wk - Daria-Maltseva/mixedmethods GitHub Wiki

Keywords analysis

Reduced network WK

WK

==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 1. C:\Mail.Ru Cloud\ANR HSE\ANR Projects\Mixed methods\Data\2019_FINAL DATASET_copy\WK.net [2-Mode] (563888)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 563888
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                405998              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines              30826              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=547407, Cols=16481
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00004500
Average Degree = 1.43999518

Simplification (multiple line - single line)

==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 2. Simplification (Single Line) of N1 (563888)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 563888
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                375172              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=547407, Cols=16481
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00004158
Average Degree = 1.33066141

DC partition - as 1st
Constant partition [1] of size 16481 - as 2nd
Fuse partitions
Operations -- Network + Partition -- Extract subnetwrk 1-*

==============================================================================
Extracting Subnetwork according to Partition
==============================================================================
 Time spent:  0:00:00

==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 3. Extracting N2 according to C3 [1-*] (34650)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 34650
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                375172              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=18169, Cols=16481
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00125290
Average Degree = 21.65494949

2-mode network - Partition into 2 modes
Binarize partition

==============================================================================
6. Binarized C5 [1] (34650)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 34650
The lowest value:  0
The highest value: 1

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         0     16481   47.5642     16481   47.5642 disclosure
         1     18169   52.4358     34650  100.0000 HILL_M(2018)34:71
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
       Sum     34650  100.0000

Input degree partition
Max of 2 partitions
Extract subnetwork
---> we did not need to do this, as the N of Keywords is the same (they exist only for hits) Saved as WKr

Indegree -- most used keywords

Based on Simplified network

==============================================================================
1. Input Degree of N2 (563888)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 563888
The lowest value:                         0.0000
The highest value:                     8367.0000

Highest values: 

      Rank    Vertex                       Value   Id
--------------------------------------------------------
         1    547444                   8367.0000   method
         2    547441                   8251.0000   mix
         3    547420                   5355.0000   health
         4    547528                   4592.0000   study
         5    547428                   4447.0000   care
         6    547418                   3743.0000   research
         7    547531                   2756.0000   education
         8    547539                   2190.0000   student
         9    547454                   2079.0000   intervention
        10    547735                   2054.0000   use
        11    547574                   2012.0000   patient
        12    547424                   1957.0000   social
        13    547662                   1950.0000   management
        14    547439                   1881.0000   qualitative
        15    547413                   1873.0000   service
        16    547544                   1835.0000   experience
        17    547499                   1814.0000   quality
        18    547540                   1783.0000   child
        19    547522                   1740.0000   community
        20    547520                   1639.0000   practice
        21    547742                   1602.0000   trial
        22    547737                   1572.0000   program
        23    547605                   1569.0000   life
        24    547578                   1561.0000   base
        25    547525                   1550.0000   analysis
        26    547734                   1546.0000   impact
        27    547527                   1487.0000   model
        28    547595                   1484.0000   perception
        29    547690                   1450.0000   development
        30    547489                   1431.0000   evaluation
        31    547602                   1377.0000   behavior
        32    547517                   1331.0000   self
        33    547849                   1315.0000   school
        34    547722                   1288.0000   approach
        35    547487                   1280.0000   risk
        36    547551                   1273.0000   perspective
        37    547771                   1269.0000   outcome
        38    547422                   1261.0000   woman
        39    547608                   1222.0000   people
        40    547416                   1209.0000   support
        41    547826                   1185.0000   control
        42    547526                   1168.0000   learn
        43    547472                   1166.0000   knowledge
        44    547841                   1152.0000   design
        45    547558                   1143.0000   adult
        46    547947                   1104.0000   family
        47    547470                   1104.0000   mental
        48    547566                   1025.0000   attitude
        49    548032                    993.0000   clinical
        50    548036                    980.0000   teacher
--------------------------------------------------------
Sum (all values):                    375172.0000

Indegree distribution in R

setwd("C:/Mail.Ru Cloud/ANR HSE/ANR Projects/Mixed methods/Analysis/Keywords")

number<-read.table(file="WKr_Indegree.vec", sep=",", header=FALSE, skip=1)
t<-table(number)
head(t)
t
length (t)
names(t)
articles <- as.integer(names(t))
typeof(articles)
length(articles)
x <- articles[2:450]
y <- as.vector(t[2:450])
              ### xt <- c(1,5,10,50,100,500, 1000, 2000, 2500)
               plot (x,y,log="xy",pch=16, xlab="N of works", ylab="N of keywords", main="N of works per keyword")
               axis(side=1,at=xt, labels=xt)

Saved plot in the folder

Partition by Indegree

==============================================================================
14. Extracting from C9 vertices determined by C13 [1-*] (16481)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 16481
The lowest value:     1
The highest value: 8367

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         1      7695   46.6901      7695   46.6901       196
         2      2069   12.5538      9764   59.2440       226
         3      1112    6.7472     10876   65.9911        67
         4       703    4.2655     11579   70.2567       146
         5       495    3.0035     12074   73.2601       128
         6       366    2.2207     12440   75.4809       200
         7       312    1.8931     12752   77.3739       170
         8       260    1.5776     13012   78.9515       224
         9       220    1.3349     13232   80.2864       209
        10       206    1.2499     13438   81.5363       390
        11       153    0.9283     13591   82.4647        30
        12       132    0.8009     13723   83.2656       179
        13       118    0.7160     13841   83.9816        33
        14       108    0.6553     13949   84.6369        45
        15        92    0.5582     14041   85.1951        31
        16        86    0.5218     14127   85.7169        35
        17        76    0.4611     14203   86.1780       237
        18        85    0.5157     14288   86.6938       301
        19        65    0.3944     14353   87.0882       584
        20        61    0.3701     14414   87.4583        81
        21        57    0.3459     14471   87.8041       238
        22        58    0.3519     14529   88.1561       692
        23        43    0.2609     14572   88.4170       723
        24        38    0.2306     14610   88.6475       325
        25        38    0.2306     14648   88.8781       940
        26        41    0.2488     14689   89.1269       230
        27        41    0.2488     14730   89.3756       181
        28        37    0.2245     14767   89.6001        58
        29        39    0.2366     14806   89.8368       176
        30        43    0.2609     14849   90.0977       223

This means that 46.7% of words are presented only once, 12.5% -- twice, etc... In general, 90% of keywords are presented only in 30 journals (= 30 times).

Networks of keywords co-occurence

Regular

WKr
Transpose, choose as 1st netw
WKr - choose as 2nd
Multiply
KK

==============================================================================
5. KK (16481)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 16481
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1        1920983              0
Number of lines with value#1         897430              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines               2818413              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                       16481              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

Density [loops allowed] = 0.01037618
Average Degree = 342.01965900

Get loops --- Remove loops ---> KKc
Arcs to Edges, Bidirected only, MIN ---> KK_clean

==============================================================================
7. Bidirected Arcs to Edges (MIN) of N6 (16481)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 16481
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1              0         956644
Number of lines with value#1              0         444322
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                     0        1400966
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

Density1 [loops allowed]    = 0.01031550
Density2 [no loops allowed] = 0.01031613
Average Degree = 170.00982950

Islands [2, 50]: pairs of nodes + 50; [2, 100]: pairs of nodes + 100
[5,100]: 1 island of 100 nodes
Link cut:
Remove lines with values lower then (600) = 38 nodes
(411) = 76 nodes
(400) = 78 nodes (350) = 92 nodes

Remove mix and method(34, 37) Islands [5,100] = 99 nodes
Link cut: (350) = 77 nodes (300) = 95 nodes

Normalized

WKr 2-Mode Network: Rows=18169, Cols=16481 Play macro norm2.mcr (18169)

Normalized network -- Transpose 2-mode -- Choose it as 1st
Normalized - as 2nd
Multiply KKnorm network

==============================================================================
19. KK_norm (16481)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 16481
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1              0              0
Number of lines with value#1        2818413              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines               2818413              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                       16481              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

Density [loops allowed] = 0.01037618
Average Degree = 342.01965900

Arcs to Edges --> Bidirected only - MIN
Loops - Get loops - Remove loops
21. KK_norm_clean no loops (16481)

Line cut: 1.7 = 30, 1 = 66, 0.85 = 82 nodes Islands: [2, 200] = 1 island of 200 nodes, several -- of 3 nodes, a lot -- of 2 nodes; [5,200] = 1 island of 200 nodes. [5,100] = 1 island of 100 (saved as KK_norm_(100 nodes))

Then tried: mix and method = 34 and 37 -- delete the line (still 1 island of 200)
mix and method = 34 and 37 -- remove the nodes (still 1 island of 200)
[5,100]: 1 island of 100 nodes

Newman normalized

WKr play macro2p.mcr (Newmans normalization) [18169] - number of works

  1. Normalized network N (previous) -- Transposed
  2. Newman normalized network N' Multiply
    KK_norm_newman
==============================================================================
40. KK_norm_newman (16481)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 16481
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1              0              0
Number of lines with value#1        2818413              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines               2818413              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                       16481              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

Density [loops allowed] = 0.01037618
Average Degree = 342.01965900

Remove loops Arcs to Edges - Bidirected - SUM KK_norm_newman_clean

==============================================================================
42. KK_norm_newman_clean (16481)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 16481
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1              0              0
Number of lines with value#1              0        1400966
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                     0        1400966
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

Density1 [loops allowed]    = 0.01031550
Density2 [no loops allowed] = 0.01031613
Average Degree = 170.00982950

line cut: Islands: [2,200]: 81 island, 1 of 3, 1 of 200, others of 2; [5,75]: 1 of 75 [5,100] = 1 island of 100 nodes (saved as KK_norm_newman(100 nodes))


Try to remove mix and method

==============================================================================
45. Removing vertices [34,37] from N42 (16479)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 16479

Islands: [2,200]: 2, 3, and 200; [5,100]: 1 island of 100 (saved as KK_norm_newman_w34-37(100 nodes))

!!! I guess, for now this is the best results are without mix and method in both normalized networks.

Keywords for Journals

Network construction

reduced networks nJWr x nWKr = JK

==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 74. C:\Mail.Ru Cloud\ANR HSE\ANR Projects\Mixed methods\Data\2019_FINAL DATASET_copy\WJsr.net [2-Mode] (22305)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 22305
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                 17882              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=18169, Cols=4136
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00023796
Average Degree = 1.60340731
==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 3. WKr (34650)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 34650
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                375172              0
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=18169, Cols=16481
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00125290
Average Degree = 21.65494949

Normalized both with norm2.mcr (choose number of rows = 18169) Transposed WJr_N' - as 1st WKr_N - as 2nd Multiply JK

==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 78. JK (20617)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 20617
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1              0              0
Number of lines with value#1              0         251684
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                     0         251684
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=4136, Cols=16481
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00369225
Average Degree = 24.41519135

Shrinking journals

BMJ Open - 2003
BRIT MED J - 111
BMJ-BRIT MED J - 684 

Cluster - Create empty cluster
Open - Add vertexes (enter the numbers)
Cluster - Make partition [dimention - number of journals 4136]

==============================================================================
80. From Cluster 1 (4136)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 4136
The lowest value:  0
The highest value: 1

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         0      4133   99.9275      4133   99.9275         1
         1         3    0.0725      4136  100.0000       111
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
       Sum      4136  100.0000

Create Constant partition (16481)
From Cluster - as 1st
Constant (16481) - as 2nd
Fuse partitions

==============================================================================
88. Fusion of C80 and C81 (20617)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 20617
The lowest value:  0
The highest value: 2

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         0      4133   20.0466      4133   20.0466 J ASSOC NURSE AIDS C
         1         3    0.0146      4136   20.0611 BRIT MED J
         2     16481   79.9389     20617  100.0000 disclosure
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
       Sum     20617  100.0000

Binarize partition (1)

==============================================================================
89. Binarized C88 [1] (20617)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 20617
The lowest value:  0
The highest value: 1

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         0     20614   99.9854     20614   99.9854 J ASSOC NURSE AIDS C
         1         3    0.0146     20617  100.0000 BRIT MED J
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
       Sum     20617  100.0000

Operations - Network + Partition - Shrink network Save as JKs

==============================================================================
Info on 2-Mode Network 80. Shrinking N78 according to C89 [1,0] (20615)
==============================================================================
Number of vertices (n): 20615
----------------------------------------------------------
                                       Arcs          Edges
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of lines with value=1              0              0
Number of lines with value#1              0         251588
----------------------------------------------------------
Total number of lines                     0         251588
----------------------------------------------------------
Number of loops                           0              0
Number of multiple lines                  0              0
----------------------------------------------------------

2-Mode Network: Rows=4134, Cols=16481
Density [2-Mode] = 0.00369263
Average Degree = 24.40824642

Number of keywords by journals

All degree

==============================================================================
60. Extracting from V59 vertices determined by C99 [1] (4134)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 4134
The lowest value:                         3.0000
The highest value:                     1797.0000

Highest values: 

      Rank    Vertex                       Value   Id
--------------------------------------------------------
         1         1                   1797.0000   #BRIT MED J
         2      1080                   1602.0000   PLOS ONE
         3       682                   1581.0000   BMC PUBLIC HEALTH
         4        24                   1503.0000   J MIX METHOD RES
         5       670                   1441.0000   BMC HEALTH SERV RES
         6       623                   1128.0000   IMPLEMENT SCI
         7         8                   1084.0000   SOC SCI MED
         8        18                    960.0000   J ADV NURS
         9      1439                    917.0000   TRIALS
        10       406                    817.0000   J CLIN NURS
        11       733                    662.0000   BMC MED EDUC
        12       385                    647.0000   CHILD YOUTH SERV REV
        13       155                    636.0000   INT J NURS STUD
        14         6                    616.0000   QUAL HEALTH RES
        15      1355                    612.0000   BMC PREGNANCY CHILDB
        16       898                    594.0000   J MED INTERNET RES
        17       288                    594.0000   NURS EDUC TODAY
        18       295                    586.0000   INT J ENV RES PUB HE
        19        32                    566.0000   PATIENT EDUC COUNS
        20      2046                    551.0000   JMIR RES PROTOC
        21       815                    542.0000   BMC FAM PRACT
        22       763                    542.0000   DISABIL REHABIL
        23       414                    537.0000   EVAL PROGRAM PLANN
        24        29                    520.0000   MIDWIFERY
        25       230                    518.0000   PROCD SOC BEHV
        26         9                    509.0000   INT J QUAL METH
        27        10                    499.0000   AIDS BEHAV
        28      1920                    492.0000   BMC MED INFORM DECIS
        29       656                    487.0000   FRONT PSYCHOL
        30       689                    468.0000   QUAL QUANT
--------------------------------------------------------
Sum (all values):                    251588.0000

Weighted alldegree

==============================================================================
62. Extracting from V61 vertices determined by C99 [1] (4134)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 4134
The lowest value:                         1.0175
The highest value:                      318.1206

Highest values: 

      Rank    Vertex                       Value   Id
--------------------------------------------------------
         1        24                    318.1206   J MIX METHOD RES
         2         1                    317.4989   #BRIT MED J
         3       670                    256.1339   BMC HEALTH SERV RES
         4       682                    218.1072   BMC PUBLIC HEALTH
         5      1080                    218.0348   PLOS ONE
         6       623                    173.1644   IMPLEMENT SCI
         7        18                    127.0618   J ADV NURS
         8       406                    101.9277   J CLIN NURS
         9         8                     96.9419   SOC SCI MED
        10       288                     92.0060   NURS EDUC TODAY
        11      1439                     87.4723   TRIALS
        12       733                     86.9443   BMC MED EDUC
        13       230                     83.4014   PROCD SOC BEHV
        14       246                     79.9542   GERONTOLOGIST
        15         9                     77.6766   INT J QUAL METH
        16       385                     75.9115   CHILD YOUTH SERV REV
        17       155                     62.6002   INT J NURS STUD
        18      1355                     61.5273   BMC PREGNANCY CHILDB
        19       742                     60.3352   J INTERPROF CARE
        20       363                     60.1768   J GEN INTERN MED
        21         6                     58.9148   QUAL HEALTH RES
        22       847                     58.1027   QUAL LIFE RES
        23       898                     56.9929   J MED INTERNET RES
        24       414                     56.0317   EVAL PROGRAM PLANN
        25        29                     54.5038   MIDWIFERY
        26       449                     52.2991   MED TEACH
        27       815                     51.1999   BMC FAM PRACT
        28       763                     50.1726   DISABIL REHABIL
        29       689                     50.0764   QUAL QUANT
        30      3579                     49.6821   EDULEARN PROC
--------------------------------------------------------
Sum (all values):                     18977.1696

Keywords in selected journals

#BRIT MED J  - 1
J MIX METHOD RES - 24

BRIT MED J

Partition - Create identity partition [4134] Partition - Binarize Partition

==============================================================================
92. Binarized C91 [1] (4134)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 4134
The lowest value:  0
The highest value: 1

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         0      4133   99.9758      4133   99.9758         2
         1         1    0.0242      4134  100.0000         1
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
       Sum      4134  100.0000

Constant partiton (16481)
Binarized - 1st
Constant - 2nd
Fuse patitions

==============================================================================
94. Fusion of C92 and C93 (20615)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 20615
The lowest value:  0
The highest value: 2

Frequency distribution of cluster values:

   Cluster      Freq     Freq%   CumFreq  CumFreq% Representative
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
         0      4133   20.0485      4133   20.0485 J ASSOC NURSE AIDS C
         1         1    0.0049      4134   20.0534 #BRIT MED J
         2     16481   79.9466     20615  100.0000 disclosure
 ----------------------------------------------------------------
       Sum     20615  100.0000

Select JK network
Operations - Extract 1-* (this network should be used later)

2-Mode Network: Rows=1, Cols=16481

Compute WEIGHTED indegree vector Input WEIGHTED degree vector Partition Vecor+Partition - Extract SubVector (take out) 2

To get labels we need to complete this with vector:
Constant vector of 0 of set J (1) (size of cluster that we search for)
Constant vector
Extracted vector
Fuse vectors

Vector - Info - we can see the labels (most important keywords for certain island)

==============================================================================
53. Fusion of V52 and V50 (16482)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 16482
The lowest value:                         0.0000
The highest value:                        9.0936

Highest values: 

      Rank    Vertex                       Value   Id
--------------------------------------------------------
         1       122                      9.0936   study
         2        38                      9.0127   method
         3        35                      8.8776   mix
         4        22                      7.3525   care
         5        14                      6.4885   health
         6       868                      5.8097   protocol
         7        48                      3.7177   intervention
         8       168                      3.7088   patient
         9         7                      2.9596   service
        10       336                      2.8957   trial
        11        83                      2.7150   evaluation
        12        93                      2.7145   quality
        13        12                      2.7037   research
        14        33                      2.5567   qualitative
        15       420                      2.2863   control
        16       612                      2.2475   primary
        17       202                      2.2190   people
        18       199                      2.0268   life
        19       256                      1.8090   management
        20       249                      1.6371   disease
        21       328                      1.5629   impact
        22       175                      1.4850   medical
        23       116                      1.4658   community
        24       847                      1.2789   randomize
        25       114                      1.2766   practice
        26       329                      1.2694   use
        27        81                      1.2665   risk
        28       365                      1.2470   outcome
        29       138                      1.1588   experience
        30        94                      1.1466   improve
        31       404                      1.1429   general
        32       172                      1.1292   base
        33        50                      1.1061   framework
        34       163                      1.0920   hospital
        35       335                      1.0825   older
        36       694                      1.0584   implementation
        37        96                      1.0560   cancer
        38       125                      1.0407   education
        39       141                      1.0339   programme
        40      1049                      1.0261   complex
        41       152                      1.0108   adult
        42       111                      1.0093   self
        43       875                      0.9744   medicine
        44        56                      0.9581   review
        45      1113                      0.9573   healthcare
        46       626                      0.9551   clinical
        47      1937                      0.9513   randomise
        48       331                      0.9267   program
        49        73                      0.9208   barrier
        50       196                      0.9116   behavior
--------------------------------------------------------
Sum (all values):                       317.4989

J MIXED METHOD RES

==============================================================================
57. Fusion of V56 and V55 (16482)
==============================================================================
Dimension: 16482
The lowest value:                         0.0000
The highest value:                       26.1268

Highest values: 

      Rank    Vertex                       Value   Id
--------------------------------------------------------
         1        35                     26.1268   mix
         2        38                     25.7109   method
         3        12                     16.7288   research
         4        33                      4.3570   qualitative
         5       122                      3.6796   study
         6      1774                      3.0256   paradigm
         7        14                      2.8627   health
         8        18                      2.8024   social
         9       119                      2.6315   analysis
        10       435                      2.3995   design
        11       965                      2.3764   quantitative
        12       316                      2.2436   approach
        13       115                      2.2134   datum
        14       554                      2.1487   methodology
        15       329                      2.0694   use
        16      3131                      2.0116   triangulation
        17       284                      1.7424   development
        18       559                      1.5145   integration
        19       125                      1.4855   education
        20       280                      1.3680   science
        21       377                      1.3615   theory
        22       186                      1.3438   new
        23       116                      1.2998   community
        24      2798                      1.2993   pragmatism
        25        83                      1.2569   evaluation
        26       114                      1.2062   practice
        27       133                      1.1931   student
        28       145                      1.1611   perspective
        29        87                      1.1580   strategy
        30       802                      1.1573   methodological
        31        22                      1.1275   care
        32         7                      1.1206   service
        33       355                      1.1150   validation
        34        66                      1.0687   knowledge
        35       121                      1.0591   model
        36       194                      1.0416   group
        37       441                      1.0356   integrate
        38      1162                      1.0160   validity
        39        48                      1.0159   intervention
        40      1322                      1.0055   future
        41       196                      0.9938   behavior
        42        13                      0.9569   state
        43       471                      0.9562   case
        44       410                      0.9430   field
        45        50                      0.9003   framework
        46       221                      0.8877   inquiry
        47       331                      0.8811   program
        48        71                      0.8107   issue
        49       443                      0.8027   school
        50       111                      0.7689   self
--------------------------------------------------------
Sum (all values):                       318.1206