5. Concept Evaluation and product architecture - G-Division-2021-22-EVEN/Repo-10 GitHub Wiki
Assign weight to the objectives.
Objectives | Weights |
---|---|
Safety | 7 |
Poratability | 8 |
Cost | 7 |
Efficiency | 10 |
Pugh charts
Model Objectives | Weights | Design 1 | Design 2 | Design 3 | Design 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
SAFETY | 7 | DATUM | -- | - | + |
PORTABILITY | 8 | DATUM | - | - | + |
COST | 7 | DATUM | + | + | - |
EFFICIENCY | 10 | DATUM | + | + | ++ |
SCORE(+) | 0 | 17 | 17 | 35 | |
SCORE(-) | 0 | -22 | -15 | -7 | |
TOTAL | 0 | -5 | +2 | +28 |
JUSTIFCATION FOR SCORES GIVEN
MODEL OBJECTIVES | WEIGHTS | DESIGN 1 | DESIGN 2 | DESIGN 3 | DESIGN 4 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Safety | 7 | Datum | The blades are sharp | The front wedges are sharp | No sharp parts |
Portability | 8 | Datum | as the blades are out not so easy to carry | As the wedges are out | everything is inside |
Cost | 7 | Datum | as there are no costly parts | all the parts are easily available and cheap | the drum roller motor is a bit expensive as we need very high rpm motors. |
Efficiency | 10 | Datum | as the blades gent blunt overtime | Even though they are effective the vertical blades get blunt | the drum roller when touches the other bot it tosses them away and even damage there defensive mechanisum |
SELECTED DESIGN
DESIGN 4:
FUNCTION CLUSETERING
INTERACTION BETWEEN SUB SYSTEM
SUBSYSTEM
Sl no. | Subsystem |
---|---|
1 | Movement |
2 | Attacking |
3 | Alerting |
SUB SYSTEM INTERATION
Movement | Attacking | Alerting |
---|---|---|
Material | no | no |
Spatial | yes | no |
Data | no | yes |
Attacking | Alerting | Movement |
---|---|---|
Material | no | no |
Spatial | no | yes |
Data | yes | no |
Alerting | Movement | Attacking |
---|---|---|
Material | no | no |
Spatial | no | no |
Data | no | yes |