5 . CONCEPT SELECTION AND PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE - D-Div-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-10 GitHub Wiki

5.1 Assign weights to the objectives

SL.NO OBJECTIVES WEIGHTS
01 sow for small farm 7
02 kept as it is 5
03 corrosion resistance 8
04 should not be attractive 6
05 Cost 4
06 It can be any color and light weighted 7
07 Safety 9
08 Ease to use 7

5.2 Pugh chart

DESIGN OBJECTIVE WEIGHTS DESIGN 1 DESIGN 2 DESIGN 3 DESIGN 4 DESIGN 5
sow for small farm 7 + + datum + ++
kept as it is 5 + ++ datum + +
corrosion resistance 6 ++ + datum + +
should not be attractive 5 + + datum ++ +
Cost 4 + - datum - -
It can be any colour and light weighted 7 + + datum + +
Safety 9 + + datum + ++
Ease to use 7 - + datum + +
Score(+) 49 48 0 48 62
Score(-) -7 -4 0 -4 -4
Total 42 44 0 44 58

5.3 Justification for giving score to the selected design:

  • selected design- Design5
design.no Objective Score alloted Justification for score
5 Sow for small farm 14 It should be used to sow for small farm
Kept as it is 10 should not be foldable and kept as it is
corrosion resistance 6 Model should be corrosion resistance to prevent operation malfunctions
Should not be attractive 5 The model should not be attractive so that it is far from children
Cost -4 cost effective for easy access of every individual
any colour and light weighted 7 The model can be in any colour and easily portable
safety 18 Parts used does not effect anyone
Ease to use 7 It's quite easy to use

PRODUCT ARCHITECTURE

5.4 Functional Clustering

image

5.5 Subsytem List:

SL.NO SUBSYSTEM
01 Sowing
02 Indication
03 Movement

5.6 Interaction Details:

SOWING INDICATION MOVEMENT
spatial - *
Data * -
Material - -
INDICATION SOWING MOVEMENT
Spatial - *
Data * *
Material - *
MOVEMENT SOWING INDICATION
Spatial * -
Data - *
Material - -