4. .Concept Selection and Product Architecture - C-division-2021-2022-odd/Repo-07 GitHub Wiki

4.1 Assign weights to the objectives

Sl No. Objectives Weights
1. it should stack domino one after the other 8
2. the domino lego should stack in any pattern 5
3. it should run medium fast 4
4. its dimensions should be not too large 3
5. it should be easy to use 6
6. it should have visible refill for the machine 2
7. it should have manual refill option 7
8. it should have remote control system 9

4.2 PUGH CHART

Slno. Design objectives Weights Flat lego stacking machine One after one lego stacking machine Adjacent stacking
1 it should stack domino one after the other 8 Datum ++ ++
2 the domino lego should stack in any pattern 5 Datum - +
3 it should run medium fast 4 Datum + ++
4 its dimensions should be not too large 3 Datum + +
5 it should be easy to use 6 Datum + ++
6 it should have visible refill for the machine 2 Datum ++ +
7 it should have manual refill option 7 Datum + ++
8 it should have remote control system 9 Datum + ++
9 Score(+) -- 0 49 78
10 Score(-) -- 0 -5 0
11 Total -- 00 44 78

Justification for the scores given

Slno. Design name Objective Score allocated Justification for the score
(A)1 flat lego stacking machine it should domino one after the other datum ________________
2 ----- the domino lego should stack in any pattern Datum _________________
3 ----- it should run medium fast Datum _____________
4 ----- its dimensions should be not too large Datum ___________
5 ----- it should be easy to use Datum _________
6 ----- its should have visible refill for the machine Datum ________
7 ----- it should have manual refill option Datum ________
8 ----- it should have remote control system Datum ________
(B)1 ----- one after the other domino lego machine 14 it properly stacks the domino one after the other
2 ---- the domino lego should stack in any pattern -6 it cant stack domino in any pattern
3 ----- it should run medium fast 5 it can run medium fast as we have controller
4 ------ its dimensions should be not too large 4 its dimensions are bit large bcoz of its storage capacitor
5 ------- it should be easy to use 10 it is easy to control
6 ------ its should have visible refill for the machine 16 it has a refill visible in the top
7 ------ it should have manual refill option 9 we can easily refill manually
8 ------- it should have remote control system 3 its remote control costs expensive
(c)1 Adjacent stacking one after the other domino lego machine 16 it stacks adjacently with equal distances between them
2 ---- the domino lego should stack in any pattern 5 it can stack in geometric shapes
3 ----- it should run medium fast 8 it is medium fast favourable machine
4 ------ its dimensions should be not too large 3 it quiety handy and less in size
5 ------- it should be easy to use 12 it is too easy to use
6 ------ its should have visible refill for the machine 2 it has semi visible refil capacity
7 ------ it should have manual refill option 14 it is manually loaded
8 ------- it should have remote control system 18 it is only controlled by RC

Selected Design : Adjacent Stacking

4.5 Subsystem list

SI NO Subsystem
01 Accept the start command
02 Loading of the lego-dominos
03 selecting the direction
04 Turn off the machine

4.6 Interaction Details

Accept the start command Loading of the lego dominos selecting the direction turn of the machine
spatial no no no
data no yes yes
material no no no
Loading of the lego dominos Accept the start command selecting the direction turn of the machine
spatial no no no
data yes yes yes
material no no no
selecting the direction turn of the machine Accept the start command Loading of the lego dominos
spatial no no no
data yes yes no
material no no no
turn of the machine Loading of the lego dominos Accept the start command selecting the direction
spatial no no no
data no yes yes
material no no no