5. Concept Evaluation and product architecture - G-Division-2021-22-EVEN/Repo-10 GitHub Wiki

Assign weight to the objectives.

Objectives Weights
Safety 7
Poratability 8
Cost 7
Efficiency 10

Pugh charts

Model Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
SAFETY 7 DATUM -- - +
PORTABILITY 8 DATUM - - +
COST 7 DATUM + + -
EFFICIENCY 10 DATUM + + ++
SCORE(+) 0 17 17 35
SCORE(-) 0 -22 -15 -7
TOTAL 0 -5 +2 +28

JUSTIFCATION FOR SCORES GIVEN

MODEL OBJECTIVES WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 DESIGN 4
Safety 7 Datum The blades are sharp The front wedges are sharp No sharp parts
Portability 8 Datum as the blades are out not so easy to carry As the wedges are out everything is inside
Cost 7 Datum as there are no costly parts all the parts are easily available and cheap the drum roller motor is a bit expensive as we need very high rpm motors.
Efficiency 10 Datum as the blades gent blunt overtime Even though they are effective the vertical blades get blunt the drum roller when touches the other bot it tosses them away and even damage there defensive mechanisum

SELECTED DESIGN

DESIGN 4:

cbca7ac0-a788-4b96-869d-16383ae78ab9

FUNCTION CLUSETERING

image

INTERACTION BETWEEN SUB SYSTEM

SUBSYSTEM

Sl no. Subsystem
1 Movement
2 Attacking
3 Alerting

SUB SYSTEM INTERATION

Movement Attacking Alerting
Material no no
Spatial yes no
Data no yes
Attacking Alerting Movement
Material no no
Spatial no yes
Data yes no
Alerting Movement Attacking
Material no no
Spatial no no
Data no yes