5.Concept Selection and Product Architecture - C-division-2021-2022-odd/Repo-14 GitHub Wiki

5.1 Assign weights to the objectives

Sl. no. Objectives Weights
1. Ease of use 8
2. Safety 3
3. User friendly 6
4. Model should be of low maintenance 5
5. Budget 7
6. Portability 4

5.2 PUGH Chart

Design Objectives Weights Design1 Design2 Design3 Design4
Ease of use 8 Datum - ++ --
Safety 3 Datum ++ + -
User friendly 6 Datum ++ + -
Model should be of low maintenance 5 Datum -- - -
Budget 7 Datum -- + +
Portability 4 Datum + + -
Score(+) 0 22
Score(-) 0 32
Total 0 -10 14

5.3 Justification For the scores given

Sl. no. Design name Objective Score allocated Justification for the score
1. Design 1 Ease of use Datum difficult to use
Safety Datum safe to use
User friendly Datum ------
Model should be of low maintenance Datum easy maintainence
Budget Datum feasible within the price range
Portability Datum can be moved in any type of soil
2. Design 2 Ease of use -8 light weight
Safety 6 safe to use
User friendly 12 economical
Model should be of low maintenance -10 belt is difficult to maintain
Budget -14 in budjet
Portability 4 easy to lift and shift anywhere
3. Deisgn 3 Ease of use 16 easy to handle
Safety -3 safe usage
User friendly 6 economical
Model should be of low maintenance 5 maintainenece is low
Budget -14 economical
Portability 4 low weight
4. Design 4 Ease of use 3 easy to handle
Safety -2 safe to use
User friendly 4 economical
Model should be of low mainteenance 3 less required
Budget -3 affordable within range
Portability 6 is portable

5.4 Selected Design: Design 3

3ab97d78-dc99-425f-9aae-e8414610886e_IMG_20220120_082050 IMG-20220120-WA0042 WhatsApp Image 2022-01-13 at 1 35 53 PM

5.5 Functional Clustering

Screenshot (30)

5.6 Subsystem List

Sl.No. Subsystem
1. Bot movement
2. sowing
3. Alerting

5.7 Interaction Details

Movement sowing Alert
Spatial yes yes
Data - -
Material - -
sowing Alert Movement
Spatial yes yes
Data - -
Material - -
alert Movement sowing
Spatial yes yes
Data - yes
Material - -