5.Concept selection and product architecture - B-Division-2022-2023-Odd/Repo-02 GitHub Wiki

5.1 Assign weights to the objectives

Sl. No. Objectives Weights
1 The model should be automatic 8
2 The model should be rectangle in shape 5
3 The model should be attractive 6

5.2 PUGH Chart

Design Objective Weights Design 1 Design 2 Design 3 Design 4
Model should be automatic 8 ++ + + DATUM
Model should be rectangular in shape 5 + - + DATUM
Model should be attractive 6 + ++ + DATUM
Score(+) 43 29 26 0
Score(-) 0 12 14 0
Total 43 17 12 0

5.3 Justification for giving score to the selected design:-

Design No. Objective Score allotted Justification for score
1 Model should be automatic 8 Single input
2 model should be child friendly 9 Rounded edges and all child friendly
3 Model should be rectangular in shape 5 Casing depicts a rectangle
4 Model should be attractive 6 Attractive design
5 Model should be portable 7 Light weight so children can move it easily

5.4 Selected Design

IMG_20221224_134458 (1)

4.2

5.5 Function tree

FLOWCHART

5.6 Subsystem Unit

Sl. No. Sub system
1 Managing of coins
2 Managing of devil
3 indication
4 Casing

5.7 Interaction Details

MOVING UNIT INDICATION UNIT HANDLING COINS CASING UNIT
Spatial no yes no
Data yes no yes
Material yes yes yes
INDICATION UNIT MOVING UNIT HANDLING COINS CASING UNIT
Spatial no yes yes
Data yes yes yes
Material yes yes no
HANDLING COINS INDICATION UNIT MOVING UNIT CASING UNIT
Spatial yes no no
Data no yes yes
Material no yes yes
CASING UNIT MOVING UNIT INDICATION UNIT HANDLING COINS
Spatial yes yes no
Data yes yes no
Material yes no yes