5. Concept Selection and Product Architecture - C-Division-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-11 GitHub Wiki

5.1 Prioritized Objectives

Objectives Weightage
Ease of use 7
Portability 6
Automatic/Manual 8
Cost 6

5.2 Pugh Chart

Design Objectives Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
Ease of use 7 Datum PP P P
Portability 6 Datum P P P
Automatic/Manual 8 Datum P P P
Cost 6 Datum P N PP
Score (+) 0 39 31 38
Score (-) 0 0 -6 0
Total 0 39 25 38

5.3 Justification

Design Objectives Score Given Justification
1. Ease of use 0 Datum
Portability 0 Datum
Automatic/Manual 0 Datum
Cost 0 Datum
2. Ease of use 14 It is easy to use
Portability 6 It is easy to carry
Automatic/Manual 8 It is automatic
Cost 18 Cost is less
3. Ease of use 7 It is quite difficult to use
Portability 6 It is difficult to carry
Automatic/Manual 8 It is automatic
Cost -6 It is more expensive compared to datum
4. Ease of use 7 It is quite difficult to use
Portability 6 It is difficult to carry
Automatic/Manual 8 It is automatic
Cost 12 It is bit expensive compared to datum

5.4 Selected design

image

5.5 Function Clustering

image

5.6 Subsystem

Subsystems identified were:

1.Notification Unit

2.User Input

3.Evaluation Unit

Notification Unit With User Input With Evaluation Unit
Material Interaction -
Data Interaction -
Spatial Interaction -
User Input With Evaluation Unit With Notification Unit
Material Interaction -
Data Interaction
Spatial Interaction -
Evaluation Unit With Notification Unit With User Input
Material Interaction - -
Data Interaction -
Spatial Interaction - -

5.7 Interaction Details