-
Ease of use
-
Portability
-
Use of standard parts
-
Cost
Assign Weightage for the stated Objectives
Objectives | Weightage |
---|---|
Safety | 9 |
Ease of Use | 5 |
Portability | 3 |
Use of Standard Parts | 6 |
Cost | 7 |
PUGH Chart
Objectives | Design Idea 1 | Design Idea 2 | Design Idea 3 | Design Idea 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|
Safety | - | datum | + | - |
Ease of Use | + | datum | ++ | + |
Portability | ++ | datum | - | ++ |
Use of Standard Parts | + | datum | - | - |
Cost | + | datum | -- | + |
+Score | 24 | 0 | 19 | 18 |
-Score | -9 | 0 | -23 | -15 |
Total | 15 | 0 | -4 | 3 |
The Best Concept selected is Design Idea 1
Justification
Design Idea No | Objective | Score given | justification |
---|---|---|---|
1. | Safety | -9 | It is not safety to that extent because of its low quality sensor and its chocking parts. |
Ease of use | 5 | It is ease to use as there is not much of coding required in it. | |
Portability | 6 | The weight of this conceptual model is comparatively lesser than the datum. | |
Use of standard parts | 6 | All the parts are easily available in the market. | |
Cost | 7 | Its cost is not to high as that of datum and common people can afford it. | |
2. | Safety | Datum | - |
Ease of use | Datum | - | |
Portability | Datum | - | |
Use of standard parts | Datum | - | |
Cost | Datum | - | |
3. | Safety | 9 | It is safety because it is fixed properly in its assigned places. |
Ease of use | 10 | Ease to use because it almost performs most of its function and reduces manual work. | |
Portability | -3 | It is not portable because it is fixed in the shop. | |
Use of standard parts | -6 | Its parts are not easily available in the market. | |
Cost | -14 | Its cost is high as hydraulic are used in it. | |
4. | Safety | -9 | It is not that safety because of its low quality parts used in it. |
Ease of use | 5 | Ease to use as much maintenance is not required. | |
Portability | 6 | It is portable as it can taken from one place to another. | |
Use of standard parts | -6 | Its half of the parts are not easily available in the market. | |
Cost | 7 | It is of low cost as compared to datum. |